Trump Says His Voters Stayed Home. A Precinct Study Agrees, Except in Texas

Illustration for: Trump Says His Voters Stayed Home. A Precinct Study Agrees, Except in Texas
Trump said on CBS's 60 Minutes that his voters stayed home rather than turning against Republicans in the 2026 midterms. A precinct study of 13 states backs him nationally; in Texas, a large poll and the same study found more of the shift came from voters who switched. Democrats will hold the House and at least 55 Senate seats, so if they also win the presidency in 2028 they could change the size of the Supreme Court by law, unless the filibuster stops them.

The claim, checked

On CBS's 60 Minutes, aired November 8, 2026, Ross Douthat asked President Trump: "And people didn't? Or-- or did they? Did they vote because they were mad at you--" Trump answered: "I think they didn't vote, really. I think in some cases, they didn't like the candidates."

  • Nationally: Mostly right, by one precinct study. A precinct analysis of 13 states found most of the Democrats' gain came from Trump voters staying home, not switching. Exit polls point to more switching, but still less than the turnout effect.
  • In Texas: Partly right. Republican areas did turn out less than Democratic ones. But a large poll and the same precinct study found that in Texas more of the shift came from voters who switched, the explanation Trump turned down.

The national picture

Lenny Bronner, founder of Broome Street Labs and a data scientist formerly with the Washington Post, wrote on November 5: "Using precinct results from 11 states, we estimate ~75% of Democrats' net gain came from the turnout gap and ~20% from vote switching. Exit polls imply 35% nationally, but turnout still leads. 8 in 9 Trump voters who didn't vote GOP stayed home." Stateline reported on November 10 that his analysis covered 13 states, and quoted him: "It looks like more Trump voters who didn't vote Republican stayed home rather than switching (to Democrats)." It is one analyst's model, built on partial results.

After adding Texas, Bronner wrote on November 6: "So far, Texas is the only state where our model indicates that persuasion explains more of Democrats net gain than turnout does!" His Texas sample was 12 counties holding 63% of the vote.

What happened in Texas

The ABC News Texas Voter Poll surveyed more than 5,000 Texans who voted. ABC13 reported on November 6: "About one in nine Texans who voted for Trump in 2024 voted for Talarico on Tuesday." And: "Trump voters were 48% of Tuesday's electorate; Harris voters were 41%." "That is an electorate Trump would have carried by seven points. Talarico won it by 12." "The gap is persuasion." The same report found: "Latino voters, a quarter of the electorate, went 66-32, after splitting almost evenly in the 2024 presidential race."

Turnout still mattered. ABC13 reported: "The precincts that voted most heavily for Ted Cruz in 2024 cast 82% as many ballots as they did in that presidential year." "The precincts that voted most heavily for Colin Allred cast 91% as many."

Democrat James Talarico beat Republican Ken Paxton for U.S. Senate by 12.1 points, or 1,195,609 votes. Democrat Gina Hinojosa beat Gov. Greg Abbott by 7.1 points, or 706,262 votes. Abbott got 4,524,527 votes, 87,428 more than when he won in 2022. But Texas had 1,369,541 more registered voters than in 2022. As a share of registered voters, Abbott's vote fell from 25.11% in 2022 to 23.76%, down 1.35 points. The Democratic candidate's rose from 20.11% to 27.47%, up 7.36 points. These 2026 totals are unofficial.

A test of Trump's explanation: from 2020 to 2022, Republicans kept 75.33% of their presidential vote in the governor's race. Had they kept that same share of Trump's 2024 vote, Abbott would have had about 4,816,189 votes. He would still have lost to Hinojosa, by about 414,600.

Rural Texas turned out least. The Texas Tribune found rural turnout rose about 1.4 points from 2022, the smallest rise in the state, while urban turnout rose nearly 8 points. The Tribune reported: "Roughly 90% of the counties that saw a decrease in voter turnout were rural." About 800,000 rural Texans voted, about 8 percent of the statewide total. Guessippina Bonner, a former Lufkin City Council member, said: "There were Republicans here in East Texas that sat out, did not go to vote." Sid Miller, the outgoing Republican agriculture commissioner, said: "Rural Texas didn't have anybody to vote for tonight," and "They felt betrayed."

What is at stake for the court

The number of Supreme Court justices is set by law, not by the Constitution. It has been nine since 1869. On September 2, 2026, the House voted on H.J.Res. 1, a constitutional amendment to keep the court at nine. It failed, 212 to 206. It needed two-thirds of those voting. Republicans voted 211 to 0, with seven not voting. Democrats voted 205 to 1 against; Rep. Don Davis of North Carolina was the one Democrat in favor. Rep. Mary Gay Scanlon of Pennsylvania said: "This proposed constitutional amendment would undermine our system of checks and balances." Newsweek reported: "Republicans argued the proposal was necessary to prevent future efforts to expand, or 'pack,' the Supreme Court by adding additional seats."

Some Democratic leaders have backed more seats. Rep. Jim Clyburn of South Carolina said on NBC's Meet the Press: "A baker's dozen, it would be a good number to have on the court." Former Vice President Kamala Harris said: "we need to revisit the point of expanding the court to 13 justices like we have 13 District Courts." House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries said "dramatic Supreme Court reform is necessary," without endorsing more seats. Those quotes were reported by Deseret News on September 2.

Democrats will hold the House and at least 55 Senate seats in January. Slate reported on November 5 that they had flipped seven seats for 54; the Associated Press called Mississippi for Democrat Scott Colom on November 11. Alaska was still being counted. Trump can veto bills through January 2029. In the Senate, a bill to add seats would need 60 votes unless a simple majority first changes the filibuster rule. Fox News reported that Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer ignored questions twice about ending the filibuster.

Profoundd's read

Nationally, the best evidence so far backs Trump: by one precinct study, most of the Republican loss was voters who stayed home. That is one model, and exit polls show more switching.

Texas is the exception. Republican areas turned out less, but more of the change came from voters who switched, including many Latino voters. Republicans would have lost Texas even with their usual midterm turnout.

Both lessons point at 2028. If Democrats win the presidency and keep both houses, they could change the size of the court by law, if the Senate changes or gets past the filibuster. Two Democratic leaders have already named 13 seats.

Trump also blamed "a great dislike, incredibly, for Israel." Profoundd checked his promise that Israel aid ends this year, and the draft deal that runs to 2033.

Reporting through Sunday, November 15, 2026. Sources: CBS News, 60 Minutes transcript, Nov. 8; Lenny Bronner on X, Nov. 5; Lenny Bronner on X, Nov. 6; Stateline, Nov. 10; ABC13, ABC News Texas Voter Poll, Nov. 6; Texas Secretary of State, unofficial 2026 results; Texas Secretary of State, Oct. 16, 2026 registration; Texas Secretary of State, turnout history; NBC News, 2022 Texas governor results; Ballotpedia, 2020 Texas presidential results; The Texas Tribune, Nov. 4; U.S. House Clerk, Roll Call 293; Newsweek, court amendment vote; Deseret News, Sept. 2; Slate, Nov. 5; WRDW, Nov. 11; Fox News, Schumer and the filibuster.

Have an update to this story?

Send us a link. If it adds to or corrects what's here, we'll use it — after we've checked it.