"atateoft /44,dee

EFTA00605232 Dataset 9 63 pages Download original PDF
"atateoft /44,dee Equipment Asset Management and Financial Appraisal Services Accredited Senior Appraisers Daniel H. Rausch. ASA Gary A. Webster, ASA 4A$ /I p Helicopter \\International Monarch Professional Centre 1W\ Norman Soclaly of Appr.son. Providing Value World.ido An Appraisal of One 1999 Hawker 800XP Aircraft Serial Number 258418 Registration Number N516TH As of March 21. 2016 Prepared For CGM Capital Prepared By Aviation Asset Management Inc NATIONAL BISINESS AVIATION ASSOCIATION, INC March 23, 2016 EFTA00605232 Index Section Page No. Introduction 1-2 Report Options and Approaches to Value 3-4 Value Considerations and Value Calculations 5-9 Specifications and Physical Inspection 10-11 Photographs 12-19 Introduction to the Hawker 800XP Series and the 20-24 Honeywell TFE-731 Engine Series Statement Of Limiting Conditions Appraisers Certification 25-27 Business/General Aviation Outlook 28-37 Appraiser Qualifications 38-39 Glossary of Terms 40-61 EFTA00605233 Adateemt Ada Equipment Asset Management and Financial Appraisal Services Accredited Senior Appraisers Daniel H. Rausch, ASA Gary A. Webster, ASA CMG Capital C/O Shawn Chemtov Dear Mr. Chemtov, Monarch Professional Centre ASV" a dirr Asnencan Sous,, of Apprantaim Providing Value Worldwide March 23, 2016 In response to your request, Aviation Asset Management, Inc. (AAMI) is pleased to provide a Full Appraisal and our opinion of the Current Fair Market Value (CFMV) of one 1999 Hawker 800XP aircraft, SIN 258418, Registration N516TH registered to South Aviation Inc, This appraisal is based on information provided by L&L International, along with publicly available data as of March 21, 2016. No consideration has been given to any liens or encumbrances which may be held against the asset appraised. No investigation of legal fee or title to the property has been made and the claim to the property is assumed to be valid. No additional values or appraisals have been made regarding such intangibles as patents, rights to manufacture, trademarks, goodwill, customer lists, etc. This appraisal has been developed and is being submitted in conformance with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP), as promulgated by the Appraisal Standards Board of the American Society of Appraisers. NHelicopter Association International NATIONAL BISINESS AVIATION ASSOCIATION, A EFTA00605234 Attalla( Alai Nanagafrait Sac Aviation Asset Management Inc. is not a manufacturer or engaged in the sale or distribution of the aircraft that comprises this appraisal. AAMI makes no representations or warranties, expressed or implied, with respect to the merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose of the aircraft. This appraisal represents the opinion of AAMI, as an independent and disinterested party to the transaction as well as the known parties thereto. It is not given for or as an inducement for any financial transaction and, further is prepared for the exclusive use of CMG Capital, our client, and shall not be provided to other parties without the consent of CMG Capital. It is assumed that the Current Fair Market Value stated in this appraisal is to be obtained in an arms-length transaction between an informed and willing buyer and an informed and willing seller without undue pressure on either the buyer or the seller. Sincerely, Aviation Asset Management, Inc. Dela Retold Daniel H. Rausch, President Accredited Senior Appraiser America Society of Appraisers Certified Appraiser International Society of Transport Aircraft Trading Page 2 EFTA00605235 Agitation ;444et 2llanagement lac Appraisal Report Options There are two USPAP-approved appraisal report options used in presenting appraisal data: 1. Appraisal Report. 2. Restricted Appraisal Report. The Restricted Appraisal Report is limited in information and can only be used when the report is to be used by the client and will not be relied upon by anyone else. The essential difference among the two report options is in the content and level of information provided. This Appraisal Report was prepared in accordance with USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(a). This is a Full Appraisal Report, which contains sufficient information to explain the appraisal process and includes a physical inspection or on-site audit of the aircraft, but not the records which were not available during the physical inspection. The purpose of this appraisal is to determine the Current Fair Market Value (CFMV) of one Hawker 800XP aircraft. The use of this appraisal is for valuation of the aircraft for support of financing. Our client is CMG Capital and an intended user of this report is L&L International Ltd.. All data gathered in support of our CFMV opinion used in the compilation of this appraisal is available in our workfile for your inspection for a period of five years. Page 3 EFTA00605236 Agitated* ;444el Iltanagement Tee APPROACHES TO VALUE There are three recognized approaches utilized to determine value which may be used in appraising, described briefly as follows: COST APPROACH: This approach begins with the determination of the current cost to reproduce the asset (Reproduction Cost New) or replace the utility (Replacement Cost New) of the subject property as of the valuation date. From the more appropriate of these two costs all forms of depreciation, physical deterioration, functional and economic obsolescence are deducted resulting in a value estimate by the Cost Approach. This approach is not widely used in aircraft appraisals. INCOME APPROACH: In this approach, the future income stream, associated with the item is first estimated. From this potential income, all expenses involved in the exchange or overhaul of the item is deducted yielding net income which is the money an investor could expect to receive from the item. This data is then processed into value either by means of a capitalization rate embodying consideration of capital cost, remaining economic life and degree of risk involved, or by means of a discounted cash flow analysis over an