Document text
1 of 3 Premium Clicks used this month SUBSCRIBE Print + Online Subscriber Activation | Register x Forgot Password | Need an Account? subscribe | newsletter | deals Home News Latest Stories 'Guitar Player' book recalls the heady days of the '70s and '80s Ashland budget proposal says solar power could attract investment Ashland High School water polo club seeks yard sale donations Final Ashland Middle School band concert of the school year set for May 20 Nashville singer/songwriter with Ashland ties dies of cancer Education Ashland Middle School students put their Spanish-speaking skills to the test Grizzlies claim speech championship Levy backers eye final push Neal Simon: This is a test Grade-school philanthropist Environment Ashland publisher offers prize for environmental book Ashland water bills could go up to fund watershed protection Stopping fire in its tracks Some trails, roads remain closed due to controlled burn Earth Day: Hope for our 'pale blue dot' Business Ride & Drive: 2015 BMW 428i Gran Coupe Ashland Safeway closes Thursday, to reopen as Haggen on Sunday Cars We Remember: Car enthusiast wishes new model designs were ‘more different’ Ride & Drive: 2015 Dodge Challenger SRT Hellcat Silvio Calabi: Taxis and traffic in the olde worlde Politics and elections Ashland water bills could go up to fund watershed protection BREAKING: Baltimore prosecutor charges officers in Gray's death Arthur I. Cyr: Cuba’s enduring challenge to American foreign policy – and American politics Kent Bush: Clinton 2.0 is neither new nor improved State News Lack of snow nixes ski portion of popular Central Oregon race Bill under debate in Oregon would limit livestock antibiotics Oregon lawmakers begin minimum wage debate Runners to follow historic salmon migration path Nation - World There's a $10 million precious stone hidden in plain sight at Grand Central Obituaries Kenneth Lee Nichols R. Charles "Charlie" Snyder Death Notices Harry D. Detwiler Death Notices Shareable Sports Latest Stories Raiders Maguin, Parks, Sanders highlight first day of CCC track meet Chris Singleton: No need for a rematch Ashland boys sweep doubles, beat GP Living on the edge SOU lands two on all-CCC softball team High school Raiders Maguin, Parks, Sanders highlight first day of CCC track meet Ashland boys sweep doubles, beat GP Living on the edge SOU lands two on all-CCC softball team Ashland softball team rolls past Springfield Southern Oregon University Raiders Maguin, Parks, Sanders highlight first day of CCC track meet SOU lands two on all-CCC softball team See you in August Same old Raiders Ashland softball team rolls past Springfield Voices Latest Stories Guest Opinion: Ambrose spins a conservative fantasy Herb Rothschild Jr.: The courage to ask James Jackson: Who’s driving your fear? Landgren cartoon: What the frack? Arthur I. Cyr: Britain’s important election – in royal political context Editorial Our View: Forest work is a bargain Our View: What price history? Our View: Waging peace after war Our View: Rail car roulette Our View: Reading the tea leaves Letters Letters to the Editor, May 8 Letters to the Editor, May 6 Letters to the Editor, May 5 Letters to the Editor, May1 Letters to the Editor, April 30 Guest opinions Guest Opinion: Ambrose spins a conservative fantasy Guest Opinion: Restoring the Plaza's sense of place Guest Opinion: Making conservation a game Guest Opinion: A good day to act Guest Opinion: Allegations unfair to Dr. Tomashefsky Columns Guest Opinion: Ambrose spins a conservative fantasy Herb Rothschild Jr.: The courage to ask Arthur I. Cyr: Britain’s important election – in royal political context Matthew T. Mangino: Aging prisoners: An American crisis Jeffrey Gillespie: Is there a right to offend? Chris Honore Council Corner Editor's Notes Jeffrey Gillespie Herb Rothschild Revels Latest Stories Peter Rowan, Big Sandy & His Fly-Rite Boys at Rootsfest Movie listings: May 8-14 Dancing People Company presents 'Salon Series' 5 picks for live entertainment Prepare for lots of dialogue in 'Clouds of Sils Maria' Theater Ticket availability Ticket Availability Ticket Availability 'Arsenic and Old Lace' has killer charm Some OSF crew members seek to unionize Music The Farr Side: Mumford & Sons’ latest is full-on rock Interview: Country singer Suzy Bogguss enjoying life on the road The Farr Side: CMAs do it right, in many ways Interview: Offspring plays hits new and old on tour The Farr Side: Slow disappearance of physical music Visual Art Movies Movie review: ‘Hot Pursuit’ is a hot mess George Miller returns to his ‘Mad Max’ roots Tom Hardy adapts to life as Mad Max Movie listings: May 8-14 Prepare for lots of dialogue in 'Clouds of Sils Maria' Food and Drink Taqueria Picaro takes over Tabu space Owner of Mix and Amuse to bring Flip burger joint to Ashland Cruelest Month: Poetry Blog Lifestyle Latest Stories Community Blog: Inspiration is the Oxygen of our Survival Inner Peace: Satyam, shivam, sundram (truth, consciousness, joy/beauty) Looking Up: Once in a while a star blows up Health Watch: Easy tips to drink more water throughout the day Orthodox Church raising funds to build new home Aging Happens Inner Peace