Document text
0 of 3 Premium Clicks used this month SUBSCRIBE Print + Online Subscriber Activation | Register x Forgot Password | Need an Account? subscribe | newsletter | deals Home News Latest Stories 10 things to know for Friday They got algorithm Posters about missing teen will be distributed Competition keen at first city chili cookoff Alice Hardesty shares healing memoir Education Ashland schools expand chicken pox exclusion rules Students go behind the scenes at hospital Ashland robotics team aims to build a winner AHS ranked No. 7 by Niche College debt load balloons: What could, should be done? Environment The top five conservation success of 2014 Protestors want Keystone pipeline plans stopped New wandering wolf arrives in Southern Oregon Turning fire fuel threat into wood stove heat Ashland watershed trails would change under proposal Business Ride & Drive: 2015 Cadillac Escalade Brammo bought by Polaris They have a plan Ashland coffee roasters win nationwide honors Chamber's Business Resource Portal offers tools for success Politics and elections Chief Holderness retiring, wants to help find successor State News New wandering wolf arrives in Southern Oregon Police officer shoots armed driver near Reedsport Nation - World Obama makes Maduro’s ‘insolent Yankees’ line harder to sell Obituaries Elizabeth Hope Garrett Death Notices Harry Theodore Hertz Death Notices Marvin Leo "Bud" Gettling Shareable Looking back: Do you remember 2014’s biggest stories? In memoriam: 2014’s notable deaths Sports Latest Stories Respect: sock it to him A Grizz sweep Heisman winner Mariota says he's going to the NFL Comets press past Grizzlies Buckeyes won title behind line play, Elliott and Jones High school A Grizz sweep Comets press past Grizzlies Raiders put on a show Graham sparks Grizzly rout Ashland drops MWL opener to Marist Southern Oregon University Heisman winner Mariota says he's going to the NFL Buckeyes won title behind line play, Elliott and Jones Sayre says character key to SOU's success Ducks grounded Raiders put on a show Opinion Latest Stories Kent Bush: Capital punishment raises questions Our View: A matter of survival Letters to the Editor, Jan. 16 Other Views: Get GMO rules right Editor's Notes: We were wrong Editorial Our View: A matter of survival Other Views: Get GMO rules right Our View: No benefit from LNG pipeline Our View: Putting slash to work Our view: Protect Ashland's crown Letters Letters to the Editor, Jan. 16 Letters to the Editor, Jan. 14 Letters to the Editor, Jan. 5 Letters to the Editor, Dec. 31 Letters to the Editor, Dec. 29 Guest opinions Guest Opinion: Bikes, hikers/equestrians need separate watershed trails Guest Opinion: SOU biomass burner would be big mistake Guest Opinion: City hiring policy is fair, unbiased Another view: Cheney defends nation's journey into darkness Herb Rothschild Jr.: Fury impedes justice Revels Latest Stories Thanks for the Memories Theatre presents 'Cardenio' Best Bets: Jan. 15-22 A look at the life and vision of Martin Luther King Jr. 'Spotlight' highlights Orbison's life, music 'Selma' struggle remains relevant today Theater Insights into the gifts theater offers off the stage Theater is an act of co-creation ACT presents reading of 'The Quality of Life' Music Jeff Kloetzel at Belle Fiore The Farr Side: Top 10 album count-up for 2014 Visual Art Schneider winter exhibits on tap: 'Baker's Dozen' and 'New Works' First Friday kicks off a new year Movies Movie review: ‘Blackhat’ is a frustrating 404 error Movie review: ‘A Most Violent Year’ is a gritty look at oily dealings in ’80s New York Movie review: Clint Eastwood shines as director in ‘American Sniper’ 'Selma' struggle remains relevant today Interview: Bradley Cooper discusses working with Clint Eastwood on ‘American Sniper’ Food and Drink Food for Thought: Wintertime wining and dining Cruelest Month: Poetry Blog Lifestyle Latest Stories Ride & Drive: 2015 Cadillac Escalade Dr. Jeff Hersh: Heart test causes undue alarm Dr. Murray Feingold: How reliable is the medical information we read? Looking Up: Comet passes by the Pleiades Suzette Martinez Standring: Chance advice was eerie Aging Happens Inner Peace Column Inner Peace Blog Classifieds Jobs Autos Real Estate FEATURED » Obituaries Photos Videos Blogs Business NEWS NOW Our View: A matter of survival ... Posters about missing teen will be distributed ... Brammo bought by Polaris ... Our View: A matter of survival ... Posters about missing teen will be distributed ... Brammo bought by Polaris ... GUEST OPINION Guest Opinion: SOU biomass burner would be big mistake Comment By Bob Palzer and Paul Fouch DailyTidings.com By Bob Palzer and Paul Fouch Posted Jan. 14, 2015 @ 12:01 am By Bob Palzer and Paul Fouch Posted Jan. 14, 2015 @ 12:01 am » Social News We are shocked that Southern Oregon University is proposing to replace its natural gas boilers with a highly polluting biomass cogeneration operation. Decades of effort by industrial sources and individuals has reduced the use of wood for heat or power in the Rogue Valley. Now SOU proposes to haul wood waste from up to 50 miles away to burn on campus under the erroneous assumption that it will reduce carbon emissions, while trivializing the significant increase in particulate matter (PM) pollution. We challenge SOU, city and county officials to invoke a moratorium on this project to determine its legality and further evaluate its negative effect on the image, livability, health and air quality of Ashland and the sustainability of our tourist-reliant economy. We also challenge concerned citizens to evaluate the truthfulness of pro-biomass contentions posted on the SOU biomass website compared with information on the Save Our Rural Oregon and Rogue Group Sierra Club websites http://stopklamathbiomass.wordpress.com/ and http://oregon.sierraclub.org/groups/rogue/. See also http://www.energyjustice.net/content/biomass-library-scientific-reports. Then please contact SOU and city of Ashland officials and plead with them to install the far better natural gas option. The SOU Cogeneration website states the goal is to reduce operating costs and carbon emissions. Although officials admit a new gas-fired cogeneration system would emit far less toxic air emissions than a biomass system, they marginalize its significance. The Medford-Ashland area once had the third-highest PM pollution in the United States. A broad spectrum of stringent measures has brought this area into compliance with PM health standards. However, this area still has extensive periods of air stagnation when individuals must stop using woodstoves or operate them with no visible emissions, while the biomass incinerator would continue burning wood 24/7. Furthermore, startup, shutdown and burning wet, dirty or frozen fuel and other factors will produce multi-fold higher PM emissions. SOU is focused on the short term and not the long-term viability of the project. It asserts that natural gas prices will keep rising and biomass prices will always be lower because current governmental subsidies, energy credits and other inducements will be permanently available. This ignores the fact that natural gas prices have been dropping for several years and are lower than their average price for the past 15 years. We contend the prices for both fuels will vary and cannot accurately be predicted over the long term by anyone. Biomass would have to be trucked in by ugly chip trucks emitting hazardous pollution and noise and causing conflicts with school buses and cars on narrow Ashland streets. Biomass is far dirtier than clean-burning natural gas, which is readily available. An OSU forestry professor succinctly states: "Biomass has a lower energy density than fossil fuels, and is inefficient because its generally high moisture content requires that energy be expended to evaporate water before useful energy can be obtained. Because wood burns at a lower temperature than fossil fuels, the efficiency of electricity production is also lower. This means that in practice, burning biomass emits 150 percent of the carbon dioxide of coal, and 300-400 percent of the carbon dioxide of natural gas, per kilowatt of electricity generated.'’ Forests store carbon from the atmosphere. When burned, all the carbon that has been sequestered is instantly released back into the atmosphere. If trees grow back on those sites it would take multiple decades or longer to sequester an equivalent amount of carbon. That is beyond SOU’s goals to obtain carbon neutrality by 2050. This facility will be in a residential neighborhood close to three large schools. Rather than an inconspicuous incinerator hidden on the campus, it will be highly visible as it emits ugly bellows of smoke and steam on a 24/7 basis. The uncontrolled chip pile will emit a similar volume of noxious emissions. If SOU really wants to support the local economy and to provide leadership in integrating the principles of environmental, social and economic sustainability into campus planning and operation, it will drop its biomass proposal and go with the less problematic natural gas option. Bob Palzer, PhD, is a retired SOU chemistry professor who has worked on improving air quality since moving to Ashland in 1986. He is also vice chairman of the Rogue Group Sierra Club. Paul Fouch, PE, is a retired manufacturing engineer living in Klamath Falls who has taught for 12 years at OIT and 3 years at SOU. He is currently president of Save Our Rural Oregon, which focuses on improving the air quality and livability in Southern Oregon communities.   By Bob Palzer and Paul Fouch DailyTidings.com By Bob Palzer and Paul Fouch Posted Jan. 14, 2015 @ 12:01 am » Comment or view comments Reader Reaction » STAY INFORMED Email NewsLetter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. calendar Connect with DailyTidings.com Facebook Twitter RSS Back to top Reader Services Reader Services home Subscriptions Subscriber controls Contact us Submissions Photos Events Letters to the editor Corrections Alerts Email alerts RSS feeds Text Alerts Advertise Media Kit Home Products and services Ad rates Advertising contacts Mail Tribune Daily Tidings The Nickel Shop Our Valley Blogs Stay Informed Email newsletter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. Your privacy is important, read our privacy policy. © Copyright 2015 Local Media Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Local Media Group Publications Original content available for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons license, except where noted. DailyTidings.com | P.O. Box 1108, Medford, OR 97501