appropriate economic life. The Income Approach is typically not used in the aerospace industry. It is very difficult to separate and allocate the portion of the operating income attributable to specific aircraft. Consequently it is not used in this analysis. SALES COMPARISON APPROACH: In this approach, sales of comparable parts or equipment are analyzed. If detailed information is available, the individual sales are adjusted for various aspects of similarity to the subject. The resultant adjusted sales prices are correlated and a value estimate for the subject is derived from them. The Sales Comparison Approach is an appropriate method to estimate the value of the subject aircraft by using appropriate comparable sales, however all details concerning the status and condition of the comparables must be known. If sufficient details are not known about the comparables, then using references sources which list average sales values during a given time period, would be more appropriate. In the analysis of the subject aircraft, the Sales Comparison Approach, using reference sources of sales prices and current market information was utilized. Page 4 EFTA00605237 Adettion "twee Iltanagenteat Sac Value Considerations AAMI follows the traditional industry standards for market evaluations, which are based on half-life (time) of life-limited parts and time between overhaul (TBO) on the aircraft high-cost maintenance items. The following parameters and assumptions are utilized for purposes of standardized comparisons; namely that the aircraft has half-life remaining on the time-controlled components to its next scheduled major overhaul or shop visit; is under an approved maintenance program and in compliance with all Airworthiness Directives (ADs), and applicable Service Bulletins (SBs). It has traceability of life-limited and time-controlled parts; all repairs and modifications accomplished are approved and signed off with full documentation; is in standard configuration; has no damage history, and is sold for a cash transaction. This, moreover, assumes the aircraft is equipped with standard part/components and options of the types and models generally accepted and utilized in the industry, and that it is one of the standard or widely used configurations utilized in domestic or international operations in private or commercial operations. Additional factors, including date of delivery, total and ratio of hours to cycles and modifications, are considered when making adjustments for a specific aircraft. Changes in the aforementioned parameters, assumptions and standards can increase or decrease the market price. Conversely, market values, as well as actual appraised values are detrimentally affected on aircraft that have been out of service for prolonged periods or not currently certified as airworthy. Deterioration in value will also apply to aircraft, which have disproportionately high cycle-to-hour ratios relative to the average achieved by the industry in operating the specific types of aircraft, or to aircraft that have a damage history. No accident, incident, or damage history was reported to us and none was found in a search of the FAA and NTSB databases for this aircraft. Page 5 EFTA00605238 Acattion 444et Nanagement Sae Forced liquidation and bankruptcy sales can cause prices to fall as much as 30% or more below current market prices during certain market trends. Sales by non-operating entities that do not include the benefits of in-house financing usually bring lower prices on a cash or cash equivalent basis. Additionally, market values are also based on knowledge of asking, offered and transaction prices similar, competitive, and alternative equipment. The analysis contained in this report, although acknowledging immediate effects, excludes extremely short-term market stimulants and depressants from both present base values and forecasted values, when it is determined that they are transient in nature. It is expected that short-term situations tend only to affect availability temporarily, rather than cause consequential price changes. This is due to the long-term economic consequences of price considerations outweighing the short-term consequences of reduced or high availability caused by these temporary problems. The pressures on the manufacturers to overcome major problems promptly as they arise lessen the chance of the values of their product lines being affected detrimentally in the long-term. Conversely, the implementation requirements of high cost Airworthiness Directives, mandatory Service Bulletins, and high time/cycle special maintenance requirements, are treated as long term impact items for applicable engines and aircraft. There were 475 total Hawker 800s built between 1995-2006 They are no longer in production. There are 469 of these aircraft remaining, 307 of which are operated in North America, and 160 in other regions. Total time ranges from 68 hours to 12,958 hours. There are 54 of these aircraft for sale and none offered for lease. Average asking price is $2.3M and the average days on the market is 314. The average total time on the aircraft that are currently listed for sale is 5,586 hours. In 2016 so far there have been 22 transactions on this model. In 2015 there were 108 transactions. Page 6 EFTA00605239 Ailation 444et 71tanagenteat Tied Value Calculations A. Current Fair Market Value (CFMV) (Half-life) Current Fair Market Value (Half-Life) is a base-line value that assumes its physical condition is average for an aircraft of its type and age, and its maintenance time status is at mid-life, mid-time (or benefiting from an above- average maintenance status if it is new or nearly new, as the case may be). It also assumes that the aircraft is equipped with the manufacturer's standard compliment of equipment. It is the starting point for making maintenance and other adjustments to arrive at the adjusted CFMV. When reliable actual sales data is available, it is preferable to use those actual sales values of recent sales for comparison purposes to establish a Base Value. We were able to ascertain current asking prices of similar aircraft currently on the market. We also subscribe to aircraft pricing services that report values based on actual sales comparables. In addition, we had a discussion with a number of owners, previous owners, and brokers concerning recent offerings and transactions. We considered all values in addition to a broad knowledge about the current executive aviation marketplace. AAMI considered numerous reference sources for the Half-Life CFMV starting point We have used a mid-life CFMV of 2,200,000. This is the point from which we make our maintenance adjustments. A. Airframe Time: Adjustments for Airframe Total Time are based on the fleet average of all of the 1999 Hawker 800XP aircraft. According to the Blue Book, the average airframe time for a 1999 Hawker 800XP is 410 hours per year. N516TH has an average of 277 hours per year 68% of the average. Page 7 EFTA00605240 24atartion 1144et Iltanagement Tad B. Airframe Maintenance: The airframe major check is the 48-month airframe check at an average cost of $75,000. C. APU There is an adjustment of $15.50 per hour for hours more or less than half life (5,000 hours). D. Engines: The engines are maintained in accordance with the manufacturer's maintenance program. The condition of the engines is a very important element in determining the value of the aircraft. There is no Adjustment for Time Remaining on the Engine Refurbishment on the engines as the engines are on a Maintenance Service Plan (MSP Gold) and are considered at Half Life E. Current Fair Market Value (Adjusted): Is the Appraiser's opinion of the most likely trading price that may be generated for a property under the market circumstances that are perceived to exist at the time in question. The term assumes that the property is valued for its highest and best use, that the parties to the hypothetical sale transaction are willing, able, prudent and knowledgeable, and under no unusual pressure for a prompt sale, and that the transaction would be negotiated in an open and unrestricted market on an arm's length basis. It is synonymous with Market Value, and likewise Current Fair Market Value is synonymous with Current Market Value because the criteria typically used in those documents that use the term "Fair" reflect the same criteria set forth in the above definition of Market Value. By itself, the term "Fair" does not bring any additional qualifications to the appraised value, but it is a term sometimes used in leases, sales contracts, tax regulations and legal documents, and is sometimes accompanied with a specific definition to which the contracting parties have agreed. Page 8 EFTA00605241 Athiuda Awe vtaa49emea Tae 1999 Hawker 800XP Serial Number 258418, N516TH Value Summary as of March 22, 2016 Current Half-Life Market Value of a (Base 1999) HAWKER 800XP $2,200,000 Adjustment for Fresh New Paint & Interior, March 2016 (interior assumes complete re-rag, refurbished ceiling and sidewall panels, and new carpet. + 150,000 CURRENT HALF-LIFE VALUE of this 1999 HAWKER 800XP Serial Number 258418, N516TH $2,350,000 Adjustment for 32% fewer hours than average. This is a low-time aircraft + 82,100 Adjustment for Fresh12, 24 and 48-Month inspections as of March 2016 + 85,000 Adjustment for the 21 months more than half life remaining on the 144-Month Landing Gear Restoration at $194,000 per restoration + 28,287 No Adjustment for Time Remaining on the Engine Refurbishment on Engine #1 as the engine is on a MSP Gold maintenance plan and is considered at Half Life +/- 0 No Adjustment for Time Remaining on the Engine Refurbishment on Engine #2 as the engine is on a MSP Gold maintenance plan and is considered at Half Life +/- 0 Adjustment for 1,329 hours more than half life (5,000 hours) remaining on the APU overhaul @ $175,000 per O/H or $15.50 per hour + 20,600 CURRENT FAIR MARKET VALUE of 1999 Hawker 800XP, Serial Number 258418, N516TH $2,5-65.gaZ BASE AVG = Full complement of electronics, dual systems, color radar, dual air data, HF corn, CVR, RVSM, Eng MSP, Maintenance and Inspections Half-Life unless specified, Paint and interior rated 8+, ADs SBs complied with, Avg AFTT, No Damage History, Complete Logbooks since new Page 9 EFTA00605242 Acattecut liatt 2ganagentent Tice Specifications As of December 8, 2015 1999 HAWKER 800 XP S/N 258418 Airframe: 4,702.6 hrs.2,665 Landings Engines: Garrett TFE731-5BR-1H RH: P107377 LH: P107376 ON MSP GOLD TT 4,702.6 TT 4,702.6 TC 2,665 TC 2,665 APU: P-461 GRT GTCP36-150W3,300 TT 3,671.0 Avionics: Honeywell SPZ 8000 1FCS/Primus II Dual RCZ 850 Comms with 8.33 spacing Dual RNZ 850Nays Dual DF 850 ADF Dual DM 850 DME Dual KHF 950 HF Honeywell LSZ-850 Stormscope Honeywell SPZ 8000 Flight Director Dual Honeywell FMZ-2000 w 5.2 software and & dual GPS. Honeywell Primus 880 Dual Honeywell FZ-800 FGC Five tube EFIS Features: Exxon Mobil previous owner TCAS 2000-11 with change 7 Teledyne angle of attack Allied Signal Mark VII EGPWS No damage history Flight Display Airshow On CAMP Interior: New 8 place interior. Forward club and aft 3 place divan. Exterior: New 850 XP paint scheme. Page 10 EFTA00605243 Agitation 444et 2llanagement lac Physical Inspection 1999 Hawker 800XP Serial Number 258418 Registration N516TH The aircraft was inspected at the Ft Lauderdale International airport on March 23, 2016 at Jetscapes. It is currently undergoing installation of a new interior. I did not observe the new seats or other interior pieces, so I can only assume it is getting the typical re-rag on the seats, refurbished sidewalls and ceiling panels and new carpet. They just completed a complete fresh paint job in the 850XP paint scheme. The fuselage is in good condition with no skin patches or dents. The passenger windows and pilot's windows are also in good condition. There are no oil or Skydrol leaks evident, as one would expect following a fresh paint job. No fuel leaks are evident, which can be a problem on these aircraft. They also just completed the 12, 24, and 48-Month airframe maintenance checks and brought all ADs and SBs up to date. The repairs will continue into next week. The aircraft has been operating