Column Inner Peace Blog Mocha Musings Rogues: Tales from the Valley Classifieds Jobs Autos Real Estate FEATURED » Obituaries Photos Videos Blogs Business Business Services NEWS NOW Ashland Calendar, Saturday, May 9 ... Guest Opinion: Ambrose spins a conservative fantasy ... Herb Rothschild Jr.: The courage to ask ... Ashland Calendar, Saturday, May 9 ... Guest Opinion: Ambrose spins a conservative fantasy ... Herb Rothschild Jr.: The courage to ask ... RELOCATIONS Herb Rothschild Jr: Framing the debate Comment DailyTidings.com Writer Posted May. 2, 2015 at 12:01 AM Posted May. 2, 2015 at 12:01 AM » Social News This is the last of four columns exploring what happens when we address social issues from the differing perspectives of the individual or of the collective. In the first two I explained how differently the analysis plays out if we prioritize our freedom to act on our own perceived self-interests or we prioritize our obligation to support the collective good. Last week I shifted from the individuals’ obligation to enhance the collective good to the collective’s obligation to enhance the good of its members. That shift led to considering whether we should address problems like homelessness by asserting rights or mobilizing care. I expressed misgivings about coming up with new rights, such as a right to sleep in public places, as a substitute for properly caring for each other. And I promised to show how, in the case of abortion, doing so makes it simply impossible to resolve the problem. We have framed abortion as a rights issue — right to life versus right to choose. The former “right” logically dehumanizes the mother, dismissing almost all regard for her physical and mental well-being. She becomes an incubator. The latter “right” logically dehumanizes the unborn up until the moment of birth, including those last weeks (ever-increasing) when the process of abortion may result in a live birth unless the fetus is deliberately destroyed. This zero-sum conceptual approach has had dreadful consequences. It has pitted Americans against each other in an ideological and political contest with no end in sight. And it has obscured, even from ourselves, what the great majority of us in reality feel about abortion. We do care about mothers, and we begin caring about the unborn as they develop toward maturity. Careful polling reveals areas of significant consensus. Few of us want to force a woman to carry to term the product of rape or incest. And few of us sympathize with women (there aren’t many in this country) who use abortion as their birth control method of choice. Few of us care what happens to a zygote, whether it fails to attach to the uterine wall thanks to an IUD or never gets into a uterus because of in vitro fertilization. And few of us would be emotionally easy with the surgical killing of an eight-month foetus before it is expelled. Our practice reflects these feelings more accurately than do our debates. In sum, once we move from rights to care, from the isolated individual to the connected community, areas of agreement and possibilities of resolution open to us. We might begin by acknowledging that God is the great abortionist. The number of fertilized eggs that in the course of nature never come to term far exceeds those that do. Thus, there is no basis in reality for humans to legislate that they must. That acknowledgement should allow us to view the “morning-after pill” as a huge asset in avoiding a journey across what is an inherently difficult terrain. Along with more vigorous promotion of contraceptive technology, we should make the morning-after pill readily available and promote its use when circumstances indicate. Framing abortion as a rights issue tends to convince each ideological camp that it has a monopoly on care. Right-to-lifers brandish photos of late-term fetuses. Right-to-choosers brandish coat-hangers. It’s not their care that’s the problem; all care is commendable. It’s their pride. You’d think we would experience humility before the immense joys and sorrows of life and death, and therein affirm our common humanity. Herb Rothschild Jr. is chairman of the board of Peace House.         DailyTidings.com Writer Posted May. 2, 2015 at 12:01 AM » Comment or view comments Reader Reaction » STAY INFORMED Email NewsLetter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. calendar Connect with DailyTidings.com Facebook Twitter RSS Back to top Reader Services Reader Services home Subscriptions Subscriber controls Contact us Submissions Photos Events Letters to the editor Corrections Alerts Email alerts RSS feeds Text Alerts Advertise Media Kit Home Products and services Ad rates Advertising contacts Propel Marketing Mail Tribune Daily Tidings The Nickel Shop Our Valley Blogs Stay Informed Email newsletter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. Your privacy is important, read our privacy policy. © Copyright 2015 Local Media Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Local Media Group Publications Original content available for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons license, except where noted. DailyTidings.com | P.O. Box 1108, Medford, OR 97501