Document text
0 of 3 Premium Clicks used this month SUBSCRIBE Print + Online Subscriber Activation | Register x Forgot Password | Need an Account? e-edition | subscribe | newsletter | deals Home News Latest Stories Couple returns to 'post-earthquake' Haiti Central Point candidates have similar goals Emergency Services Medford school officials consider costs of full-day kindergarten Family rallies help for Mexican community Crime, Courts and Emergency Services Couple returns to 'post-earthquake' Haiti Emergency Services Family rallies help for Mexican community Emergency services Iron Mike loses his rifle ... again Politics and Elections Kitzhaber embattled as he seeks fourth term Five compete for three council seats Jville Council Q&A: Brad Bennington Jville Council Q&A: Jim Lewis Jville Council Q&A: Ken Gregg Education Medford school officials consider costs of full-day kindergarten Foundation kicks off ambitious 'Count Me In' fundraising campaign 100 hours and counting SOU students protest university's free-speech zone Boys & Girls Clubs bursting at the seams Environment Work begins on Southern Oregon's first dedicated mountain bike trail Applegate Dam hydroelectric project dead in water Fear of orphaned cubs nixes new spring bear hunt Josephine County ballot measure would ban commercial and government pesticide use Low water exposes Emigrant Lake's past State news Nation - World Obituaries Marylen Agrell Kocks Lillian (Hulinsky) Kamarad Carol Erenst Reynolds Jay P. Greenwade Harriet Sheehan Weather Photo Galleries Since You Asked Videos Web Cams Mail Tribune 100 Sports Latest Stories Manning breaks Favre’s all-time TD record Impact of a Comet Keselowski keeps title hopes alive at Talladega Tim Lincecum waits his turn, still yet to pitch Denkinger’s miss revisited as Series returns to KC Varsity 541 College Sports UO’s Dargan sets the tone for improving defense Mariota keeps touchdown streak alive Royce Rolls SOU shuts down Beacons for weekend sweep Raiders drop wild game to Carroll, 42-40 Pro Sports Manning breaks Favre’s all-time TD record Tim Lincecum waits his turn, still yet to pitch Denkinger’s miss revisited as Series returns to KC Vickers wins pole in strange Talladega qualifying Spurs' Popovich jabs Suns owner Sarver Community Sports LOCAL EVENTS LOCAL RESULTS Business Latest Stories Rogue Credit Union awaits southeast Medford opportunity People in Business Blog: Early Holiday Shopping Hundreds look for work at Harry & David hiring fair Frontier Airlines to end Eugene-Denver service Real Estate News Lithia buys Clovis dealership Rental vacancies increase Jackson County real estate sales, prices continue rebound Pallet Wine Co. expands in downtown Medford People In Business People in Business Transportation Frontier Airlines to end Eugene-Denver service Business Resource Fair has answers Erickson's Navy contract extended Lithia buys Clovis dealership Agriculture Hundreds look for work at Harry & David hiring fair Umpqua Holdings more than doubles net earnings Harry & David will hold hiring fair Thursday Ranchers offer livestock exchange 1-800-Flowers CEO: Labor shortage an issue for Harry & David Opinion Latest Letters to the Editor, Oct. 20 Another view: It's easy: Just stop having sex Letters to the Editor, Oct. 19 Our view: Endorsements include Bates, Talbert, Hoppe Don't overlook importance of Jackson County commissioners race Editorials Our view: Endorsements include Bates, Talbert, Hoppe Reversing course: Hoppe for judge Our view: With respect, our support goes to Bates Our View: Bearnson, Stine, Lane for Medford council Our View: No clear favorite for county commissioner, position 1 Letters to the Editor Letters to the Editor, Oct. 20 Letters to the Editor, Oct. 19 Letters to the Editor, Oct. 18 Letters to the Editor, Oct. 17 Letters to the Editor, Oct. 16 Guest Opinions Don't overlook importance of Jackson County commissioners race Measure 92 misleads rather than enlightens Oregonians have a right to know what's in their food Infill is the answer to growth issues Guest Opinion: Who’s really to blame for 2014 wildfires? Lifestyle Latest stories Scenic byway showcases colors of the Cascades New arrivals Held captive by whimsy How to know when trees and shrubs need to go Community blog: My New Best Selling Book Food Community blog: Southern