under FAA FAR Part 91 rules, and a non-commercial maintenance program. In addition, routine maintenance, minor issues are being corrected as they are found. This aircraft was previously operated under the FAR 135 regulations. The records for the aircraft were viewed and no problems were apparent. There were numerous large airframe log books plus engine and APU logs. All Airworthiness Directives and all Service Bulletins have been complied with. The information in these log books stops after March 2014, but the records are being kept in a separate large binder and John Taylor is in the process of cleaning up the record books and putting all of the service items in the binders. There is no history of damage. Both engines are on a pre-paid maintenance service program (MSP) called MSP Gold which covers all routine maintenance. The engines are operated "on condition" which means they fly until there is something needing routine maintenance or repair, then the item is repaired. The airframe is on a computerized aircraft maintenance system (CAMS) which tracks all maintenance items. The Airworthiness Certificate and Registration certificates were inaccessible due to work being accomplished on the interior. Pictures of the aircraft follow: Page 11 EFTA00605244 Aactudw "Imet 7Itamagemagt Vac N516TH March 23, 2016 N516TH at Ft Lauderdale, FL Ceiling Panel Being Installed EFTA00605245 Adaave Aaaet 7/toutagemeat %c N516TH March 23, 2016 Nose Gear Nose EFTA00605246 14-mt/tt Auer Xtxurage..,e,t Twc N516TH RH Forward Fuselage RH Wing Fairing March 23, 2016 EFTA00605247 "1,'Atintot ,44Jet 71tamaguiceat Ise N516TH March 23, 2016 Right Hand Wing Right Side EFTA00605248 :4‘dat/cot "imet Ilfamagemeat Tat N516TH March 23, 2016 Right Main Gear Rear View EFTA00605249 iliatation /hut Vtanagernact Sac March 23, 2016 N516TH Tail Section fiaytfreon Aircraft Aircraft Data Plate EFTA00605250 Ageism" ,4w Wanagemees Tad N516TH March 23. 2016 Left Wine Interior Removed for Refurbishment EFTA00605251 74otatton Ai.xt Nasagemcgt Tiec N516TH March 23, 2016 Cockpit Overhead Instrument Panel EFTA00605252 Aliaeat Amet Nana9entent TOCC Hawker 800XP INTRODUCTION The Hawker 800 is a derivative of the de Havilland 125. The British Aerospace Board sanctioned the program to improve the, then current and strongly selling, BAe 125 700 series in April 1981. By May 1983 the new aircraft was ready for its first test flight. The 800 series has a number of modifications and changes over the 700; most noticeable was the redesigned cockpit windscreen. Accompanying this are a modified rear fuselage fairing as well as a glass cockpit and uprated (from 3,700 to 4,300 Ib) Garrett TFE731-5R-1H engines. British Aerospace also improved the wing by incorporating new outer wing sections. This helped to reduce drag and improve aerodynamic efficiency. The launch of the Raytheon Hawker 800XP extended performance mid-size business jet was announced in 1995. The aircraft is in service both as a business / VIP jet and also in special mission versions. The XP features uprated engine, enhanced aerodynamics, increased weight and system upgrades. In December 2006, Raytheon announced the sale of Raytheon Aircraft to GS Capital Partners. The new company is called Hawker Beechcraft Inc and the sale was completed in March 2007. Page 20 EFTA00605253 Aveateos Azet 71faaagearat Tae The Hawker 800XP business jet is derived from the design of the UK-built de Havilland / Hawker Siddely and British Aerospace 125, first built in 1962, which evolved into the Series 400 to 800 produced up to the early 1990s. Raytheon purchased the Series 800 program in 1993 and the aircraft took the name Hawker 800. There were 475 total Hawker 800s built between 1995-2006 They are no longer in production. In November 2005, Raytheon introduced the Hawker 850XP, a successor to the Hawker 800XPi. The aircraft has composite, outwardly canted winglets, a range increased by 4% (an additional 185km) and 8% improvement in time to climb. The 850XP has the same Rockwell Collins Pro Line 21 avionics Airshow 21 cabin management system as the 800XPi. The Hawker 850XP received certification in March 2006 and is the current production model, superseding the 800XP. The aircraft is powered by two rear-mounted Honeywell TFE731-5BR-1H turbofan engines each rated at 20.73kN. The engines, fitted with Dee Howard thrust reversers, are mounted in Northrop Grumman pods on either side of the rear fuselage. The engines are fitted with BCF engine fire extinguishers and engine bleed air ice protection. SPECIFICATIONS TYPE: mid-size business jet POWERPLANTS: FUEL CAPACITY: ACCOMODATION: DIMENSIONS, EXTERNAL: Two rear-mounted Honeywell TFE731-5BR-1H turbofan engines each rated at 20.73kN. 1,273 gal Flight Crew: Passengers: Baggage Compartment: Wing Span: Length Overall: Maximum Height: Fuselage Diameter: Wing Area: 2 between eight to 15 passengers 29.6 cu ft 15.66m (51ft 3in) 15.59m (51ft 1in) 5.36m (17ft 5in) 1.93m (6 ft 3 in) 34.75 sq m (374 sq ft) Page 21 EFTA00605254 Adatieue ,4aae€ 7/tcugagemeat Tae DIMENSIONS, INTERNAL: WEIGHTS: Total Cabin Length: Maximum Width: Maximum Height: Cabin Volume: Baggage Volume: Empty Operating Weight: MTOW: Max Ramp Weight: Max Zero-Fuel Weight: Max Landing Weight: Max Payload: PERFORMANCE: Maximum Speed: Service Ceiling: Take-Off Field Length: Landing Run From 15m: Range: 6.50m (21 ft 3 in 1.83m (6 ft 0 in) 1.75m (5 ft 7 in) 17.1 cu m (604 cu ft) 2.46 cu m 7,303 kg (16,100 Ib) 12,701 kg (28,000 Ib) 12,755 kg (28,120 Ib) 8,369 kg (18,450 Ib) 10,591 kg (23,350 Ib) 989 kg (2,180 Ib) 845km/h (456 kt) 13,100m 1,640m (5,380 ft) 1,372m (4,182 ft) 4,222km (2,280 nm) PRODUCTION: Since it's introduction, there have been just over 470 800XPs built. Page 22 EFTA00605255 Afibviist Aadet 7/tanagesient Vac Honeywell TFE-731 INTRODUCTION The TFE731 was based on the core of the TSCP700, which was specifically developed for use as the auxiliary power unit (APU) on the McDonnell Douglas DC-10. The design featured two important factors, low fuel consumption, and low noise profiles which met the newly established U.S. noise abatement regulations. The first test run of the TFE731 occurred in 1970 at Garrett's plant in Torrance, California. The first production model, the TFE731-2 began rolling off the assembly line in August, 1972, and was used on the Learjet 35/36 and Dassault Falcon 10, both of which entered production in 1973. The TFE731-3 was developed for use in the Lockheed JetStar re-engining program, and subsequent versions of it have been used on a number of aircraft, including the Learjet 55. The -5 model was certified in 1982, and a decade later, an engine utilizing the TFE731-5 power section and a TFE731-3 fan was built and designated the TFE731-4, intended to power the Cessna Citation 650 and 750 series aircraft. The latest TFE731-50R, has 70 improvements to this already robust engine, including improved core and LP spool technologies, new Digital Electronic Engine Control (DEEC) and a complete nacelle and thrust reverser system. Page 23 EFTA00605256 Adatecut Aset 7llanagesteet %c These changes resulted in greater versatility, dramatically improved temperature margins, a better lapse rate than the TFE731-5BR and, depending on altitude condition, up to 8% better SFC. The TFE731 family of engines has a legacy of proven reliability. The first TFE731 was certified in 1972. Since that time, more than 13,000 engines have been produced, logging an astounding 100 million plus hours of service on more than 30 different aircraft applications. SPECIFICATIONS TYPE: Two-shaft geared turbofan FUEL CONSUMPTION: 23.65 mg/Ns (0.835 lb/h/lb COMPRESSOR STAGES: 1 stage fan, 4-stage low pressure axial compressor, 1 stage high pressure centrifugal compressor TURBINE STAGES: 1 stage high pressure turbine, 3 stage low pressure turbine COMBUSTION CHAMBER: annular reverse flow combustor DIMENSIONS & WEIGHTS: Max Envelope Diameter: 39.4 in. Max Envelope Length: 51 in. Dry Weight: 885 lb PERFORMANCE RATINGS: T-O Power Rating: 16.46 kN (3,700 Ib) Bypass Ratio: 2.80:1 ENGINE VARIANT TAKEOFF THRUST ALTITUDE THRUST ALTITUDE TSFC* TFE731-2 3500 755 0.790 TFE731-3 3700 817 0.794 TFE731-4 4080 929 0.771 TFE731-5 4304 955 0.777 TFE731-5B 4750 1050 0.735 TFE731-20 3650 870 0.719 TFE731-40 4250 1010 0.739 TFE731-60 5000 1120 0.679 (*) 40,000ft. max. cruise, .08Mm ISA Page 24 EFTA00605257 Adation timet 71tamagemeat Tow ASSUMPTIONS AND STATEMENTS OF LIMITING CONDITIONS ✓ The values stated in this report are based on our knowledge of the Aircraft, Engine and Spare Parts. The values stated in this report are based on our knowledge of the Aircraft, Engine and Spare Parts inventory market, current market conditions, and certain definitions and assumptions regarding the inventory condition and status, which is described in this report. ✓ The values stated in this report are based on the information supplied by the company that is being appraised. It has been assumed that this information along with any of management's statements relative to the topics discussed concerning the inventory, aircraft, or engines are full and complete representations that accurately depict the company, its inventory and the quality and condition of the market for the products produced and/or distributed. No warranty is given for its accuracy. Every reasonable attempt has been made to verify such information. ✓ Possession of this report, or a copy thereof, does not carry with it the right of publication. It may not be used for any purpose by any person other than the party to whom it is addressed without the written consent of that party, in any event, only with proper written qualification and only in its entirety. ✓ Neither all nor part of the contents of this report (especially any conclusions as to value, the identity of the appraiser, or the firm with which the appraiser is connected) shall be disseminated to the public through advertising, public relations, news, sales, or other media without the prior written consent and approval of the appraiser. ✓ No risk or guarantees have been purchased by the owner of this report. ✓ All values stated in this appraisal are the appraisers considered opinions based upon the facts and data set forth in this report. ✓ The appraiser, by reason of this appraisal, is not required to give further consultation, testimony, or be in attendance in court with reference to the property in question unless arrangements have been made previously. Page 25 EFTA00605258 Azatticut "islet Ngagarifteite TN& ✓ Aviation Asset Management, Inc. reserves the right to recall all copies of this report to correct any omissions or errors. ✓ No consideration has been given to any liens or encumbrances, which may be held against the assets being appraised. ✓ Aviation Asset Management Inc. expects the Lender or any other party, with regard to the subject-appraised inventory to conduct their own due diligence before determining and entering into any loan arrangements and shall not base any loan or borrowing base solely on the opinions of Aviation Asset Management. ✓ The maximum liability of Aviation Asset Management Inc for the breach of any obligation in connection with this engagement or the Report, and for any and all damages of any type or nature (whether in contract or in tort, and whether compensatory, consequential or punitive in nature) sustained or claimed by the Company(ies) or any other person or entity in connection with this engagement or the Report, shall be limited to the fee actually received by AAMI under the engagement agreement. In no event or circumstance shall AAMI have any liability to the Company(ies) or any other person or entity in excess of the fee actually paid to and received by AAMI under the engagement agreement. ✓ This appraisal is based upon the various types of values as defined in the Definition section of this report. ✓ This study and appraisal was accomplished by Aviation Asset Management, Inc. and will be held confidential. An experienced appraiser has prepared the appraisal and the analysis and conclusions are arrived at from many years of experience in the appraisal industry. ✓ We reserve the right to include your company name in our client list. AAMI will maintain