Document text
4
é
1
E1|I92
J
4
5
=122
5
;1
5
2
=;:
iFEDERAL BUREAU 011 1N VEST1GATi0N
JQSEPH MQCARTHY
PART 13 OF 28
BUFILE NUMBER: 121-23278
i
2
¥
iwBJE¢TFILE l92TUMI5ER- " i j 7
r-1-92/!1'1'l'f'92 YC>I492.¢-L LU
1». I1; 1:-t-t-I
'-7 .
3 flit;-92.' .' "V -~ _ 4
1-»;
. -.-.;:
Ii
e
"4,_ :-:73_:'see.-*2
_K ;'. -'-,f',-
-;~ ,14:1 . '
,, 7,:-_,._, 1
'._::,"1,v'n;i
dt*", W,
-+',~&-
if I3.. -'31., ii
.-15*:. 1, ' -TI-'. 1}; ' "'3-' _; .,z_ .
1;-T".?»,wae?
-- ,=.-z.- -> 71' 53
. "a-'1"-"' , J
-_-1-.:.". "*:-.,-5' -.1? 51:a'92.- - -_F: Qt:a1{-4'3'
.:=<',g,=*.
:.»"r;- .< 1.. . _,
-';=T?3_<:~.-
"' F3
' 1
F-§:3~":_~' ,-. _'-F4 :,'
. -1; 1
'-.2;1;-_';r~_-._P,92'r
' z;--:1
J! _ - __ _-92-*.'.=.= "W =2~ a¬~ 1-, .7:?I'_urL- .:."T-'§y'*r-¢.1-2
1- ', ,,".'1_-_'§:§=; _ {-,- 92 .a» ¢;=592'-'7i:a:.».§_: ;T:'.r5_--1;12??»-i.' _= -'.Y' L'";, 1 I -..::' - -.92
..;; J r ~_ Qsq»srmm :2 FORM vnfdA ,,_- _' In ' -' . 92Ojrt .»:»7l6ZZ£77Z - UNITED _S'I".4,,1.%S GOVERNMENT
To = was DIRECTOR 9 DATE: March 31, 1950
IP TnllnnFROM 2 Du Mo M . .» |_,-14
/7B ECT° I-'!] ~11 1,1 ,, S" J - C05.-H-IUNTSTS IN THE rs nEPAm.u.a.N'r /1,./1-s» H..-/ Names mmiehed 1: §Iff§s C"_ormn':I't'tee 3&3;"O" by Senator McCarthy! mi-' ;' ' /l LOYALTY OF ;OVEHNMENT EI92{PLOY'u1ES -d ;_ 1 Iqr 92 _P:U_RPOSE: To advise you concerning vmose Loyaltf." Form was returned to the Civil Service Commiss on on Marc 12, 19146, gaarked, a-=u_T__,
-_ I "L10 dis-loyal data, FBI files."
j.» }_3!92C1<.GROUE-TD: with reference to the attached memorandum to. March 26, l§;»O, setting forth an analysis of the cases furnished to92 rigs_. |_ COn"c.1ittee by Senator I-fcCar-thy, it will be noted that Case No. 68 is5| who is presently employed in the Department of State. In view o e
-1» -imormation in the B11-eau's files developed as a result of a previous
I-ation for the Office of the Coordinator of Information in April, 1.9112, itI 1 the B~l1"¬B.1J. may be vulnerable in view of the return of the Loyalty Form mwked, ,;i!-ere disloyaj. data, FBI files," on March 12, 719%. _ l¢_,___. - :7 4-"-
It W111 be noted that the lI'1I8Sl,1gEl'bi_OI1 in l9h2weve1.o ed information,_ similar to the char;-,es made by Senator McCarthy indicating well as hisI '1; parents , had signed a Conuuunist Party petition. Reports din the Special Inquiry,-_,' qfor Office of the Coordinator of Information were hxrniahed to that agency onQ April 3, 19142, and a summary of this information was lrnished to the State DepartL-ment on August 7, .L9h6, The Office of the Coordinator of Infonnation was the -,-_"" predecessor of the Office of War Information, and -was transferred to the >F, State Department from the Office of War Information._
STATUS: In View of the above, a._;ILl,_.i_.e1d_lcLy-alty __i.nye_sti§3;?-iii-9T1 hasbeen @ ' [L-which is being expedited and the a - n1n'furnished to the Civil ..>er1nce_C91mission and State __Depag'_tmegt_uD_0i1_3;l',§ coggletione,I
i
i1
l, - .
y ACTION: Hr. Nichols is inquiring into the circumstances surrounding theF. return of the Loyalty Form on -to the Civil Service Commission marked, "No
-J disloyal data, FBI files." -
U _! 92 _B5? f_ »-171",
:1 A
I ""'92' 92=>*l.-3 RECORDED - 124é~-_
1
92
Q: 1f T ./t_~.-= '/£2/::_9__"._._}
92'--._".;=;;-_<
__;.'- . 1_!*:'F>.-~= ' $14..-._. ,. .: :1 Y"I or". -" up 'br__Lk'.' J?=f
F: -3» ' .- , = ,- , , ,-
J
of-53¢;
"»-<1-vi"
='.**<"<:-z= 4-1' ' - .
~..5'---
~..~ia.§_
.1" V?h
41-
=. V ¢_,.
'_y3:_' -:_
._u____.: _..!_,-1- --;1-.".*92! '- :¢ .. . - _,V .
3'»
-»- -.. -31:"
t _, _.$1, y =1._|-<1 ,'9 .'
-*.-,1 El"¢! - -,_--.- 92. _..?¢{'r . _;
J" 31'
3; g-at
E; _:_I-.:;;i??%I~$.
-s;f"1
Y._¬_,;__ _,' Y". '=" .__V:f_T""
.92"'.-.
;_;_f~.;::T S
.__ ._ ~,_929_q.
-jgfg _
iaia»-1%
-15-" '-A .-43:r- §J! "'-' T.=.-%,'r-.r==r»:,-*.
*=»'
4..-' 1_*~_ -_:_1-.-"_i. T.; .92 V . '- _. . _ . _ ,
-3- ' ., -,.,._|92_,._.-,-__ _I - .- b _ ' _ ,_ , _92. ".- 92 -. -.;".!~~,-r-_- -.a.;.=: V...-.;1_,.-----~--'----P -
1 3 JJ-Y. E4I 0
sfaruamo roam no. 64 i _ N , I . ,
Oié-6 Memorandum - _UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
TO = The Director
FROM :
SUBJECT; ': 92. /_ t D. 1:. Lcxld /'/
C011. "_TI-YIIJTEE II. 'f '.i STATE DEPIGTIETT
.'a~.1es fuzmish-ed to Tyj ings Committee by
i"3":::.'2.t<;~1" .'<:1t~f',l1'*li! .
LO""'ll1"Y Oz sou-;a.v"';cc .i->13"-» DATE: Ijaroh 28, 1950 -
N184!!!
ma
*""'_.......iD- IO
;>-', ='-- 6.51.] " 1
-'-54? __ _ __ _ 'h1l.192omlo aivise 3';-"1 Oi the 1*-i~.s"1lts of a chest: of our files on all the names
"' - --2.-'1 '.'i.. "I- Id. 'T?.a
are in shzzpe,
t; *_»1-' 92_ '71!
--"">o1'a1<-1: of Fo.."11*ua.ii'1, 24: 1950; .,"OL1 1'.'e"e fu1'nisne"1 the _.l ,
oi v.-"~; 17; .1. iv *.1=*a1s 1'e{'o;'1O'I to ar1or.;y"1:Lo|_1:;ljr by Salwator I.IcC-arthy 1?2fC3l
as rr_.g;1'tel in the FM-::;;L'c-osior~al_ P.eoo1':"1 oi. E-zzhrut-a.1"y 20, 1950. These
1.: le if-1;~-_92-ltfh a crzpa"-.iSc=n of thrg ,§rz11ato1 s al1e_ja"$7i*n5 ".':ith the 1?-.aterial *.'.'hich3
92"~ " 1"" W "'" - obi on .r"mar 2 1 '8 b Eel ;-,<>.r;.1,1 to 92-ilk? 1n1f.'oan oonfi-.1'=x ally J-- y 9, 94 , y-
to tT.e Tfiinfjs £-cnunittoo by Senator Joseph R. Iiclarthy with refcIer.eeM,,
as to ! *.."E1ethor the cases have been properly horileti ani ! v:hethe§',_our files _
.9292 /,
92 t
i-;1c11tity of <58;
9 the Senate, '
ide nt icat ions
. V i iI
You will r-2 call that, 92i."it1: respect to the original testiznony of Senator !
1a1o>".e:~th'--' cartahi rentlonei by his could not be identiiiei by either the 1?-u:'oa11
or tho
t"e1" £1to Def"-¬iIl;._i~_?I"1[3 due to the fact that the Senator lumped several cases to- ii
o;nitt-oi s-=.":-.:1'al 0"C.1;?1"S¢ '
On Ifarch 21, 1950, the State Department furnished us with a list of the Sl
names given by Senator 1.1cCa.rthy to the Tylings Committee. Subsequently, on Farah [
24, 1950, the State Dapartment furnished the Bureau with a chart showing the emp1oy-|1-
ment status at the "T=e;:-arttnent of State of each of the 81 iniivi-duals plus the 9 i
:i_oLivi:1~.1als named by Senator I.ioCarthy in his appearances before the Tyiings Committee.
You instructed that we check our files on all the names furnisheci to the I?
Tyiings Co1'nm_ittee by Senator I.1cCarthy and make certain that we have properly haile
_ the cases and that our files are in shape.
- 19292 {tn &I1Ei1j,'SL3 has
"Iy:iings Committee. B1 41
conrh1ote~i ani rei'errei tobeennmarie of the complete list oi 81 names furnished to theof the cases full field loyalty investigations have en ,
the Civil Service Commission. In one case iTégase I-Yo. A0! we are presently coniucting a full field loyalty investigation at theL peoific request 0i the State Department. In 6 of the cases preliminary inquiry tykpeloyalty investigations have been coniucted and in ll. of the cases full field invest?-
gations were ooniucted under the provisions oi Public Law 4 2 th gpe goiof America Program!. In those cases where we have complet IIm' vain Ya Vfull field type loyalty investigations, G! investigations .V%ce §§-'1BIl08.
Program, the case files show that the investigations were properly led in accord-/in l__ Piggy "
-1- ~:?- ",.-92 :_
_!-_ -,__;,-_-..92|- .92.1.92 -...-92__'.~_-'-. -_92 92.
-~
i
6 NAB.-
?-5'
_i"1*'
1' -
i"-"-.5 '7
="?E°?:~;'
- ">1 ; '7
.513; =1..5.aL92- -_ 1* -g- .;.-.n;|>:u~
i *2"-
. we-_,. ' 1,rm?!<21¢ -'--1 ..
:;._e_-so
RAE-'.-s¢ ' 31.
1; -'_ ."-L-"i~
, _ 15,- "-um. .
~v1"¢Q rl
JP
newQ.
. I f.
"rig-* -v
"1'"'v.>- T-=<'. .. .-1.-saga
-. -- .1,.=-ea.
;§.;:r';""-'7 - IQ . -.' ;Z_.f92 _
i L J" |.. ..
77?-s
J -""'u'_-92~,,-,'!r92. ' té t-5'-.L."""'L J :. oi92 >
;_-__ » <- - Ar~¢, vY-:5.-~,-'-¢'4»-.-
_
. ,. V..-92-1%. .2. M}
. . ,.._.. -» -_ . 92 _ 1In _92 ix - ,_ _ '' I 1 , 92._ _ .- . __
' ' , II. - r ~ 4 5' *1.92 _ ~ - - " 11.»; .. t n = M 1 -r - - ~ :L¢li__:,._-I . ::'. -.1.. ...- .
In '7 of the 81 cases other type anplicant or security investigations have
been coniucted i'n_t11e past or are presently penling. Jith respect to these 7 oases,
however, 5 of the in-iliviiuals involved are no longer employed in the Government and
11121;; not seen in Gc=rc:"m.ent service sine "0 e far as our files show The
maininv" two involve Case Ho. '79 - and Case IE0. * bot? of *-.".'E;o: . are still f31.LD.-.O:;""?. tie s ace Deoartne-_e11t,
j.-resen y the subject of an Atomic Energy Act investigation which we f
bq c.§yi111lete'l "arch 2?!, 1950. As you previ.o1_1sl.y1ie.*rn been advi.s->:1, I".-'3fOI'l3S in this f
case will be furnishei to the Civil Service Comr.i::sion ani the State Department aswell as the Ator=1"'~.c Energy Commission. With regard toU3tate Department records
inriicate he transferrei to the State De_'r>az~t:z¢ent from t. L_iCE of .'.'ar Information
oi 1-e conluctec a "sci 1 I ' - '. 4-ViV.92-_; t' - _1 In 1942 .1, "1 n,.11_ry type L"ves.1Fa ion re ariing
1. or 4;, Of." f ice of Ccorlinator of .T_='1f'or.2:;ti_r-:1, preiecessor a,;erc_'-I to the 01'1-
.,t i vei 1 x "L .' t I .' ' "
"' *1: ntlj, . by Se * .. If '"" - * 1'-_lt}=-. U
e -="' ' I . .- ' _, - beI _.=; no 011" rojoi s U1 1 lS Sp<.C:lal Inquiry ease do co;:1_-pletely cover the al12{;a-_-
-10 s pz so" ' re? "1aoO'" csart?1y. ouch the-re is nothing EEL1'lllO1181 in l
oir iiles, it does not " ear that this case his en properlyaijuzlicated under .
the Loyalty Cr-_=.er anl, , seq-lently, we have ini.t-i.atc'1 a fell field investigation. r
'ihere are 12 of the a n x.-}:"7e3": no i.11vesti.Q"-ition 111:; nor.-n E.0J}l1.'=ClL'?T]
1.3; the Twreau =2-it oi these 10 of C ini-'|.v:'-.;1".s. s involvei are no longer employer} by.
the iJ~;acc 1l='->oart1a".:r;t avii tl"ore is no tLr1i:Ii:.atit~r1 in "311r.*a11 files that they are e..'".-
ployei else.'rheIo in the Government, A choc: has been ;'.18.'le with the Civil Service ;
Con-.1ission eni there is nothing in their roe-"ris to t?;1."?.icete these 10 in'iivi~:Iual.s }
1 F ' ,1 F t it ti! .~ fnsent t-=~».e. ale oi,-_o 0 lll 1' 0 *"n:-.e. o a o Pro .. ,T?.o T¬lI!18.lIlll'1'-' 2 involve CaseYo. - an".1 Case To. 59 - both oi whorl;
are presently ezzaio eye by the State "lopart11'1"2 nt. 1 lies <1 .ot "how s1f.'ficier1t 3information to warrant initiation of imrestigation of? With respect ,;topt is hotel that the case involving him cou not be Ltientified by either
the .ureau or the State Department until Senator Efoifarthy actually furnished the 81?
nauss to the Tydings Cormnittee due to the fact that in his original testimony before
the Senate on February 20, 1950, Senator I-.TcCarthy omittei Case No. 59. No Loyalty 1
"orm for as been located in our files. F A qr '0':-ever, our files do contain some _'inf.or.".~.ation 0 questionable significance which may pertain to qni which does
warrant the initiation of a preliminary inquiry type loyalty inves 'gation to I
establish iientity and to furtr<.er evaluate the information. Accordinjly, a pre- -
li.-.-in.-any inquir'y type investigation has-been initiate-:1,
I
In so far as the condition of our files is concerned, in the event they 1%
are subpoenaed by the Tydings Committee, it should be noted that the following
general characteristics pertain in the loyalty files: ,
1} The original copy of reports as received from the fielil have been, i
in almost every instance, edited an-'1 changei by the Bureau. to delete contro- Iversial material. It might be noted that,in this connection, many of thesecases were handled in the early stages of the Loyalty Program = L
I2! Original copies of the reports contain administrative and informantpages showing the identity of our confidential informants and the identity '
of cooperative private citizens who have cooperated with the Bureau on a s
confidential basis. Y
3! References are maria in the files to other Bureau file numbers and
investigations.
4! Each file contains a.n administrative marking of "disloyal" or "uniou.nded"
for statistical purposes within the Bureau. If these notations came to the
attention of outsiiers, it might create the erroneous impression that the Bureau
_2_
: ;?;'1-=
-;..~g.";j
H--.
¢-":::$-'
§' ;_..-_w-1,. _M_.92,=,-is - .9,5.3:-E
_ ,-F '=.
gr 3
{$1.%ér*.?;~I
.:_-,'.- ,~.F
;~;',-.- .. 92-
-11'}
v-.'?' '-R r ._..,§if .' t ; A ._ .
ié-5='.'_,'Z
'u..==. -- '
¢ " .. 5.
'73--"eff
92-
H
' .§§'.;;j. -t yr-* .=~~2q
' 4'5-5.1 !. ql ._;_":-- ~. ----I.-4 ,,.' - 92' :'_ inaz-.a~.; =
<":§P'.§.-~.. 3-' V r -
-:?.S;i';l;.=i~='§:+;-
7. I 9;
'$i:~§..*
' Ff "r-
" =5!'1-1-yr .
;_h;_.-5: ~.-also-.;+af
*.¢=fTs."¢":: -T-1
'_* :_T"h.'i'-{LI!/ndividuals were ther 3&5 uer and her band, Swm mr!, Gustavo. _ l"ii
_ .1. >1 ..1 _.__ ..-.
I 1
'92 .92 ntti
is adjudicating these cases and eventually result in a controversy with the G
Loyalty Review Boar. ' '
5! Administrative memoranda. containing various notations as to proper E
action which should be taken on controversial issues by various Bureau
oii"icials. ' _
6! Intra-Bureau communications revealing use of confidential procedures T
and the identity of other Government agencies providing us with information.I
The characteristics noted above will also pertain generally in the case =
files of investigations conducted under the Voice oi America Program, as well as
those 1-.-here to have conducted other type applicant investigations. lhesa
characteristics are, oi course, in accordance with existing Bureau policy and
procedure. Although the above list is not purported to be a complete list of the
crrrtroversial types of material appearing in case files, it does present a general
picture of the type of material contained therein which strongly evidences the
for us to strenuously resj st any efforts _on the part of the Tydings Committee
or any otlzcr Congressional Comnittee to obtain our files for either public or
private hearings.
As you will recall, Senator 1-1bCarthy in his early appearances before the -
'I§"dir.gs Coxrsoittee named 9 iniividuals whose names were publicized in the press.
F
respectfto loyalty neaiaaana ani 1;~;§e;i;;ga»¢1¢a.;Amaai- +,1;e'v3i¢Si&E'a.m;;i@a
Program, the Civil Service Commission and/or the State Department already are in i
possession of our investigative reports.
For your :i.nioz-mation there is attached a list showing a brief analysis {92
on each of the 81 cases cited by Senator }.hCarthy, showing the Bureau's investiga-
tive position ani the employment status oi each of the individuals involved so far
as our files and the records of the State Department reflect. A separate list is *
also attached showing an analysis of the Bureau's investigative position on the 9 i
individuals mentioned by Senator lblsrthy in his appearances barons the Tydings
Committee whose names we publicized in the press. As you Ii recall, these
./Duran, Haldozeon, llhilissup, Dorothffkémron, Owen Jhftlattimoze,-..
I
92__ '1
_ §é{_V:f;"~-.- an$2 if '92 -':'
. j"-"Ev
W S ,. "'
..__ _.1-{Y-;~
;'
5-"; :@_I'.'-92 ~_~_:.";£- g
i»,-_<-i-I._
.1.gg-l,;:;;»;;>,:+;?-1 : J
I-,;._
. __._Ej92 =_ *1f-l!~;:¬:"
1. -=_=_ ¢_- , ~ V .;>-V -<
-. -,-._, 92
qiu .- -
.11-~:2%.r,=
~___ :hV_V_{
';.fw '*
i";ji'.{' -
-J ;: 2» Q54 1'
is#13 I arr ."*1. Q=
-1,-;-L:-92 -;
f I
F +
-,-re»
. 3'. ~
{"""_ we
'» 15-,1 21
>
;¢.92_-V _"'-:31, ¢;__-: , -.
' _'-j-- 1'25 1;,. , -. , 92->
jr-.; J, .;:~=-:41 '-_92,,-7 ._ ,.»=»'.:s 3 ~ L . , t. ,4 . A.l in-::=;' ~7 92' . IoI |; Aa
. --Lg, V. ,- :5 .2 . _,- ,7!I I - _, 1 r _
<
ACTION -
As you testified, disclosune of our files would seriously hamper our
entine operations and would jeopirdize the identity of our informants and our
future effectiveness. Grave injustices would be done to many innocent people.
We should certainly continue to resist any efforts on the part of the Tydings
Comittee or any other Congressional Committee to obtain our files for review-
_ '92,; .
_
._4_
-- .< --.-- . ~--- Y - -*-'- ~.'---I11 11?? ='*-W -'9" 51,." =1"-__"- .'~~"" ".." 'T ' 'I-_ - _ ,_ ' _'-_- __:-- .= .,~_ . _.¢V-1; ' _.. _<_,- » . 4, -_ ,M
. Hy__- s-
1 ii . 1.."~ 1.-_ , $I- 1. >4. »
emf:
92:.". "Q-I-T-,L 1-92._. ..
,5».
an
.11 .gag!- .. -In _-.1. Ta
.-
.._-a
"1""
.,< not
1~ 0.!.. ,.,,,__..
i
pp; ;.- _
:;>:- J-~;=r;;_',. *-
sii-,e. -'-
eea*
_ .. ..-':.' '
ii:-.1:-f
"fr:
dee-
."7' "
tih
iie
es!-5,?". -1"? ,
= Q 8 _-_
._-7&4;-.
;- ._5 ..
»,--:_*-e -'L it -- *
A I -_-P
T5,». {"I-3'5. --'1 s. 1..7 8 '9' , .he
3_ r 92iéttd
;$§-§;é%
;¢.-iv»' J; < if '" ~r= 1::IPII ': ' . _
-- we-~ _
rt" P. .1»-t
3"':~'='3-'-Ii- 5'a;¥'..L_~. F;-'11=.: '.'; -xi? A. ;- 1- w ..1&1-1'!;-1", _!-.:' K1 - g92
r __ _.
March 2e, 1950I .
THE 81 CASE3 FUBNISHD BY SENATOR JOSEPH .
' * R. McCARTHY T0 THE TYDINGS SUBCOHMITTEE
§WTH SENATE FOREIGN HEIATION3 COMMITTEE
CASE NO. AND NQQQ *
iN00 lo
as subject full field loyalty
igation. Reports sent to CS6 9-15-48.
Loyalty Review Board dis osition "eligible
on loyalty" 1C-?~49.
No. 2.Informat ureau 1° es re -.furnished to Attorney General by memorandu1n92.
5-17-48 requesting advice whether loyalty 92~
investigation should be conducted. Memorandum
dated 6-9-48 received from Peyton Ford advising
question referred to State Department and State
Department indicated in possession of all infor-
mation. Mr. Ford suggested Bureau review infor-
mation in State Department file and unless lead
developed requiring additional investigation,
unnecessary to undertake full field loyalty
investigation. After review State Department
file memorandum directed to Attorney General
'7-13-48 advising no investigation would be
conducted. State Department also advised by
Liaison 7-16-48. Loyalty Form subsequently
returned to CSO 4-18-L9 with notation all infor-
mation in files of Bureau in possession State
Department and in absence of request no investi-gation would be conducted. tNo. 3. - Employed by Department oi may Dwe field 1 lt investi- e sub,-1 ct °'.YB Y ' W
ga on. Reports sent to CS6 1,-19-48. Loyalty State Department 1&5-£37..
Review Boa on "retained" 1.-15-49e m>-TENIPLOYMENT STATUS ' '
Presently employed by State
Department. '
Presently employed by StateDepartment
as of 4-15-1.9 Terminated
,, ,:,¢/:1 '> *<>-7 7
",2?
1 92-.: -,~ --. :<-*-'--
.2" -3, A 1}, _ -92._.§§;;-. . ,;
-Ks: .., .=-:_a* _ .1;"'37 ' r--:=- 4I»;
'-';..@;- -- .3
ti;-if§1;f@.=?_ii
Pg.-_.a--g -.1-s:~-,; ~q1'-I-_-. a'-.55 "'-.3 -i'~.=->1. -___-~ '_-.~_ 5.5--<
;*£'92. -1'--1» 1;-.-.'¢,'; '
3I,'~,*:*1..n.K ;-5-. -. _.
K "Ft-
F2; '. " *""_1.
iii;.;-_,$t1 "-Q, 2:;-sf =1-".. ~ ~--'5;L. __ . __
'1»;¥,..92 RFE
1 ,.. :15 L.f__»;.--- '§~_:§.. '_
$1; l"<">.i'~:kit '
» I
;_. - * _t 1'-.,jn§:!-"{'h§ "', I V
..-_:",>;»> - f
' 1
r--
.¢
_f_F__;£'$...
T ,_/ 1
" ' _ .-1- '47- s**= =:z"*, ?-_§~.__,_.-.5,2-£7;-g
mu-*-;;1*¥'
J3 .-.; +1
L-?IwE Errl
-T .. P , 1'...;-92_.,.. _a., .<1. _L5._l I;j, f <. J - ."16_ ,
. 2 ,-<5: .';e>.i1. v ~-* A -- .,. _|.-1
4
i never investigated by Bureau» Investige.-
tion conducted by CSC n 191% 8111 1914,50 Rated B1
gible 3-8-1,6 by CSC Loyalty Rating Board.
2l'789O-60'? P8 5181!. Loyalty Form returned
to CBC stamped "No disloyal data FBI files"
-1 - 8» in subse uent investigation 01'er VOA Program,comp eted and sent to State De rtment 6-1-formation develc that in ped
as member of IWO, contributed articles to
an newspaper sponsored by IWO, critized. U.7 92
Resigned State Department 3-5748.
1..
S- xmgax 1
Government and advocated ideals of oamnuniem andRussian Government. Reports on #re-
flectin this information also sent to C 9-20-48. _
No indication in Bureau files that -
is presently employed in Executive Branch of Govern-
ment-
h was discontinued when ascertained -
of discontinuance of investigation
No. 6-
¢as subject full fiel loyalty
investigation. Reports sent to CSO 3-13-48.
Loyalty Review Board disposition "retained"
2-4-49 ~ p
ROI I
s subjeot full fie loyalty investi-
ga om Reports sent to CSO 4-20-48» Loyalt.y_
Review tion "eligible on loyalty"
6-7 -1+9 -
Reports sent to CSO 3-3-48.
vi Board dis oaition "resigned or Loyalty Re er potherwise separated" 3-25-49- _t full field loyalty investiga-
rminated employment by State Department. _
Presently employed by State
Department.
Presently employed by State
Department.
Resigied state Department 1.-30-1,8
full eld loyalty f
i
r
92
4 2 .2 Q it pat; _ W 76 /21 In; 2 '5 onifég-'77 7 llResigned State Department 5-16-48.
I i.
.' V .5. '.-;'-'-
fc7-ti--
.--..-5 -'1It :_.,_..
-A .1
.-
I"-¥.'592I-.*'~
. 'q*'_~..'47
. ~vr._!_. : ~-- 92;- 9292.. -4'-~.
-Ie£~g.-F,.245;-_92-=1 We-5__h- -3 '
!T92!I .31
§§§
ii,Hf.
. -2. .;=r,."" <- $3."!
.- if-<..92 2-_.¢- - .. _....»;13., *- '¥?.,-'-. - I;--~
-J?'~r.~'
$3.'~4-.. -5
,$§ .1-_._
T J
I-
. .t':"-t _.,.'¢r.< .
. _,1-;-;_~3-1;_ 1- - CF.,_ 1F .'7 " .2
I i-v#_;92..- 92 - -' . - -'?<"!"n3 =.*1:-.-.-'3-.171?; - 'L
,1.-
;_.'.;.'.__ .- -3.-' . 1.».--4.1.
'4é§*
'-£:¥i:§¥,E-m
._ .92,
-».N0. 1.1.0
!!OI'1r ':;
4 w W 1
iv NO: 90
-'-as subject £11.11 field loyalty investi-
gation for National Military Establishent. =
Reports sent t0_C$C 3-9-48. No L alt ReviewBoard disposition received. a
never inves gated by Bureau. Loyalty
Form submitted by State Department returned to
CS6 3-30-48 stamped "No disloyal data FBI files.
No indication employed U. S. Government since
resigned from State Department 2-11-48. No
dislo 1 information in Bureau files under nameother than information provided '1Bureau entially by
on 1-29-48 indicating husban was s ePresently employed White House -i,
Staff as Representative, National
Military Establishment. Terminated
State Department?-30-1,6. 1'
Resigned State Department 2-ll-1,8.
|4I
i
-S7
petition. Bureau files under m t
apparently maiden name, reflect cma on eating
applicant for American Youth for Democracy membership
6 9'-1 in 191.5 2-sew. 10<a,
field loyalty investiga-
Reports sent to CSG
d
1-33-49:
field loyalty investiga-No. 12.
Pureeon discontinued on determination she had
terminated State Department emplo nt. CSO advised
of discontinuance 6-ll-1,8.
No. 1 .
was su ject f field loyalty investi-
ga on. Reports sent to CSC 6-7-1.8. Loyalty
disposition "retained" 10-1-48.ispos ition "retained"Transferre! lrom State Department
12-2 8--1+7. .
Resigned State Department I-8-4'7.
Terminated State Department 8-ll-1.8
Not. an Four-1 d...92¢t..,m _ 92Y'92§ovrv92§T|by92 dd!-1e.+acl92. __-5. Rb,
i /GU-1132.78-77 W."5' -.92»
k_5:?*7% .* I I _ .. v .5-" ' . ' __ -, _. 4 1' '5 ?'7 °" f"" '
1&5??? Sgw
-:."- .
" "-"" ".' " » ?f'.-"T "'3 '?1'.73." T92 -W ";":TF " 7 :'f'vi '.._ " ' 1 " ' E W
/Y'.1='- » '.
*"?~'.='i'-*2-=
k-1-=§:_r,¬§..
3--.: .- ---92'. Hf -
-s.é.3' l£' '..= '- --,'~:--_92;§l-.7,-"
.___,-, .. .A~, ._.-131 Q :-
¥¬i=-"§<
=.¢ I.-z"
- "fr ,
11.-
31:: .
Fe -'3
o
ta _.§§t.,.,.
!r*1
-?§§
.5§%%
I
.--- _'-S
'- V,-_ -1'5= , -2 .--.i. _ -..":'4. -we-:-_.
5 ';'r_.:_ 1,:t 4 :4 1--er.
. :29-1, -. 5'.
, , V. .L '-it ' ' ____,'
-.- .---H'.~
1' W
,_,,,_=. ..-=.., .-_._._ ~,.-A, .,.-". -F" . my. 1,5.. MW
a-'¬*3é§.- w. ,1; f HV-I ..<'__.;
'1151
CL-"'92- -.' ,7, .
fa - J '=.- -.-_ .1 ....-..:___.*.._a-=-.__
-
_-Qf? 5§%1
NW 15- PHILIP JESSUP . Presently employed by State ' ,Jessup was subject of no.1 field loyalty Department 92investigati0n- Reports sent to CSC lO-l8t,8- DLoyalty Review Board disposition "retained" - 922'¢ L9o - i
No 6. ' Besigned State Department 12-13-Lehesigned f State Department
issuance of E0 9835 on
No- 17- Resigned State Department employ-
- men? _1+'23-L70 neve by Bureau Taylor r .
res gned State Department employment prior toappropriation of funds for administration of
E0 8 5 on 8-l-4'7- No Loyalty Form located reend no indication in Bureau files employed
ecutive Branch of Government subsequent to
resignation from State Department-Ho- 18- my ' Resigned State Department ll-28-1,?never investi ated Buream No LoyaltyF ted onin Bureau files Bureau f orm oca -
tiles show no indication employment Executive i
Branch U. S. Government subsequent to resignation ,from State Department ll284'7- '
N00 190 "
Case Ho. by StateDepartment as see present
Case No. 28! subjectfull field as employeeDepartment of Commercn Reports sent to G306-l2-48- Reinststed after appeal to Loyalty -i
Employed Gonmeroe Department asj
or 2-9-!,9- Never employed State
Depart.ment- i
.:. 92.._ ,_ .-,
' I- /1-._'
'. '.'-_
~-;-._-..~rr-,___
.~ " "E71-1* - .5. : ..'_92,-_ .21..
".;_:'' -1?.
'. 3:;. _i,:.r
_"" re-':_*;;"_~ .' *3 , r-.-1, - ,=
..R_u____:--
'. '."1*'-¢. -...-=44um - .. ~. l -_-'1 H"-1.15.
-.,.' --2 ,1: 7. - .. ... . X.". =-92- ---:
I 4;.
3 .14."§t V
em
__.
- -.'T_
'45,
._:;,f_.;-r
I ; '*" .
i;
. gg?
J ,.-
2.?_.';.."1.___-.._I .0. ., "L-L4v- -,_,'.. r.. _- _--..~92. '3 5.;'=.' 1, .92{f;"<. 'f%:._7>' '7'.. , :_ _..
:35:. 1;..... -
..;_ '-
*..
-5_" em_._ ,-7' I-1
.-"-i-n .
">;.>'-
'- =+.1:¢..- _-1-4. -.-.
}_ 4$'§I"_.1-
- 1: *--1 fI 7
Fnever inves get by Bureau. Bureau
1 es show numerous disloyal referenc o =erson believed identical 1rithV-I§dicating GP front affiliations. indi-ca on in Bureau files -ever employed in
Executive Branch U. S. Government.
Fae su ject investigation under P.L. 402,
Oth Congress, VOA Program!. Re orts sent to
State Department. 7--2 -48.
N00 220Eras subject investigation under P.L. 402,
- Congress, VOA Program!. Re orbs sent toState Department 7-19-1-,8. i
we 22- q as subjec vestigation under P.L.
, h Congress VOA Program!. Reports sent
to State Department 8-19-43. Loyalty Review
tion "eligible on loyalty" 8-22-49.
NOQ
- as 1
80th Congress, VOL sent to
State Department 1-26-1,9.
under P.L. 402,
sent toion
, VOA
State Department
1l8.S su gee ves gation under P.L. 402, °' *6 Q
to ongress, VOA Program!. Reports sent
State Department '7-27-48. Loyalty Review Board
disposition "eligible on loyalty" 6-13-49.
Oe 270 I
u ves igation under P.L. 402,
30th Congress, V01. Program!. Reports sent to
_ State Department 7-.23-1,8. Loyalty Review Barddieioeition eligible on loyalty" 6-15-49.One time applicant for position
with State Department but never 92
employed.
Presently employed
Presently employed
Department.
Presently employed
Department.
Pres ently employed
Ht 0
Presently employed
Department.
Presently employed
Department1'
|
i
f
I
State Department.
by State
by State
by State
by State
by State
4>
1
i
92
I
I
1
I
Resigned State Department A-29-49.'
1 -- P92 H-" -'.-'*v-< .-7;;-. -v- - 92 A ,- -1 1 -e --.192 -; _.__ Aug -_.,-~§.,,.,".'-:-3,. :1 /_: , .?e:.=-111;: - -.-?L.-- P ~" -" "- / P."._-_,|3,_-ex. ~ 'Y *' '. ~r '- ' ' r .:->' I I /' T H.» ' W
F-.rf""* II I
1/.§ l
J 92 01:f"T""::;'
1.-":592.
3.
r c£0
' 92-
-4%
'-£5
. _
..I-rR-
.23-
.-ii
.4?
P-1;.
k. _
+r*~"
1-
ér _-_i,Q"-.. 1-_|'_.';'_-I.1 _I.- _- -- L '1' y ,- . '_ -1; . - r , 1 H-.. - - F --. i ;.'i-..... ..._.I'...c..--.5-._4_|..-.|_a__.,'--..... _. . -
. Q75 e
_1ppointed Department of Commerce 5
5-21-LB. Applicant but never - Case Ho. and
State De rtmen as see below!. employed by State Department.
was ty investi .
appointee Department oi Commerce. Reports . i ga on as _
sent to CSO 7-14-1.9. No o 'alt Review Board //_
disposition received. ."O0 280
1'.
abgect full field loyalty investigation Subsequently employed Department
rployees e Office Hilitary Government, Dep_art of Lrzrw until 11-49. Nmr employed
ment of rmv, Germany. Reports sent to CSC 5-2'7-48. Economic Cooperation Administration.A
Loyalty Review Board disposition "cleared on
security under P.L. 808" by Amy! 8-19-49.-
novr subject pending investigation under European
Recovery Program in view of present empl ntonomic Cooperation Administration. & .
Employed Federal Security Agency |
as of 3--25-1.9. Applicant but
Federal Security never employed by State Department.
Agency. Reports sent to CSG 5-8-1,8. Loyalty ._ _-i - .
Review Board disposition "retained - restored efull field loyalty
after oiial to Loyalty Review Board," 3-25-1.9.
Terminated State Department by N90 300
reduction in force 12-6-17.
Bureau. lcdartny
involved affid vit that he was member 8 B"
of Comm never, material provided G-", ; by _hows only that person Dof e r name a gn GP petition not Comimist
affidavit!. Bureau Tiles signer
one
rather
State
submitted by C50 on peron apparently
identical with former 8t-ate Depilrhnent employee
returned t at-a No disloynl
6-"1580 62" 3q o9"1-1%}
lay 28, 1
. _ [1
v-.._/ ' _ ,*L.',> iii -17': -rd; "' J *7 If 1 4. 7 *-ax
G [UTerminated State Department 'io-1o-.10
1,1
' r .7. ,71.' .'.'2-f -. ' ..,, ._,_-I92"'.'92'..-I
Q -'-.--"
v
+1.,,,_-._92'.'.'..
if. -.92
-é§>Q-.2
.= re 2. ~- I d~ '-.=¢*?,=1 13... :1i._-Q;;'. ; ; ~ 2*. tarecs:
-'-.--.-2:-
ii.»
.95 "
n.~'-1.5!
"Le: '
m"-* -!_>"--V =.,-'§E -r ,-K15 . .
1-.-':---_-:i-
'1 »:?~_.
-'25. -
-.7
*5" :~i;- .'-$179.3?» :_ , - st
13:.
AS
. "4§!;,: 131*; L-
' -I-2,1; C-.K _. ..
:1". ,. *'-...v"~'!'1'R
+¬-.115- :--_>;:,, 'r..<-,¢-
. _ :__
; '-,3. Tiff: -31!""~}Z~-.I..- :31-.5;92/E;-II, "<-
-.. ..-
vNo- 31- F
Note: This ass carried on Senator hIcCe.rt '5U list as No record of a -tor» y <
¢
Presently employed by State Departme nt. 92-
8I11P.LOY¬3Q state Department. nowever, i 1
was subject investigation under P.L. 402, 80th ' Z
Congress, VOA Program!. Reports sent to State
Department 7-26-1.5.
N00
- was investigation under P.L. Department. 1
402, Congress VOA Program!. Reports sent -i
to State Department '7-15-1,8. .
N» 3- _ D "es subject investigation under P-L. 1,02,
8 th Congress, VOA Program!. Reports sent to
state lleparignent, '_7-26-1,3. Loyalty Review Board 92
disposition "eligible on loyalty" 2-2'7-50. *,
No. 25. t Presently employed State¥was subject full field loyalty investi- Department.
gab on. Reports sent to CSO 3-2'7-48. Loyalty
Review Board tion "eligible on loyalty"
8-1?--49. Fl|1
Presently employed by State 1
Presently employed by Stats
Department.
i
No. 35. r Resigned Stats Department 12-21,-1,8
Note; on Senator McCarthy's _»list as inves ti gs ti on con- ;
fil ontain Q, ducted by Bureau re Bureau es c
no identifiable disloyal information o" r than Q _ia rovided confidentially byl-29-48 indicating unusua at i
in mail w e employed as messenger in State Depart- §
meet err! discussion one fellow employee indi-
cating possible interest in Russia. No Loyalty Form -
located in Bureau files. No indication in Bureau
files employment Executive Branch U. S. Government
subsequent to resignation State Department 1.2-24-4,8.
2-39749-11
No. 6. Presently employed by Statewas subject iniéstiga ion under P.L. 402, Department. e '
n-I-be Fan rnnnac It'll §rInn1I:l'rn92 - ph92'92+_l Illt ".Ugo V§ w¬D, 92I92I IQ IIZPIQ i YYXT YTState Department '7-2'7-48.
/6-1.. ..-we .- . __..'.r.**-i.~//>i/ __./V>/
I -W-q - ._-Hr--. ; -=v~92._ -| - .- -. _ J _._|;___ _,_-p ". "r.- .- -1 -w~.~_ ...-~-; ~.~ ,-r r ,, _. V ,- - I V 92 > I . -. ' '//
M» 7- was subject investigation under P.L.
402, 80th Congress, VOA Program!. igorta" _ _ --2 -'80e/ sent to State Department 6 A Q _
0.
Kaufman was subject run field loyalty
,, """* " sent to CSG 3-18-118-':-'.'.>-f.':
N 38- _
.2 _ -I __, 1-» J1 - e-I - .
.;.'i-"1. R R 'No.j9- gras full field loyalty*,§'4y=§§"" nv stigatiom Reports sent to GSC R -
14! 3-4-48. Loyalty Review Bcnrd disposition
"resigned or other"-rise separated" 9'-21-48.
ga C10!!-" .:*S
No. O.dis :92.=_11 field loyalty investigation requested by .
" J State Department, which was opened 3-24-60-
/
92/' NO» lo
- was eu ject full field loyalty
vest gation. Reports sent to GSC 3-3-1,3.
_ " Loyalty Review Board disposition "retained" -1=2»1_;mi RPg. - "* j
".<Le -
§}?=.% -92 -i
1:-i _,
11?.
1:13. ~-
. _ ,:-L --;1:---'
._ -1
Q! |.'*-'-"q"f-:"!-h. ms.-.'4 I ' ~.-it-=25
..._~,_,..
_r._ ?1 ';@'92,2:;,<3,':-:':,_i:,'!;J» _.W.
WK2,! _--_'r_"- »- .~,4 /
J. -.
' N n 1 9292 ' I5 ' - -'_~. '. ,'-.; .1 ;-_.-"ft -'' . - _ - __,_' 1- "
_ """ D 1- 924 -In--1.JJ-lVK..£:l blbd Blunt HBPUTBS
" N0 Lo alt Review Board disposition received. -
Fresently investi-
_- : } ti '.L§§1'--1-.-,1: P 8
I1' .J
Presently employed by State
Department.
Presently employed by State
Departmenf-0
Resign- -=
Presently employed by StateT-92l§1'92FlY92"'9-n/92b92*UGPGL '-II-HUJLUI
Presently employed by State
Department.
-:51. 92 .. 3 At
.;;»492_'_:- _u..___... . i .- ._. -92_.j:'.-,-'. ;~. >.
ant
:§'
»--an-.1
F»; "-;- ., ,;l'.*~£-:.."v"a.1" Q.3'». L.*:5Z;'5. ~
___i 1:-ii ".:.w-'__-' 5&2 £-, :-' :-
$7.;
Eii&1Ȣ:=.'
tit???-
¥jrf'_7_'
J0-1-12...,
:;,'_'_.§_ . -
'3
-92;-.
_ ;. '1} -
EESEQ
-1"»; 92_ -.5 ri _-si--'
-""»; .'
¢ ,.,o__.;.
i$j§' " L .-.'-_ - 4',
_,:"i:..
;' .~¥"f.F. ~.'**=-_ .. -,1.-v
-'=:'..'.'.:~~
¢i§;
§¥C
. ..1" _ -:1--r;-_ ,§.:_|_ ._.-i,-;_1.<+-_,' ._1-'I,_.=- ."2;
w.$%
J ¥@
';*';~. ¢**5ii==~
" !2'.il. =';<2c*-.*.:7.?; A;-.w;">*l
be '1 ¢' i
No. L12. _ 7 =
No investigation Eonducted-Ev Bireau regard- '
ing- Note,
appropriation of
9835 on 5/1/b7.resigned from State prior to
funds for administration E.0-
No Loyalty Form located in
Bureau files and no indication Bureau files of
subsequent employment in Executive_Branch of
q'OV8I'T1II].8T1't| subsequent to separation from State
5/B6/M.
110- h3-
Fishback was'subject ful1.field loyalty
investigation. Reports sent to CSC 5/3/h8-
eview Board di ' " 'Loyalty F
9/30/hB.
No.
Note
prior_ .
sposition "netained",
State Department
appropriation of funds for administra-tion of E000 9335 iilélo State Department
records indicate ransferred to State
from Office of has Information 8/3l/h5- Bureau
conducted Special Inquiry investigation for
Office of Coordinator of Information in 19h2.
Reports were furnished to OCI 5/b2 and 6/h2-
OCI is
Information,
N00 LL50
Ness was
121011.
wfor Office of Wa.r
eld loyalty i_nvestiga-
Reports sent to CSO 3/1/h8. Loyalty
Board disposition "Retained" 9/20/n8.
lld loyalty investigaw
tion. Reports sent to csc 7/Bo/ts. _Loyaity
Review Board disposition "Retained" 5/2?/119.
NOI I-$70 O.ea ;
Esther Brunauer was subject full field loyalty
investigation. Reports sent to CSC 3/2/L8.
Loyalty Ravi Board disposition, "eta,j_ned_,l2/11/1:9-i ~Terminated State Department by
reduction in force 5/26/k7. . F
Presently employed State Department
Terminated State Department by
reduction of force T/26/I47. T
92
Resigned State Department L;/'30/1'48.4
I
I
Presently employed State Department
Presently employed State Department
92
E ,
- 2.; /1" ..
F, -Iu___
!_ __92.._.
so
t?
w. ._.' A
~www
i
KIT?
r
... ,7
'";Fi-"5":-E. ':"'r.. vi 1; *
' ,-r-'7-.
-'3"-.p.
-=wu
e
_ 5*-1;,-. .'
'_,;:| .,'._. '- ixv,"HY;-"
74' 61'4-
t-$ 4".".,., .. I _
7-Q.-,=
1;@g
R.
I?-2
v- E--".. -. ~-1:.
._-__::.,;-. '
ieée
i' Q?-;" =- J;-._._ 4,," L, _92,ȎkQ@-1- Lu < A, im-' -= '- _92.a
-nawiq
,_-,;_/elm»
w
1.1
was field loyalty
on. Reports sent to CSC 6/l2/MB.
tion, "Retained,"Loyalty
9/30/b8.
subje full field loyalty
orts sent to CSC 6/12/h8- OH. nép ' '
Loyalty Review ard disposition, "Retained,"wow» i
it sol _gt-Ye e'eBj?et¬ of full field loyalty
1 res igation, Reports sent to CSC T/22/k5.
Loyalty Review Board disposition "Retained,"
1/7/L9.
No. e. jpi-xas su Ject full field loyalty investiga-
on. Reports Sent to CSC 3/30/b8. Loyalty
disposition, "Retained," 2/h/H5.
NO0 52 ! '
field loyalty investiga-
Heports sent to CSO 3/l/t8. Loyalty
Review Board disposition, "Retained," 9/20/LL8.
No. e. iPeas sugject ll field loyalty investiga-
on as employee of State Department! Reports
sent to csc 3/1/us. Loyalty Review Board
disposi or otherwise-separated, 3/'18/"49. it-~ _
N9: 5110
- field loyalty investiga-
tion. Reports sent to CSC 3/5/b8. Loyalty ReviewBoard disposition, "Retained," 2/h/b9. _
su c field loyalty investi-
gation. Reports -sent to CS6 6/18/P43. Lyalty
Review Board disposition, "Retained," 9/30/ha.IELS S
100Presently employed State Department
Presently employed State Department
Presently employed State Department
Presently employed State Department
Presently employed State Department
Resigned State Department 12/30/1,8.
Presently employed State Department
on leave without pay,
Presently employed 3tate Department
T F
' _>:f »_
'.~ ,.".,-" "" . _ 7
* = ' :; » .- 3
' "
u-.'.-r,-u~
.'-_ -92" ~
> . L,§
_ ,_;.. 1 -'.:.
.~
Ff?-' Hr-5'
2'4»
§.7"<& ii I
'5; .:.,3 11%;
is
. -*5.-1"*=.'4T 92.fir! 1';- _.»L?.< i:~4.'.92'|
1, ;
if_ <1- 1' ¢
Lei -.
m"i;
1'.215:: 2 M J, _ :-
.4 V1"
~f~l S »
;=_-Q- M s' ,1 1 , __,_ ""
.5
'.;..-.4:
'*§ i-f9~§§§
a-3 9 "
;,.?f§.3*a"'1};$§l.*;ttestJ I ,7-4.".
~;2é{--'§§1I -'.',92:: , 3:.'3;fr~»; '<__-,- -3-,» >.'1fiJ . "N ' -"- -|.92 V' _~.» -.-. 4.- 921 ,5, __,;,-_ .1i 1 IfNo. 56. Presently employed State Department
' =' ' ' ted on iNo 1!'1V092..G1g3.b1On conduc
by B.1_I¬¬9.11a Senator 1IcGarthy's allegation on ithis case based on information furnished State !:!1 Ir~ t t 1» qvfar men y
State Department document in room shared by him QLQ
and another nussian. Routine investigation made
in December, 19b6, Informati y
eived information
an associate of
possession of
mert report. Nothin dcro "%.tOI" developed by State _
an fa t hat was roommate ofDepart-
On request "a 132.1 ment, 5/8/.47, "
. . A 's . ;'!_;"n:'a.l;.o1*v "Ln'P:J1n"=_:,1ti.Q;'1 in our > _.1rsau e;1vi_ed no <=~i -u _ i _ oi _files. In connection he was subject IDA i
investigation based on allegations by fellow ' 1
employees at Army Iiap Service. IDA investigation 1
discredited allegations made concerning him and :
indicated motivated by professional jealousy. IDA a-
report indicated intention of Commanding Officer
Resigned State Department 3/1.2/L18},Army Map Serwrice, as of 2/J;9 to reemp1oy
in duties involving access to classified
FBI files. -39749-1109;
Ne 7. _iv-vas subject preliminary inquiry type lo altnvestigation discontinued when ascertained
had resigned employment with gtate Department,Loyalty Form returned CS 8/l,§/I8 with notation there- i 'on referring to fact inc longer employed by
State Department. No indication Bzreau files of
subsequent e nt E utive Branch, U.S.
Government. .
_ Presently employed State Deparipent
ubjeot full field loyalty investi- '. e
/ /J48 alt gation, Reports sent to 650 3, 3, . Q Loy gr I EReview Board dis sition, "Eligible on Iteyalty U K9/=3/mi s s ~
1 I l
1/
11¢
_=-:_92_
g ...92"
.,'~f__. :<_¢.
2* at.,-1~ -
'§§;¥-.5-_ -
:_,.
-F.-=.'_%7":
.- "
__'@.92"-' 2
_~
92: ' 92 -A-I_' :!£-I
",5!_-.v: -iE?-,g
.:,'- F 2.
age;
v.~. ' 'J...'1 I
,..' ' .'¢ '.1-1 -?".£" . --' 'tr" " --
sang
_Z_' _ ..,.3-" r.»~_
Q ; '
i
at.
. =4.-Q,
.-I
-"- IF?
,.*. -,;-'-15-Ȥ921'.='-'.-
' V ¢-.- ..» .-"aw
.i" ~r
'. 5%.";
--3*; _1.
'33:,- L
~~a-rt »-
"-
4:15; .
. _ QT. ,-' §I1kg ~.
h-_-Q-"'--. - J,
5'-7z92t_'§S'Ltf>;¢/1--~ '.-.-§;';§'.£'."f.5?-','a 1. .-gt -as.-;=r.._j_ .:.~,In. '92'_"-'|'--" 1
--» .4.
~er~rIJ I
i
N00 590
No investigation condudted of by Bureau-
Note, Case No. 59 originally omi e in Senator
McCarthy's testimony before Senate on 2 20/50,
s when
ena or MbCarthy to Tydings
ty Form located in Bureau
Bureau files containFirst identified a
of Bl gi s names n
C OT"_:.ilL
files on
tionV
has preliminary
initiated to establish identity and further determine
significance of information in Breau files.
:t full field loyalty
on. Reports sent to CSO 9/lO/h8-
Loyalty Revietr Board dis osition "Eligibleon Loyalty," 6/15/b9. b
-L '
Io 1II 6 l I'll.-IIIIIIIIII was subject full field loyalty
' ts sent to investigation. Repor CSO 6/h/H3-
Loyalty Review Board , "Eligible on
Loyalty," T/25/h9-
No. 62
In regard to this case, Senator McCarthy did
not allege_dis1o{alty but rather moral inter-
pretude. -aas subject of preliminary
inquiry type investigation which failed to .
develop information warranting conversion to
full field investigation. Aecordingly, Loyalty
Farm returned to csc 5/19/M3 , "Ho dis-
loyal data, FBI files.!
Nol Gil .loyalty investi-
§§£ion. Reports sent to CSO 3/1/h. loyalty
Review Board disposition "Retained," 9120/LB.
12¢" it _r ].'"=-
_ V1 ' 2 I,/7 -_
. 92 '
Presently employed State Bepartk
56
Presently employed State Depart
_ .
Separated State Department by
reduction in force S/20/h9.
U
Resigned State Department 3/19/i
5
F
|
§
Presently employed State Depart
I
3 I
ae<=
. '1 "-.
_}
.. _ 1+
tr?
£11
. . .¢. *15323.. _ ..
tee"
;,§$:i;;;'--.>. t .1:Ear;
-..»~~ 1-=.:':'. ..
Iffi'1 "f%%;;;11'; -.,' 3- s "
r,-is-" ' 1 '-
|:£-
'2.»-a: .'I
J?
54%; -=.'
. . _-11. ,,.=--no. '1-'".;e~~ey.' *-j
-. I - 92
:2 57'
Q. 7%.-J. ,_ 54_ _.,.,J3-
'1'?
.5-v __
~'r
4-, _
E-1:
zzié
ta
A 1 5,. Ii _._!_
.;-_-5 i-,_j-fl -'
*'i In
1;~*=+51 as_.
.?# NJ
- 92J __
- - _ '- 7- 6-"J-'2. .. 4-. ._
'92I; rt,92 ..i i
.1I
No, 6h. Presently employed State Department-was subject fu 1 d loyalty; investi _-Tat-ioni Reoorts -sent to G-SC 3,/21'./lL5= Loyalty JI2 L
Review Board disposition, "Retained," 2/2L;/n9.
65. iF"-as Eioject investigation under P-I» 7402,
Oth Congress VOA Program!. Reports sent to
State Dopwtrnent T/13/31,8. In connection,subsequent aalication with Atomic Energy
sion, iinvestigated under Atomic
sent to AEC ?/6/h9-Resigned State Department H/15/II9.
Apnlied Atomic Enengy Commission,_'5/is/ta. <
Terminated State Department "9/16/1;?Note, with 3taté '
to time actual procedures for
administration of E.O. 9635 in effect. State
Department records indicate entered
-P1"-1 n "mt.-'| nn-l92192J.J-92J.l§ __-<
s sent to otate Department /uo,
Terminated State Department byN00
Note, .t with State reduction in force 9/12/m._
procedures for administration of p _os.c. 9835 in Gff¬Cta 5tate Departent recordsindicate transferred to State 8/31 from Office _
War Information. :as subject of SpecialI ! c nducted for 92 Inquiry investigation y P eau o _
Office of Coordinator of Information in 19142.
Final reports this investigation furnished to '
Office of Coordinator of Information, predecessor
to Office of War Information on 7/3/112. Subsequentlyon 842/116 BAT6311 directed letter to State re
arrest by Perk Police and reported desire
Em ass o , of !ov-1e! b y t have him released. Note this
information in Senator McCarthy's allega-
1'»1OnB.
-'.-x/
_fJ-1: .;;_-,2 Q"
5 " '1
as-' , P
3.-~ T
. ~_ _
.;'--.-,_I =
_:$..r__¢_
_
=.*_92>' -=_ I4:!':-- 73'7*, I:.=~_-1,?--;.~.-.'_"
;-92 '= J,
. . .
l.!;,-, "-1.1.
pa. .-a:r-".--
M: 3
'3"? '92"
l
gas
.,, -
3'
m-
1 5-.'5»=.o .
"7_é'-92 0-st= ~:~"-j"_*.- 4
'_ - _92,aF 92_,_f£_-... -7'-cT:-, -~_..;2" N1.
-L;R; T:
:31;1.7 8I _-"' '7''-..-
¢.", "..t., _.492.1,-;.
Jess
% t i
- 1.-ta- §
.',,.'~. - 3f*"E'-;'l:<¢:.'?g
.c o __
- 4 A V
-if *I_ , dst?92
._ '.¢;,|
No. 68._ _,ontinued!
for Office of Coomlinator of Information,
predecessor of Office oi War Information. _
Reports furnished to OCI 34/3/112. These reports
completely covered allegations made by Senator
McCarthy, Summary of irormetion was furnished
to State Department B/7/llé, All information on
which Senntor 1.IcCe_rthy oases his allegations
CSC lemoval
recom.r.1enda'tion not acted on
ll/30/'42 Com-ssion had reversed decision;that form givingnsecurity clearance dated
10/8/21? in State epar"r>ont file checked, "Results
of investigation completely favorable to subject."
Loyalty Form located in alphabetized. forms showing
returned to CSC 3/12/i;8 stomped, "No disloyal data
FBI files." Although previous reports of special
inquiry "type investigation conducted by Bnreau '
completely cover Senator LfcCerthy's allegations -
I ' ' at°on a arently in possession oi and tnls l.rL|.0I'iI2 LL pp
State Department, obviously case not adjudicated
under Lyalty Order. Accordinggl ful ' d
loyalty investigation re w 'has been initiated. £62- -
l - I - - iwas sub3ect full field loyalty investiga
tion as State Department employee. Reports sent
to csc 7/21/L16. Loyalty Review Board dis osition"Resi or otherwise separated," 10/26/E6. .
was subject investigation under P.L. 1102,-
80th Congress VOA Program!, Re orrts sent toState Department 7/26/L18, h
presently
information developed fur s d to INS, CIA and
State Department-
14$'-k-_.-'
Resigned State Department 9/114/[L8
I
Presently employed State Department
Terminated State Department ?,2/8/hr
lo'Ic
- r
, 4 /,¢
'92'.'. ~..=T" :,__.
§."饧
::§- "
be-'#_§- 5',
t-:.?",:', .11.? ._.;cut, .~"-:"_.-
?*'>»--.1"
-= 5.4-* t
g 1
3
.5?-.
M, .
t '°' .1
1,,
,...
- -;.l»l,-?f'92r
71; 1,.'*"' ?¬># _ ,_'._'..'"~.-3
-:3; ifsv!- 1%. 1; .-.-1. _,,- ~:='
2 gain,-. .92-rug
4*Y -.7-_;a.;" 'r- ,.s_*-.
4rJ2¢-=5*-1-1+;92§£-'
45' U
?;,_,:.._ is '
r-.~.-_-1-,.J{-':'i=".'
'71.»:» ,,,;.'_, -
Note no name given by §enat0r }.IcCwthy to
Tydings Committee on Case No, 72. However
this case identified by both Bureau and State
De artrnent as referring to _bsugject of full field loyalty investi-
g 1 " 0No. 72. Presently employed State Department
b | t
<= on as employee Department of Army Reports
sent to csc 11/t/148. Loyalty Rexrlen" Board
disoosition- "Resirned or otherwise S¬3pL¥I¬2tGd?!