Oregon Micro and Nano Brewing Scene Fall 2014 Community blog: Eggs make for economical, unconventional curry Mobile meals perfect for autumn forays Community blog: Green beans go global from gleaning garden Kitchen Call: Pumpkin is nothing without the spice Home and Garden How to know when trees and shrubs need to go Dear Monty: Is your real estate agent a secret agent? The best way to store your books A list to help you get ready for winter How to create a fashionable painted floor cloth Health Held captive by whimsy Community blog: My New Best Selling Book Dr. Jeff Hersh: The enterovirus is not new Dr. Murray Feingold: The first successful uterus transplant Health Watch: Skip the energy drink and reenergize naturally Hiking Biking Faith Religion Briefs Religion Briefs Religion Briefs Religion briefs First Church of Nazarene plans cleanup Milestones and Achievements New arrivals Southern Oregon Pride parade celebrates gay marriage ruling New Arrivals Still stifling laughter 40 years after 'Young Frankenstein' New Arrivals Columnist for a Day Rogue Healthy Aging Tempo Latest stories Review: Funny 'Lion in Winter' roars to life at Camelot Theatre Yu's Yummy Yan's offers great take-out A cappella fellas sing for schools Theater's haunted house not for faint of heart Tutunov Piano Series begins at SOU Theater Camelot presents 'The Lion in Winter' 'Carnage' is short, smart, darkly funny Randall Theatre presents 'Blithe Spirit' A tribute to a great lyricist Music A cappella fellas sing for schools The Farr Side: Bryan Adams releases album of influential hits Tutunov Piano Series begins at SOU Benefit for Nita Day at The Wild Goose Cafe in Ashland Call for musicians Community Events Review: Funny 'Lion in Winter' roars to life at Camelot Theatre Theater's haunted house not for faint of heart Third Fridays in downtown Medford Works in progress Southern Oregon Pride Festival celebrates diversity Dining Yu's Yummy Yan's offers great take-out Agave offers tasty tacos Asian cuisine for all seasons at Misoya Bistro Spoons Tempo Videos Classifieds Jobs Autos Real Estate FEATURED » Obituaries Blogs TV Listings Movie Listings Oregon Outdoors Oregon Healthy Living Magazines & Special Sections NEWS NOW Central Point candidates have similar goals ... Family rallies help for Mexican community ... Green Party candidate drops from state Senate race ... Central Point candidates have similar goals ... Family rallies help for Mexican community ... Green Party candidate drops from state Senate race ... ANOTHER VIEW 'Redskins' petition seeks to end annoyances MailTribune.com Writer Posted Oct. 16, 2014 @ 12:01 am Posted Oct. 16, 2014 @ 12:01 am » Social News Wretched excess by government can be beneficial if it startles people into wholesome disgust and deepened distrust, and prompts judicial rebukes that enlarge freedom. So let's hope the Federal Communications Commission embraces the formal petition inciting it to deny licenses to broadcasters who use the word "Redskins" when reporting on the Washington Redskins. Using the FCC to break another private institution to the state's saddle for the satisfaction of a clamorous faction illustrates how the government's many tentacles give it many means of intimidating people who offend it. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, empowered to ban trademarks that "may" disparage persons, has already limited trademark protection of the Redskins' name. The FCC petition argues that broadcasting during prime time of the word "Redskins" has "an adverse impact on impressionable young Indian as well as non-Indian children." (Today's sensitivity arbiters say the word "Indian" does, too, but never mind.) Furthermore, uttering "Redskins" is "akin to broadcasting obscenity" and pornography, is "hate speech" and an "ethnic slur" that "keep[s] alive the spirit of inhumanity, subjugation and genocide" and "may" cause violence against Native Americans. Besides, it is a "nuisance," defined as something "annoying." Is the FCC empowered to protect an entitlement to a life without annoyances? What if the FCC is annoying? This is complicated. Professor Eugene Volokh, who specializes in First Amendment law at UCLA's School of Law and supervises an invaluable website, The Volokh Conspiracy, thinks the petition refutes itself. It argues that "Redskins" is offensive because of the ideas and attitudes the word conveys. But when the Supreme Court upheld restrictions on the broadcasting of certain vulgarities (George Carlin's "seven dirty words"), it stressed that the mere fact that speech is offensive is not a sufficient reason for suppressing it. And although the court focused on the content of the words, it did not focus on the political content or on the speaker's opinion. "Indeed," Justice John Paul Stevens wrote, "if it is the speaker's opinion that gives offense, that consequence is a reason for according [an utterance] constitutional protection," because "the government must remain neutral in the marketplace of ideas." Volokh adds: "The premise of the criticism of 'Redskins' is precisely that it embodies a racist, demeaning message about American Indians (whether or not this is intended by those who use it), and that it offends because of this racist meaning. It thus is the speaker's imputed opinion and supposed 'political content' of the word that gives offense." Some say "Redskins" is merely an offensive epithet with a negligible ideological message. Volokh replies that the epithet is offensive to those who are offended "because of its allegedly racist ideology, and the call to suppress it stems precisely from the perception that it conveys this racist ideology." Anyway, the anti-"Redskins" petition is less legal reasoning than a form of bureaucratic bullying known as regulation by "raised eyebrow." The petition's author notes that the FCC sometimes indicates disapproval of this or that, thereby compelling broadcasters, worried about being put out of business, to practice self-censorship. So the petition seems designed to trigger this, thereby succeeding even if it fails — even if the FCC dismisses the petition. If, however, the FCC under progressives today but conservatives tomorrow, can, in the petition's words, define and ban particular words as "nuisances" because they "annoy" a "substantial composite" of the population, what other words will appear on an ever-lengthening list? Today many colleges and universities have "free speech zones" — wee spaces to which the First Amendment is confined. Such institutions are run by educators whose meager educations did not teach them that the Amendment made America a free speech zone. Campuses are habitats for progressives, and the distilled essence of today's progressivism is the use of power to limit speech. The fact that censorship is progressivism's default position regarding so many things is evidence of progressives' pessimism about the ability of their agenda to advance under a regime of robust discussion. It also indicates the delight progressives derive from bossing people around and imposing a particular sensibility, in the name of diversity, of course. The petition, which uses "R*dskins" (this typographical delicacy supposedly will help prevent pogroms against Native Americans), says the phrase "colored people," too, is "now considered derogatory." If so, some progressive has the awkward duty of notifying the NAACP that its name is "akin to" a disparagement, an obscenity, pornography, a racial slur and hate speech. The language policeman's lot is not a happy one. George Will's email address is [email protected]. MailTribune.com Writer Posted Oct. 16, 2014 @ 12:01 am » Comment or view comments Reader Reaction » STAY INFORMED Email NewsLetter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. calendar Connect with MailTribune.com Facebook Twitter RSS Back to top Reader Services Reader Services Home Subscriptions Subscriber controls Contact us Submissions Photos Events Letters to the editor Corrections Announcements Obituaries Story ideas Since you asked Alerts Email Alerts RSS Feeds Text Alerts Advertise Media Kit Home Products and services Ad rates Advertising contacts Mail Tribune Daily Tidings The Nickel Shop Our Valley Blogs Stay Informed Email newsletter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. Your privacy is important, read our privacy policy. © Copyright 2014 Local Media Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Local Media Group Publications Original content available for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons license, except where noted. MailTribune.com | P.O. Box 1108, Medford, OR 97501