the confidentiality of all reports, documents, and conversations provided to us for the preparation of this report, subject to any legal proceedings. ✓ This appraisal has been prepared in conformity with the Principles of Appraisal Practice and the Code of Ethics of the American Society of Appraisers. Page 26 EFTA00605259 Atatteon Asset Vtanagenfact Tee APPRAISERS CERTIFICATION We certify that to the best of our knowledge and belief: ✓ The statements of fact contained in this report are true and correct. ✓ The reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported assumptions and limiting conditions, and are my personal, impartial, and unbiased professional, opinions, and conclusions. ✓ I have no present or prospective interest in the property that is the subject of this report, and no personal interest with respect to the parties involved. ✓ I have no bias with respect to the property that is the subject of this report or to the parties involved with this assignment. ✓ My engagement in this assignment was not contingent upon developing or reporting predetermined results. ✓ My compensation for completing this assignment is not contingent upon the development or reporting of predetermined value or direction of value that favors the cause of the client, the amount of the value opinion, the attainment of a stipulated result, or the occurrence of a subsequent event directly related to the intended use of this appraisal. ✓ My analyses, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and this report has been prepared, in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice. ✓ The signatories on this report all provided significant assistance in the compilation of this report. ✓ The American Society of Appraisers has a mandatory recertification program for all of its Senior members. All Accredited Senior Appraisers (ASA) signing this report are in compliance with that program. ✓ I / We have not previously appraised the property that is the subject of this assignment, within the three year period immediately preceding acceptance of this appraisal assignment. ✓ The aircraft was inspected by Daniel Rausch for this appraisal. niota Reta4C4 Accredited Senior Appraiser Page 27 EFTA00605260 Business/General Aviation Outlook 2016 Prepared By Aviation Asset Management Inc. EFTA00605261 Aveatest Aa42et 21tanagesient Tat Aviation Outlook The following information is taken from numerous industry sources, including General Aviation Manufacturers Association (GAMA), Honeywell Aerospace Forecasts, Boeing, Embraer, Airbus Industries, Cessna Aircraft Corporation, Federal Aviation Administration, IATA, ATA, and the National Business Aircraft Association (NBAA). Inventories of pre-owned business jets for sale are climbing again, and the number of aircraft for sale in the six- to 10-year age range is at an all-time high. The inventory of business jets for sale inched up a percentage point in January, reaching 11 percent of the installed base of aircraft. Young aircraft for sale, those five years or younger, went up 2 percent in January and 1 percent over 2015. While this is still 63 percent less than peak, the inventory of slightly older aircraft for sale, those between six and 10 years old, jumped 19 percent over 2015 and is now above the 2009 absolute peak. In the six- to 10-year range, the number of large-cabin aircraft for sale has reached 12 percent of the installed base. The General Aviation Manufacturers Association (GAMA) announced that total worldwide general aviation (GA) airplane shipments fell 4.6 percent, from 2,376 units in 2014 to 2,267 units in 2015. Billings for GA airplanes also dropped to $20.9 billion, down 4 percent from $21.8 billion in 2014. Business Jet shipments were relatively flat, up 1.6 percent, from 644 units in 2014 to 654 units in 2015. Piston-engine airplanes fell for the first time since 2010, down 6.5 percent, from 1,129 units in 2014 to 1,056 units in 2015. Turboprop airplane shipments also declined, from 603 units in 2014 to 557 units in 2015, a 7.6 percent drop. 2015 AIRCRAFT SHIPMENTS OF AIRPLANES MANUFACTURED WORLDWIDE Manufactured Worldwide Manufactured in U.S. Only* 2014 2015 Change 2014 2015 Change Pistons 1,129 1,056 -6.5% 788 783 -6.4% Turboprops 603 557 -7.6% 468 420 -18.6% Business Jets 722 718 -0.6% 375 389 +3.7% Total Shipments 2,454 2,331 -5.0% 1,631 1,592 -2.4% Page 29 EFTA00605262 Adalecut Awe 21teutagement lac Bombardier delivered 199 business jets last year and expects shipments to drop by nearly a quarter this year, to about 150 business aircraft. Bombardier's business aircraft deliveries in 2015 comprised 73 Global 5000/6000s, 68 Challenger 300/350s, 25 Challenger 605/650s, one Challenger 850 and 32 Learjet 70/75s. Gross business jet sales also fell to 119 aircraft, from 181 in 2014. After accounting for Learjet 85 cancellations and restructuring certain customer agreements in the third quarter, net sales were -21, compared with 129 in the previous year. Dassault Falcon sales declined by 72 percent in 2015 compared with 2014. In 2015, Dassault reported 45 gross Falcon sales, but a NetJets cancellation of 20 Falcon 2000s brought the net tally to just 25 aircraft. A disappointing 55 new Falcons were delivered in 2015 versus an expected 65, which would have put 2015 on par with 2014. The backlog included 91 Falcons, compared to 121 Falcons one year before. Embraer delivered a total of 221 business jets and airliners in 2015, marking its highest number of aircraft shipments in five years. Deliveries were up by 13 aircraft year- over-year, with both its executive aviation and commercial aviation units making gains. The Brazilian manufacturer handed over 120 business jets in 2015, the most since 2010, when it shipped 144. Deliveries were up by four aircraft over the 116 delivered in 2014. The 2015 shipments included 82 Phenoms and 38 of the larger jets, which include the Legacy 450, 500 and 600 and Lineage 1000. In 2014, Phenoms accounted for 92 of the deliveries and larger jets the remaining 24 deliveries. Business And General Aviation Airplane Shipment Report 2015 versus 2014 Manufacturer