Blueprint to Close the Women%E2%80%99s Health Gap 2025
Page 42 of 62 · WEF_Blueprint_to_Close_the_Women%E2%80%99s_Health_Gap_2025.pdf
2.3.2 Metric 5:
Assets in the pipeline
Definition: Assessment of innovative assets relative
to burden for conditions
Source: Pharmaprojects, IHME
Period: April 2023–June 2024
Assets in the pipeline for women’s health
conditions – pharmaceutical assets in clinical trials
in progress from preclinical to Phase 3 – can be
an indicator of where pharmaceutical companies
and researchers are focusing efforts for treatments
and medical interventions. These assets were
assessed by the McKinsey Health Institute (MHI)
team in collaboration with the Forum to understand
the level of innovation and readiness to market for
pharmaceutical interventions.
To capture year-on-year impact, the initial data,
comprising Year 0, was taken from April 2023, and
an updated view on Year 1 was captured in June
2024 from the Pharmaprojects database. Innovation
and readiness to market were assessed for three
categories of pipeline products:
1. New assets that have entered the pipeline in the
past year
2. New assets that have entered the pipeline for
that indication in the past year
3. Phase 3 assets
The absolute number of assets in the pipeline
may not capture the full potential for innovation:
e.g. a condition may have many assets that lead
to incremental improvement or few approvals for
actual treatments if over-indexed on early-stage
development; others may have few assets, although
those assets may lead to a leapfrog impact. That
said, the more assets in the pipeline for a condition,
the more likely an intervention for a condition may
come to market and have potential to improve the
standard of care over time.
Assessing pipeline assets as a proxy to
understanding potential shifts in care delivery is
complex. Given the long development times and
resources required to ensure assets are making
it to late-stage trial phases, a fraction of pipeline
assets is approved out of total pipeline trials.
Understanding innovation and where the standard
of care may be improved is nuanced.
Innovation and quantity of innovative assets for
each prioritized condition were measured to track
impact, with an additional focus on later-stage
(Phase 3) assets that may come to market sooner. Readiness to market was also measured, with
assets in later stages possibly more likely to come
to market earlier, alongside those with similar
assets on the market already in the indication and
medications that are similar receiving expedited
review designation.
From speaking with experts, looking at novel, first-
in-class assets for mechanisms of action is a core
indicator of innovation, meaning assets that are the
first of their kind for the mechanism of action in an
indication. However, there are other specific criteria
for innovation on an individual asset and indication
basis that make the assessment challenging to
scale to all indications.
One such example is assets already launched and
entering the pipeline for a new indication. This
challenge is particularly complex when looking
at oncology indications. It is often the case that
early-stage oncology assets are trialled across
multiple tumours, given the broad focus of oncology
research and development initially. Once in trials,
the indications narrow, and assets come to market
specifically for indications. In this analysis, for
example, there are assets in preclinical and Phase 1
stages that fall into both breast and cervical cancer
indications. With this in mind, assessing innovation
by first-in-class for the indication is less applicable
for oncology, even though often relevant once
assets are advanced to later trial stages.
2.3.3 Metric 6:
Number of clinical trials
Definition: Number of clinical trials per condition
Source: clinicaltrials.gov
Period: June 2023–May 2024
Clinical trial data can be used to indicate research
and funding focus areas and potential innovations
in the care delivery pipeline. Clinical trial data
can be a useful proxy for understanding industry
and academic priorities. Active clinical trials with
women enrolees registered with clinicaltrials.gov
were assessed (1 June 2023 to 31 May 2024)
to understand the location of trial settings, as
compared to the burden of conditions in different
income archetype regions.
To understand the locations and number of clinical
trials, clinicaltrials.gov and the international clinical
trials registry platform were used. Condition-specific
queries were created using the terms mentioned
earlier, and the trials tagged under those conditions
over the past year were downloaded and analysed.
Trials were analysed for the location, split into the
four income archetypes.
Blueprint to Close the Women’s Health Gap: How to Improve Lives and Economies for All
42
Ask AI what this page says about a topic: