Document text
0 of 3 Premium Clicks used this month SUBSCRIBE Print + Online Subscriber Activation | Register x Forgot Password | Need an Account? e-edition | subscribe | newsletter | deals Home News Latest Stories Emergency Services Homework matters Reward upped to $10,000 in elk-poaching case I-5 stop leads to pot seizure, arrests Sewage sludge can be used on pastures Crime, Courts and Emergency Services Emergency Services Reward upped to $10,000 in elk-poaching case I-5 stop leads to pot seizure, arrests Fast-growing wildfire burns 100 homes in Weed, Calif. Onion Mountain fire now at 1,950 acres Politics and Elections Mark L. Hopkins: What the next election should be about Senate race could be expensive Talent to consider taxing recreational, but not medicinal marijuana Candidate files false statements Just one seat will be contested for Central Point council Education Homework matters HOLA program helps Latino students ease into college Phoenix-Talent gets grant to create teacher-leaders Alert system kept parents in the loop during shooting threat Ink Out provides inexpensive tattoo removal for those trying to move on Environment New disease strikes Roseburg deer herds Dredgers might return to the Rogue next year Dubs' auction preview draws bidders and gawkers OR-7's pups are true wolves ODFW director Elicker will step down State news Nation - World Obituaries Donna Jean Cunningham Cecilia Perry Leslie James Mathers Death Notices Wanda M. (Duval) Rasor Weather Photo Galleries Since You Asked Videos Web Cams Mail Tribune 100 Sports Latest Stories Comeback Eagles Cougars notch third triumph Vikings bring back Peterson despite abuse charge US uses big third quarter to pull away from Canada Linebackers to offer new setup this year Varsity 541 College Sports Raiders take hit on road Thompson leads Huskies to rout of Illini No. 2 Oregon pulls away from Wyoming Loyd nets emotional assist for Oregon No. 2 Ducks not looking past Wyoming Pro Sports Comeback Eagles Vikings bring back Peterson despite abuse charge A’s can determine wild-card fate When Bears attack Gates’ three TD catches carry Bolts to 30-21 upset Community Sports Barry fires back into SOGC finals Super seniors strong at SOGC Crenshaw pulls off upset in SOGC Murphy claims victory in Stroke Play Championships South Korea downs Chicago for World Series title Business Latest Stories Rogue Retreat thrift shop to open Sept. 30 Dutch Bros., 'Walking Dead' comic artist team up for new book Rogue Valley seeks to get on the map in search for new businesses Blog: Busy Week Survival Tips Purchasers praise Harry & David's turnaround Real Estate News Purchasers praise Harry & David's turnaround Historic building owners get lessons in restoration Pleasant weather, stable interest rates spurred summer home sales People In Business Transportation Agriculture Purchasers praise Harry & David's turnaround 1-800-Flowers.com buying Harry & David for $142.5 million Earlier than normal pear harvest coming up short of expectations Weisinger's Winery has earliest crush on record Amy's Kitchen begins expansion in White City Opinion Latest Other views: Privacy will be key to tech industry's future Letters to the Editor, Sept. 16 Granlund cartoon: Hillary in Iowa Letters to the Editor, Sept. 15 Catherine Rampell: Atlantic City is going broke, again Editorials Other views: Privacy will be key to tech industry's future Cover Oregon won't be mourned by many Balance needed in rules protecting streams Obama does what must be done in the Mideast Our View: Good riddance to Super PAC attack ads Letters to the Editor Letters to the Editor, Sept. 16 Letters to the Editor, Sept. 15 Letters to the Editor, Sept. 14 Letters to the Editor, Sept. 12 Letters to the Editor, Sept. 11 Guest Opinions Manor residents give in many ways Transparency is essential in O&C debate Hazardous fuel treatments vital to protection from severe wildfires Wilderness for Kalmiopsis has served us well The summer of my discontent: An open letter to Bill Rauch Lifestyle Latest stories Community blog: Taste cherry tomatoes to judge sweetness, acidity Rogue Valley's latest aerobics craze is Insanity Wedding Why did the chicken cross the road? Zucchini abuse: a national shame Food Community