Model 2015 2014 Airbus ACJ (A318, A319, A320, A330) 4 5 AT-401B & 402A & B 12 21 AT-502A & B 36 62 Air Tractor AT-504 AT-602 3 18 3 14 AT-802 8 10 AT-802A/F/AF 41 36 Page 30 EFTA00605263 liventbut 74444 71(anagesiat 'Zee Manufacturer Model 2015 2014 7EC Champ 1 1 7ECA Aurora 1 2 7GCAA Adventurer 0 0 American Champion 7GCBC Citabria Explorer 0 3 8GCBC Scout 6 7 8KCAB Super Decathlon 6 14 8KCAB Extreme Decathlon 5 3 BBJ 4 3 BBJ2 1 2 Boeing BBJ3 B777-300Er 1 1 0 1 B787-8 2 4 B787-9 2 0 Learjet 70/75 32 33 Learjet 60XR 0 1 Bombardier Challenger 300/350 68 54 Challenger 604/605 25 36 Global 5000/6000 73 80 CL850/870/890 1 0 Cirrus SR20 31 31 Cirrus Design Corp. Cirrus SR22 128 117 Cirrus SR22T 142 160 CC11 Sport Cub S2 0 0 CubCrafters CC11 Carbon Cub SS 47 53 CC18 Top Cub 5 7 Daher TBM 900 55 51 Dassault Falcon Jet Falcon 900LX/2000LXS/7X 55 66 HK36 1 0 DA20-C1 22 16 Diamond Aircraft DA40 75 136 DA42 Twin Star 44 50 DA62 2 0 Phenom 100/300 82 54 Embraer Legacy 500/600/650 35 8 Lineage 1000 31 2 Shuttles (ERJs and E-Jets) 0 0 Extra Aircraft AE300 27 31 Flight Design GmbH ASTM CT Series 59 88 Gulfstream G150/280 G450//550/650 34 120 33 117 Honda Aircraft Co. HA-420 HondaJet 2 0 Page 31 EFTA00605264 ,74,mthut Aadet Vtanagement Tat Manufacturer Model 2015 2014 i Mahindra Aerospace Airvan 8 14 17 Maule Air MX-7-180B M-9-235 12 1 1 0 Mooney Aircraft M20R Ovation M20TN Acclaim 3 8 0 1 One Aviation Corp. Eclipse 550 7 12 Pacific Aerospace PAC 750XL 5 4 Piaggio Avanti / II 3 2 PC-6 4 10 Pilatus PC-12 70 66 PA-28-161 Warrior III 20 3 PA-28-181 Archer III 25 45 PA-28R-201 Arrow 5 8 PA-34-220T Seneca V 8 10 Piper PA-44-180 Seminole 17 22 PA-46-350P Malibu Mirage 34 37 PA-46-350T Matrix 2 11 PA-46-500TP Meridian 27 36 Quest Aircraft Kodiak 100 32 30 ASTM-LSA 102 108 P2002JF 20 18 P92JS 4 7 Tecnam Aircraft P2002JR 0 0 P2008JC 24 36 P2006T 21 21 P2010P Twenty Ten 20 0 Textron Aviation Beechcraft Corporation Bonanza G36 23 32 Baron G58 18 40 King Air C90GTx 15 21 King Air 250 28 35 King Air 3501/ER 74 71 CE-1725 Skyhawk SP 143 155 Cessna CE-182T Skylane 33 0 CE-T206H Turbo Stationair 51 43 CE-240 TTx 44 22 CE-208 & 208B Caravan 102 94 CE-510 Citation Mustang 8 8 CE-525 Citation M2 41 46 CE-525B Citation CJ3+ 22 18 CE-525C Citation CJ4 33 28 CE-560 Citation XLS 21 22 CE-680 & 680A Sovereign 34 28 CE-750 Citation X+ 6 9 Page 32 EFTA00605265 Agatha Aaeet ?Management Tat Manufacturer Model 2015 2014 S2R-T34 8 10 S2RHG-T65 0 0 Thrush Aircraft Inc S2R-T660 7 1 S2R-G10 0 1 S2R-H80 14 24 WACO Aircraft Co. 2T-1A-2 YMF-5D 6 4 6 5 Grand total: Shipments 2,331 2,454 The Business/General Aviation Fleet Honeywell is forecasting up to 9,200 new business jet deliveries worth $270 billion from 2015 to 2025, with a 3 to 5 percent reduction over the value noted in the 2014 forecast. Honeywell forecasts 2014 deliveries of approximately 675 to 725 new jets in 2015, a single-digit percentage growth year over year. The improvement in deliveries expected in 2015 is largely due to new model introductions and an increase in fractional-usage type of aircraft deliveries. 2016 deliveries are projected to be slightly lower reflecting weaker emerging market demand partially offset by deliveries to fractional operators. Operators surveyed plan to make new jet purchases equivalent to about 22 percent of their fleets over the next five years as replacements or additions to their current fleet. Of the total new business jet purchase plans, 19 percent are intended to occur by the end of 2016, while 17 and 20 percent are scheduled for 2017 and 2018, respectively. Operators continue to focus on larger-cabin aircraft classes, ranging from super mid- size through ultra long-range and business liner, which are expected to account for more than 80 percent of all expenditures on new business jets in the near term. The longer-range forecast through 2025 projects a 3 percent average annual growth rate despite the relatively flat near-term outlook as new models and improved economic performance contribute to industry growth. Page 33 EFTA00605266 Aveateat Awe 21teutagement lac The worldwide business aircraft fleet continued to grow in 2015. There were 35,682 turbine airplanes at the end of 2015 compared to 34,755 airplanes in 2014. The number of active operators is also growing; A the end of 2015, there were 21,339 business airplane operators. After several years of decline, the fractional aircraft fleet has stabilized. In 2015 there were 837 aircraft used in fractional operations, up from 823 in 2014, and the number of fractional owners was 4,369 slight decline from 2014. when there were 4,402 owners. 2014-2015 Business Jet Deliveries 240 - 200 - 160 - 120 - 80 40 - 0 5 4 10 11 204199 159166 66 55 116120 1501`54 P H Airbus Boeing Bombardier Textron Dassault Embraer Gufstream ❑2014 MI2015 The active general aviation fleet is projected to increase at an average annual rate of 0.4 percent over the 21-year forecast period, growing from an estimated 198,860 in 2014 to 214,260 aircraft by 2035. The more expensive and sophisticated turbine-powered fleet (including rotorcraft) is projected to grow to a total of 45,905 aircraft at an average rate of 2.4 percent a year over the forecast period, with the turbine jet portion increasing at 2.8 percent a year, reaching a total of 20,815 by 2035. Page 34 EFTA00605267 Ameation Ada Nanagement Ime ACTIVE GENERAL AVIATION AND AIR TAXI AIRCRAFT FOR 2015 nSingle-Engine Piston 122,435 Multi-Engine Piston 13,175 Turboprop and Turbo Jet 21,305 Experimental/Sport 27,235 i-IRotorcraft and Other 10,440 Business/General Aviation Market Forecast According to the 2016 Business Aviation Forecast, the world's western produced in- service business fleets will increase from 31,000 aircraft in 2016 to nearly 38,000 aircraft at the end of 2025, a growth rate of 2.3% annually. Additionally, the 10-year demand for maintenance, repair and overhaul (MRO) in the business market is expected to be $121.8 billion. The 2016 forecast expectations show that the North American market will dominate the world sales and MRO demand for years to come; and will also have a vibrant fleet replacement cycle with nearly 3,400 aircraft retirements and over 8,000 aircraft deliveries. Other key findings from the 2016 Business Aviation Forecast Summary include: 1. Ultra Long Range category jets will grow fleet share the fastest along with Super Mid Size category aircraft growing nearly as fast ending the year 2025 with nearly 3,200 aircraft. Very Light Jets will grow its category share rapidly to over 1,500 aircraft over the next 10 years. 