Mining company faces long odds in Smith River proposal - News - MailTribune.com - Medford, OR

Mail Tribune (Medford, OR — Wayback)

2015-02-05

Document text

0 of 3 Premium Clicks used this month SUBSCRIBE Print + Online Subscriber Activation  |  Register x Forgot Password | Need an Account? e-edition | subscribe | newsletter | deals Home News Latest Stories Emergency services Since You Asked: Thunder in winter is a rare sound Police arrest Jackson Elementary arson suspect Counterfeit ringleader, co-conspirators sentenced Man sentenced in Highway 66 chase case Crime, Courts and Emergency Services Emergency services Police arrest Jackson Elementary arson suspect Counterfeit ringleader, co-conspirators sentenced Man sentenced in Highway 66 chase case Fire destroys Applegate trailer Politics and Elections Kent Bush: Fraud kept alive by the left and right Walden sets town halls on Friday Amid rising scrutiny, governor says fiancee won't have role in administration Ashland aims for diversity, but numbers show shortfall Kent Bush: The keys to decoding the State of the Union address Education SOU board names officers, committees SOU students targeted in Drive Less campaign Parent files discrimination complaint against Ashland schools Some gains, some losses Medford reconsiders full-day kindergarten Environment Commercial users can get rid of pesticide waste for free Jackson County looks at compensation for wolf kills Commissioners won't object to BLM road closures Mt. Ashland Ski Area crew dips to five Public sounds off on gas pipeline State News Senate committee advances Oregon low-carbon fuels bill Oregon hemp farmers can plant in spring UO students' cricket flour might put chirp in your step Oil prices raise questions about Coos Bay LNG plant Oregon class-action lawsuit bill advances Nation - World Obituaries Michael Lewis Carl Russell Davison Death Notices Jeanette �Jean� Stewart Carol Jerome Weather Photo Galleries Since You Asked Videos Web Cams Mail Tribune 100 Shareable Sports Latest Stories Curry erupts in comeback win Young passes 2,000 points in Oregon victory Eagles down Grizzlies in league dual Raiders ink 40 on signing day Olson to Montana highlights local signing day commitments Varsity 541 College Sports Young passes 2,000 points in Oregon victory Raiders ink 40 on signing day Andersen's scramble yields Oregon State prospects QB Waller is official as Ducks wait on Adams Syracuse self-imposes postseason ban Pro Sports Curry erupts in comeback win Lopez's return ignites Portland in victory Quinn lays out plan for Falcons Warriors rip Kings behind big first half In a first, Madden accurately predicts score Community Sports Local Events Business Latest Stories 1-800-Flowers dumps Harry & David execs Housing prices climb 9 percent in Jackson County Big plans on the Butte Harry & David helps grow revenue for 1-800-Flowers Ride & Drive: The 2015 BMW M4 Real Estate News Housing prices climb 9 percent in Jackson County Big plans on the Butte Homes for the long haul New owners of Medford Center promise a hands-on approach: Home loan rates continue to fall, applications soar People In Business People in Business Transportation The heart of Brammo will remain Want to be an investor? Four companies will be pitching their plan to you Medford airport traffic flies to new heights Agriculture 1-800-Flowers dumps Harry & David execs Nine companies pitch investment opportunities in Medford Darigold to shutter Medford plant, putting 29 out of work Opinion Latest Our View: Our growing disagreement with science Letters to the Editor, Feb. 5 George Will: Defining economic failure down Dana Milbank: Speaking from the high ground Kent Bush: Fraud kept alive by the left and right Editorials Our View: Our growing disagreement with science Our View: A gesture, but one worth making Our View: No reason to hurry pot-tax vote Our View: Wood-fired steam plant at SOU makes sense Other Views: Nothing to see here; move along Letters to the Editor Letters to the Editor, Feb. 5 Letters to the Editor, Feb. 4 Letters to the Editor, Feb. 3 Letters to the Editor, Feb. 2 Letters to the Editor, Feb. 1 Guest Opinions Guest Opinion: Health professionals don't always act that way Help wanted: The Medford School District needs you Guest Opinion: Market forces work against LNG project's success Guest Opinion: More reasons to oppose gas pipeline A fair shot for all: addressing our low-wage crisis Lifestyle Latest stories Marketta Gregory: Your dance matters Landscape lighting for beauty, safety and value 5 Things to Do This Weekend (Feb. 6-8) Lost in Suburbia: When the shoe is on the other cellphone Dear Monty: First time home buyer seeks differences in housing lifestyles Food Cupcake love affair Fish stew is a winter delight Community blog: Bone broth on hand makes for effortless flavor Food for Thought: Sweet potatoes are a versatile vegetable Gail Ciampa: Spinach contains an alphabet of vitamins Home and Garden Landscape lighting for beauty, safety and value Dear Monty: First time home buyer seeks differences in housing lifestyles Home Help: 3 upgrades sure to turn kitchen time into quality time Dear Monty: Is a home ‘trade-in’ a good idea? Buying a home? Consider its walkability Health Community blog: Five "Must Haves" Health Watch: Don’t let your fitness resolutions fizzle out Community blog: Toxic Love: How to Identify an Abusive Relationship Community blog: A Higher Walk To Better Health HealthStyle: Are you in an unhealthy relationship? Hiking Biking Faith Religion briefs Religion briefs, Jan. 23 Religion briefs Old stained-glass windows face threats Milestones and Achievements 50 years and counting: Bulebar Wedding: Lindsey-Maria Rios New arrivals Columnist for a Day Rogue Healthy Aging Tempo Latest stories Jacksonville celebrates Chinese New Year Camelot presents Playwright Richard Manley's 'A Question of Words' Here it is! Live Music in Local Clubs Terrapin Flyer plays Historic Ashland Armory Eric Johnson and Mike Stern at The Rogue Theatre Theater Camelot presents Playwright Richard Manley's 'A Question of Words' Classics, premiers highlight '15 season for OSF Randall Theatre presents playwright Charles Ludlam's comedy "The Mystery of Irma Vep" Roy Orbison tribute hits high note Thanks for the Memories Theatre presents 'Cardenio' Music Here it is! Live Music in Local Clubs Jesse Cook plays the Craterian Theater Shybo Torres plays South Stage Cellars Terrapin Flyer plays Historic Ashland Armory Trio Valtorna plays SOU Music Hall Community Events Jacksonville celebrates Chinese New Year Comedian Susan Westenhoefer pulls no punches Paula Poundstone performs at the Craterian Len Dickson's 'Fall Harvest' to grace Belle Fiore wine label A look at the life and vision of Martin Luther King Jr. Dining Sandwiches and burgers are hits at The Rogue Chef The Vine offers a taste of Italy Cheeseburgers on the cheap Valley View — It's all in the family Patty Groth's Morning Glory is still a delight Tempo Videos Classifieds Jobs Autos Real Estate FEATURED   » Obituaries Blogs TV Listings Movie Listings Oregon Outdoors Oregon Healthy Living Magazines & Special Sections NEWS NOW   Get Up & Go: Thursday, Feb. 5       ...       Our View: Our growing disagreement with science       ...       Police arrest Jackson Elementary arson suspect       ...       Get Up & Go: Thursday, Feb. 5       ...       Our View: Our growing disagreement with science       ...       Police arrest Jackson Elementary arson suspect       ...           ENVIRONMENT Mining company faces long odds in Smith River proposal Comment By Jeff Duewel Grants Pass Daily Courier MailTribune.com By Jeff Duewel Grants Pass Daily Courier Posted Feb. 1, 2015 @ 12:01 am By Jeff Duewel Grants Pass Daily Courier Posted Feb. 1, 2015 @ 12:01 am Metals Red Flat might find --> The Red Flat Nickel Corp. proposes to explore mining these metals in the North Fork Smith River area:  • Nickel. A hard, corrosion-resistant metal, most of the world's supp... » Read more X Metals Red Flat might find The Red Flat Nickel Corp. proposes to explore mining these metals in the North Fork Smith River area:  • Nickel . A hard, corrosion-resistant metal, most of the world's supply of nickel is mined in the Sudbury region of Ontario, Canada. Nickel is used in steel alloys, electroplating and the manufacture of wire as well as some types of coins and batteries. Because of its resistance to corrosion at even high temperatures, it is also used in gas turbines and rocket engines. Most nickel on Earth is inaccessible because it is locked away in the planet's molten core. • Cobalt . Usually recovered as a byproduct of mining and refining metals such as nickel, silver, lead, copper and iron, cobalt is used in electroplating, but is even more widely used to form alloys used in the manufacture of powerful magnets, cutting tools and dyes, jet engines and gas turbines, and some types of stainless steels. Cobalt compounds have been used to color porcelain, glass, pottery, tile and enamel, and is important to human nutrition as an essential part of vitamin B12. • Chromium . Very resistant to corrosion, chromium is a key ingredient in stainless steel and other alloys that are used to make armor plates, safes, ball bearings and cutting tools. Rubies and emeralds owe their color to chromium compounds, which are used in paints and other materials that permanently fix dyes to fabrics. • Scandium . Usually obtained as a byproduct of refining uranium, scandium is a soft, light metal that may have applications in the aerospace industry but is currently too expensive ($270 per gram, or $122,500 per pound) for widespread use. It is expected that scandium-aluminum alloys will be important in the manufacture of fuel cells. Compounds are used each year in the United States in the production of high intensity lights and mercury vapor lamps. »  Social News A mining company's plans to explore for rare metals near the North Fork Smith River just north of the Oregon-California border continue to inch forward, in the face of opposition from lawmakers and conservation interests. Red Flat Nickel Corp. proposed two years ago to drill 59 sample holes on 139 mining claims on more than 3,000 acres, hoping to one day mine nickel and possibly cobalt, chromium and scandium. "It's taking longer than we expected. We have to let the process play out with the Forest Service," said Obie Strickler, Red Flat's consulting geologist and project manager, who first staked the claims in 2007. "It's premature to talk about a mine. This is a very preliminary exploration into a mining project, with a number of steps. If any step doesn't go right, it stops the project." The project today is no more than wood stakes marking potential drill holes, but any mine faces long odds in this area draining the headwaters of two federally recognized Wild and Scenic Rivers — the Smith and the Illinois. The U.S. Forest Service hasn't approved any hard rock mining on the Rogue River-Siskiyou National Forest in many years. A proposal by Walt Freeman to mine nickel along Rough and Ready Creek near Cave Junction 20 years ago never came to fruition after U.S. Forest Service analysis and a series of legal battles. It won't be any easier for Red Flat, an Oregon corporation with a parent company, St. Peter Port Capital, based in Great Britain. On Jan. 21, California state Sen. Mike McGuire, D-Healdsburg, introduced legislation to protect the North Fork Smith River from mining. The North Fork Smith, a Wild and Scenic waterway rising on the south edge of the Kalmiopsis Wilderness, flows south into California and enters the Middle Fork at Gasquet, Calif. The Smith and all of its forks are prized for kayaking, rafting and steelhead and salmon fishing. The Smith is the longest undammed river in California. The potential mine site is located within a mile of Baldface Creek and two miles of the North Fork Smith. "Mining of any kind in the Smith River watershed is simply unacceptable," McGuire said in a news release. "I will work tirelessly to protect our river, which is one of the premier salmon fisheries in the lower 48 states and the source of drinking water for tens of thousands of residents in Del Norte County, including Crescent City." Strickler said he believes the project's potential impacts, particularly the drilling portion, have been overstated. "If I ever got to a point where I felt a company did things with the environmental process that weren't correct, I wouldn't work for them," he said. "I was born and raised in this area, and I agree the Smith is beautiful. I've taken my family there. I like to swim in it." But Strickler pointed out the need for metals. "I understand the need for this type of industry and the benefits it provides," he said. "These metals are very important to everyone's life. It's just a matter of where you get them. It's better to get them here where we have standards and regulations, than in less-regimented countries." Opposition has been heavy. The City Council of Crescent City and Del Norte County Board of Supervisors sent letters to oppose mining, according to the Del Norte Triplicate newspaper. Oregon Sens. Ron Wyden and Jeff Merkley have asked the Obama administration to withdraw the area from new mining claims, which already has happened to the south. All of the Smith River drainage in public ownership in California was withdrawn from mineral entry when the Smith River National Recreation Area was created in 1990. Barbara Ullian of Grants Pass said Red Flat shouldn't be surprised by opposition to despoiling "the watersheds of some of our last, best wild rivers and native salmon and steelhead streams." Ullian has spent more than two decades advocating for protection of wild rivers in the area. "Pollution flows downstream, and according to EPA, the metal-mining industry is the highest toxic polluter in the United States," she added. "So California has a huge stake in whether National Forest lands in Oregon can be grabbed by a foreign-controlled company to locate one of the dirtiest industries in the nation." Matt Paciorek, Wild Rivers District ranger in Cave Junction, said his agency is waiting for word from the Oregon Water Resources Department before proceeding with National Environmental Policy Act analysis. "At this point we haven't done any analysis on their proposal," Paciorek said. "All we have in front of us is the proposal to do the drilling and exploration. It would be premature to guess what they want to do after that." In a letter dated on Friday, Red Flat's attorneys — of the giant Pacific Northwest law firm Schwabe, Williamson & Wyatt — told the OWRD it would withdraw its application for water, saying, "We expect the Forest Service process will take up to an additional year." The water application to pull up to 10 gallons per minute from a small tributary was denied in October, then Red Flat's attorneys petitioned to have that order reconsidered. That petition was granted, but now the company says it will wait before applying again. In its annual report in December, Red Flat parent company St. Peter Port Capital wrote: "The approval process has taken far longer than was anticipated. As the principal shareholder and major economic interest in the company, we have increased our direct involvement in the project to try to bring this to a speedy conclusion." Reach Grants Pass Daily Courier reporter Jeff Duewel at 541-474-3720 or  [email protected] .   By Jeff Duewel Grants Pass Daily Courier MailTribune.com By Jeff Duewel Grants Pass Daily Courier Posted Feb. 1, 2015 @ 12:01 am » Comment or view comments   Reader Reaction »  STAY INFORMED   Email NewsLetter   Sign Up Today   Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. calendar Connect with MailTribune.com Facebook Twitter RSS Back to top Reader Services Reader Services Home Subscriptions Subscriber controls Contact us Submissions Photos Events Letters to the editor Corrections Announcements Obituaries Story ideas Since you asked Alerts Email Alerts RSS Feeds Text Alerts Advertise Media Kit Home Products and services Ad rates Advertising contacts Mail Tribune Daily Tidings The Nickel Shop Our Valley Blogs Stay Informed   Email newsletter   Sign Up Today   Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. Your privacy is important, read our privacy policy. © Copyright 2015 Local Media Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved.    Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service  |  Local Media Group Publications Original content available for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons license, except where noted. MailTribune.com | P.O. Box 1108, Medford, OR 97501