blog: Taste cherry tomatoes to judge sweetness, acidity Community blog: Rise to challenge of eating more local tomatoes Quail Run Vineyards expands into Talent drainage A cook's contest Community blog: Dukkah dresses up hummus, spreads and dippers Home and Garden Counting the reasons to keep your eating local Medford gardens to be showcased Saturday Trees aren't always the best companions for plants Hot tips for a cool (shade) garden An August checklist for your garden Health Rogue Valley's latest aerobics craze is Insanity Community blog: Menopause: What's it Good For? Community blog: A Fish Tale Community blog: A Healthy Way to Enrich the College Experience Community blog: What's Wrong With This Picture? Hiking Faith Religion Briefs Religion briefs Religion briefs Milestones and Achievements Wedding New Arrivals Barbecue will support treatment for stricken skateboarder Ink Out provides inexpensive tattoo removal for those trying to move on Grange memberships going like hot cakes Columnist for a Day Healthy Aging Tempo Latest stories Greg Frederick & Friends at The Wild Goose Dark Night of the Celtic Dream Paul Schmeling Trio at Martinos Jacksonville's Thai House is everything good Thai should be Creedence Clearwater Revival Theater Friends of Jim Giancarlo remember Ashland theater icon OCT's Ginger Rogers tribute sparkles 'Cocktail Hour' shows at the Craterian Theatre CultureFest at Oregon Shakespeare Festival Musical 'Backwards in High Heels' opens at Oregon Cabaret Theatre Music Greg Frederick & Friends at The Wild Goose Dark Night of the Celtic Dream Paul Schmeling Trio at Martinos Creedence Clearwater Revival Jeff Fest to feature an all-star lineup of musicians ... named Jeff Community Events Oregon Poet Laureate Peter Sears reads in Ashland Ashland's First Friday Art Walk showcases new exhiits by regional artists 5 Things to Do This Weekend From business professor to artist Shady Cove Tie Days Swap Meet Dining Jacksonville's Thai House is everything good Thai should be Ami Sushi serves up Asian dishes Wild River Brewing & Pizza Co. NW Raw Tempo Videos Classifieds Jobs Autos Real Estate FEATURED » Obituaries TV Listings Movie Listings Oregon Outdoors Oregon Healthy Living Magazines & Special Sections NEWS NOW Fast-growing wildfire burns 100 homes in Weed, Calif. ... Josephine County officials warn of fake evacuation orders ... Man struck by pickup after reported trespassing in Central Point ... Fast-growing wildfire burns 100 homes in Weed, Calif. ... Josephine County officials warn of fake evacuation orders ... Man struck by pickup after reported trespassing in Central Point ... ANOTHER VIEW Michael Gerson: Obama's careful war against the Islamic State MailTribune.com Writer Posted Sep. 12, 2014 @ 12:01 am Posted Sep. 12, 2014 @ 12:01 am » Social News The most compelling and encouraging parts of President Obama's Islamic State speech — his intention to "degrade and ultimately destroy" the enemy, his pledge to hunt down its fighters and deny them "safe haven," his moral clarity on their "acts of barbarism" — also sounded least like Obama. Everyone — and I mean just about everyone on the planet — knows that he was more comfortable declaring that America had moved "off a permanent war footing" and that the war on terrorism, "like all wars, must end." This is not merely a statement of the obvious. It illustrates the main problem with Obama's current approach to the rise of the Islamic State in Syria and Iraq. His newly announced policy consists mainly of previously discarded policies that would have been easier to pursue in the past: Supporting moderate rebels in Syria. Asserting executive authority to bomb on both sides of the border. Actively cooperating with Iraqi and Kurdish forces to build their capacity. It is reasonable to question the level of Obama's enthusiasm for a series of options he has previously ignored, dismissed or even mocked. (It wasn't long ago — actually about five weeks — that he called proposals to arm the Syrian rebels the outgrowth of a "fantasy.") Tim Arango, The New York Times Baghdad bureau chief, recently observed: "After 2011, the administration basically ignored the country [Iraq]. And when officials spoke about what was happening there, they were often ignorant of the reality." This was the period in which al-Qaida in Iraq — then seriously degraded — began to recover, gained a foothold in Syria, changed its name, attracted jihadist recruits, gained battlefield experience and resumed the offensive. So Obama's policy shift is late. For this reason, it has a reduced chance of success. It has, so far, attracted a distressingly small coalition of the willing. But the essence of the policy is reasonable. In his speech, Obama correctly identified some of the most important lessons of 9/11. First: disrupt the immediate terrorist threat — particularly the thousands of jihadists in Syria and Iraq (hundreds with American, European or Canadian passports) who might attack targets in the West. They present a short-term prospect of violence — a mass shooting or a bomb on a busy street. (And they are not alone, since various al-Qaida-related groups, particularly al-Qaida in Yemen, have continued to plot against U.S. targets.) A second lesson: prevent the scale of the threat from growing in territorial safe havens. From the time that Osama bin Laden gave the go-ahead for his hijacking plan, it was more than two and a half years until the complex, coordinated attacks of 9/11. Large-scale violence generally requires training, time and a base of operations. America's goal is to keep terrorist leaders harried, moving and fearful for their lives — unable to do their day jobs, which includes planning spectacular acts of murder. Territorial havens magnify the terrorist threat. America has successfully implemented this type of strategy before. Following 9/11, American forces drove al-Qaeda out of its camps in Afghanistan. Intelligence operatives pursued its leaders to safe houses in Pakistan. After a few years of building up its intelligence capacity, America found ways to track and strike terrorist leaders in Pakistan's remote Federally Administered Tribal Areas. Obama now has an even more difficult job. It should be possible, over time, to increase the capabilities of Iraqi and Kurdish forces (which are numerically superior to the enemy) and roll back the gains of the Islamic State in northern and central Iraq. Both the Iraqi army and the Kurdish peshmerga were initially unprepared for a battle-hardened opponent — but might, conceivably, be made prepared, with sufficient American support and training. The worse problem lies in Syria. Rolling back a safe haven is not done from the air alone. And the forces on the ground are either weak (the moderate rebels) or directed by a war criminal and Iranian puppet (Syrian government forces). Obama has correctly ruled out a rapprochement with Bashar al-Assad. But there are serious questions about the capacity of moderate rebels eventually to hold a Syrian state together. Suffice it to say, the American campaign in Iraq and Syria will take years and hit major obstacles: lack of intelligence infrastructure, disappointing allies, badly flawed options in Syria. It is one thing to have a strategy; another to pursue it with creativity and absolute resolve. And there is basis for skepticism in Obama's hedged and careful war. Michael Gerson's email address is [email protected]. MailTribune.com Writer Posted Sep. 12, 2014 @ 12:01 am » Comment or view comments Reader Reaction » STAY INFORMED Email NewsLetter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. calendar Connect with MailTribune.com Facebook Twitter RSS Back to top Reader Services Reader Services Home Subscriptions Subscriber controls Contact us Submissions Photos Events Letters to the editor Corrections Announcements Obituaries Story ideas Since you asked Alerts Email Alerts RSS Feeds Text Alerts Advertise Media Kit Home Products and services Ad rates Advertising contacts Mail Tribune Daily Tidings The Nickel Shop Our Valley Blogs Stay Informed Email newsletter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. Your privacy is important, read our privacy policy. © Copyright 2014 Local Media Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Local Media Group Publications Original content available for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons license, except where noted. MailTribune.com | P.O. Box 1108, Medford, OR 97501