2. China, with a small base fleet, will grow the fastest fleet at 9% and MRO requirements despite economic and political pressures; the largest market, North America, will grow at 2.3% rate. 3. North America's in-service fleet share will remain constant during the forecast period at 63.5% while Western Europe will increase its share to 12.5% of the Page 35 EFTA00605268 Aveareda .4444 Neutagenrent Sac world's fleet. Latin America and Africa will lose fleet share, with Eastern Europe and China gaining fleet share. 4. The top five aircraft deliveries are expected to be: King Air 300/350, Pilatus PC- 12, Gulfstream G650, Challenger 300/350 and Phenom 300. Bombardier estimates that 9,000 new business jets worth $267 billion will be delivered over the next decade. Although the light jet segment is expected to provide the best sellers in terms of numbers, with 3,400 sales forecast, it offers the lowest share of the revenue, totalling $39 billion, and only a 2.4-percent annual growth rate. 10-Year Business Aircraft Fleet Forecast 24,000 21,000 18,000 15,000 12,000 9,000 6,000 3,000 0 22 91 0 15,735 9000 1825 0 2014 Fleet ❑ Deliveries ❑ Retirements O Fleet 2024 The midsize category fares a bit better, with a projected growth rate of 3.8 percent. Conversely, sales in the large-cabin arena are expected to cover 2,500 aircraft that generate $137 billion in sales, with an expected annual growth rate of 9.6 percent. Regional analysis suggests that the North American market will continue to lead the way in terms of numbers, with 3,900 new sales, but at a growth rate of only two percent. Europe is expected to generate 1,525 sales, with a growth rate of seven percent. One of the criteria examined by Bombardier in its analysis is regional penetration, measured by how many business jets represent each $1 trillion of GDP. In the U.S. the figure is 600, while in Page 36 EFTA00605269 Aotateat 21teutagestent Sac Europe it is just 80. This suggests to Bombardier that there is considerable potential in the European market for greater penetration. Bombardier's analysis sees the slowdown in business aviation in China and Russia as being short-term effects, and that both markets, along with other developing regions such as Latin America, will contribute to the market growth in the longer term. For instance, Bombardier estimates an annual fleet growth rate of 13 percent for China and six percent for Russia/CIS Embraer's market analysts have revised their 10-year forecast for business jets predicts sales of 9,100 aircraft worldwide worth $259 billion. This represents a modest annual growth rate of 3 percent, as well as a slight increase in deliveries compared with the previous decade, at 8,190 business jet shipments worth $198 billion. Once again the North American market drives the demand with 4,850 units worth $130 billion, followed by Europe and Africa with 2,100 jets worth $64 billion; the Middle East and Asia-Pacific with 1,500 aircraft worth $54 billion; and Latin America with 650 airplanes valued at $11 billion. Large jets will lead the market both in terms of number of units and valuation at 3,400 and $175 billion, respectively. But midsize jets are expected to regain some traction, selling 3,280 worth $66 billion, which is good news for Embraer's new Legacy 450 and 500. Meanwhile, while the light jet market will continue to struggle, with estimated deliveries of 2,420 worth $18 billion. While other regions of the world are lagging, the North American market is steadily improving, accounting for 66 percent of deliveries in the third quarter this year. Page 37 EFTA00605270 Acatteda Aidet 2ganagement lac Appraiser Qualifications Aviation Asset Management, Inc. (AAMI) was founded in August, 1997. The experienced staff at AAMI brings over 100 years of aviation experience in an integrated consulting group. We provide financial/technical services, appraise and physically inspect individual aircraft, fleets, support inventory, tooling and equipment. AAMI's staff is composed of professionals who have held key operational, maintenance, financial and marketing positions at airlines, business flight operations, and aviation consulting firms and possess an intimate knowledge of the worldwide aviation industry. AAMI is able to provide both aviation and investment clients with the highest level of resources and experience. Our experience includes work for air carriers, aircraft manufacturers and corporate clients, attorneys, banking, finance, leasing and investment concerns, federal and local assessing, taxing authorities, government and military authorities, insurance companies, and repair stations. AAMI is able to provide hands-on management as well as expert strategic analysis to meet our client's requirements. AAMI is able to provide expertise tailored to each individual client while maintaining an overall "big picture" perspective of how each client's needs relate to the company's goals and the larger worldwide aviation industry. * Dan Rausch is a member of The American Society of Appraisers (ASA) and is an Accredited Senior Appraiser. • Member of International Society of Transport Aircraft Trading (ISTAT) and is an ISTAT Certified Appraiser. * Member of National Business Aviation Association (NBAA) * Member of Helicopter Association International & Member of the Aviation Suppliers Association it Special Magistrate for Ad Valorem Tangible Personal Property Taxes ASSET MANAGEMENT SERVICES 4- Inventory Appraisals 4- Aircraft Appraisals and Value Forecast 4- On-Site Maintenance Representation 4- Aircraft Surveys 4- Maintenance Records Audits 4- Portfolio Management & Monitoring 4- Tax Letters 4- Expert Testimony and