:[1'om Department 0; Army! 6/211/L19. State Depart-
ment list furnished Bureau 3/3/S0 re State92Depart-
ment's identif" a on of Senator I1c:{;arthy's cases-identiies gs Case No. Y2 and i1]-di0¬1f»95 F
Femployed by State Department. 239?4911+L17!
_ Pesi nod State Department ll/12/J4? No, 73, 5Ito investigation conducted oij:;,r Bureau= IT30 icientifieble disloyal information in Bureau bfiles other than material provided byw C con.£'idential1y on 1/Q9 4 - ' - 2
ILI1 icating a eged close association with "known
leftists and fellow travelers." No Loyalty Form .~
located in Bureau files 011-110 indication -
in Bureau files employed Executive Branch subse-
quent to resignation from State Department 11/ 12/M,
A'J..'ao".*l.o_1'mQ92
92 "" If I *1 -I---I-INo Q Resigned State Department 1/1o/118
was sub ect rel n inquiry type J P a~1 Y
loyalty investigation discontinued when ascertained
he resigned from State Department. Loyalty Form
to CSC 12/2h/b3 with notation showing
esignation No indication
BJIBHU files of subsequent Executive
Branch, U5 Se Cwavernmenti
preliminary inquiry type discontinued
6/h/hf} when ascertained through liaison channels
she had resigned 'om State Department 9/23/Mia»
esu files oi subse ent e loyment no indication Bu-Executive Branch of Government-
92 .
.'_'_d 4ti e 1 Yul. , ~..; Yr
. _-. .._, ._,_.. .. .. ~ ,,__,-.,_ .__ ,_-.,.92_<--_._-c_-.,,___.-T,',.,_»? _-....- V, .__,__,-__ it-.4 . . 7' _. _Q
I
i
Resigned State Department 9/23/L17.
.i;Z
kg?
,si
st
;$k
1: .;'-QK. Q:
92:'»'f
New
,a,
5% -I- e
.-' 4 f 3.§:"
l ?.
£1
-_*S{.";-.~_- _-_-
$5 -1.:w->9? .. -"V-1:
,3;
_.._ . ,1-..,!'e1a1_
25¢-
I #:4-_-11'-W191'4-"-*.;" Q
1'5-'92f"¬'_, IrF*"' - ~ _
rteI %
1 »=.-92-'_-_,__ _..,_f.-.4. ,,_-..- ,_._.ig___, _ Jr. .-r<_ ~*.
.
' -7?-Ti
.".;=:-=
Less".-_'
." If?
I59 '1'..-,'_
1..~ 2*
T Z
=-as
e
. _- w
T. - e. '__ -_, , .=:-<1.-.e
"-F-'-;-H-1
--ea-23,:....... ; 1 _ _ HF
_n
. Hp.
I
92
92
N» '16- FNo invest gation conducted ofq
by Bureau. Note, Case No. '76 previous y
identified by both Bureau and State Department
as referrin? to W terminatedemployment with !8p3.I!I118I1 priorto issuance of E.O. 9835 on 3/22 . o
identifiable dislo al information in Bureaufiles o '0 identif ble informa-
tion in B es re other
than materal provided by
on o sloyal nature but contains allegations
re competency and falsification oi application§eoords which is substantially same as made by
enator Hccarthy. 2-39749-1109!
NOo 770
Note, Case No. all called repeat to
by Senator Case No. 9
McCarthy be o ena on 50. Case No. 7'7named as nazn urnishedby McCarthy to gs oxmnittee-eknassubject full field loyalt investiga ¢Reports sent to CSO 6/26/:8. o a1ty'Re-view
Board disposition received.
N 8-has subject pre ry inquiry typeoya y nvestigation not converted to full
field investigation and Loyalty Form returned ,
to CSO 6 8 stamped, "No disloyal data FBI
files." ubsequently invesigated
under Eur covery Program by uream
Reports sent to CSO 10/2'?/43 for consideration
under Loyalty Review Board~ -. 1u.-
ever employed State Department
5» -D
1/29/48, whic con a ns no orna-
Presently employed state Department
b'1c.
t h
but nerer employed» Department
I gj
-.1;--3
:7 ':9292.:'._-.:
""!-Q
' - E :_"'-1i_'$-S~§*.==¢-
..'I.'-=T1-
. _92_'_.P1».-_-, .7
223.1-, -f ;*-u.z"5'-3% -~-!;L. 1- '
1..'= 1-1: i-. -92-..
F2."-T_ 1.. ,
'4."-§L_5~.:
-:
Ll
5"
.2:-n.u.:E,~
. 5 fr?-
*;. ~; ,
Qéegg-vie
4 a.- 4 - i"l:92
!_i=@<1..;g_'- §
- u.':_' '- .F.-I. .-..-'-.".~' '
._ 3;-__-,92. 44_;."¢.§-g" -¢-e
veeeé
?;v_?
. 2' .9 - -
~:-it _.-
3, 45-_,92 §-"If? L -"'.~':.-"'1 7 -:; __ - i -._. i - - _
I J I
Ivl e
I0 4 .1; _ ,- .-.92_
,-
N0- 80. Presently employed StateNote Case .0. on list furnished Tydings Department.
Co. ittee b Senator TcCarthy carries nameas 1'.'h0 has never beeneqp oy y btate Depnrtlent Both Bureau and
State Depax-t:.ent previously identified alle a.-131.0312: in Case 1'0. CO as ertsining t
was sub 'ect 0 u ' Jld ovalt investigation. Reports sent toie ycsc 5/ivyka. Loyalty ew Board disposition
Reteined" 9/E0/ha.
Resi
subject of full field
inve _ation as employee, Office
of Vilitary Govorrment, Department of Army,Gen"1a.:1v. Reports sent to CSC 12/15/48. NoLjtllt-ii 1?.ev-lew Board dispositi. on received.
17$
1;.__-_ 1 ,1
~;¢r/>2?--5.
.
Y =1 53'
. ff?"_z_ 1- _
>, Luig--e_ . _-'9-..-r_ _ :-. . 92 92_- ».§'* _
i.
¢F¢'{'
m- 2:.4
- I 1- _-I-5.-:--92,..5'_,r 1" . "3
F-.<.E' Q-#73:!'~Tf_v!f:1 .- ' .=51 -92,_;__ .
1:-~ ' -.-.- 1' -7
"Ta? 1,,-_=_. w.
<1
g .13.;
W"
3. -".
-1!='. ;-' A
-'2.
'34.-1 '1 Q .~.". -7',"r I-.-. 92. we-;1,..'1>-I,-,1
_:Y"".'>.|£J_ E-.';'f':, . =I- .,1-2%; : Ix 1'' -,.:.-'. .1-' .; | _ _ _ I ' - 1 _ ._.. ": .-41- .._.:-' .¢ » -92-+4.-4;-L -,., .. L A-._',' .,
I e .
I .
_.- T!-- :'-%<'>-1 ' - 1 92;;x 92-- __
"a
-
- * March 28, 1950
a L
NINE IiiDIVIDUA1lS LEENTIONED BY SENATOR MCCARTHY DURING
APPEAPAT-ICES BEFORE T1"DINGS' SUBCOBIHITTEE OF SEIQTE
501131? i3:Pl1AIl7Z91§ °9¥@T§,T.T§3-: T7 _ _ . , 1?; c ,_. t
E1.1'PLO11.'UENT STATUS
:
ESTIETR C. BRUNAUER See case No. 4'7 in list of 81! Presently employed State
Esther C. Brunauer was subject full field loyalty Department.
investigation. Reports sent to CS6, 3-2-48.
I.0ya.y,~,r T_~}ggiew Board disposition "retained" 2-4-1,9.
STEPKE1-J BRMIAUER mentioned in connection with case Presently employed Department
of wife, Esther C. Brunauer.! Stephen Brunauer of the Navy. ,
was subject of investigation by Bureau under Atomic
Energy Act, which was completed 5-15-4'7. Reports
furnished to Atomic Energy Commission 5-l_5-L7; to .FJLI -E
I H~ b '1
r 92
. .
I
1 r
AB of June, 1949, employee;
Chief, Section, Cultural ;
lr92+.-{qr-1+-Ian YTn-1+n_r¥ 92I::+. runsn.uu.|.92|4.u_'_wu un-i..uv92-A uuv UL/ GUSTA92lQ__mEJ}_I§I, resigned State Department,
10-3-46. Note Daren resigned from State De-
partmen 10-=3-46 on-|-A -fpeunnnna nU UU .l-Dull- MAI-.¢U BU
.5§11;"B'=~§aen, Igf State. Summary of ;
results this tats D9-
/? 9:l3.?'7*"77
heI
, .1 .
e - e ____,_.6.f¬.;.,Wj.7'T, 7.- . 7 .9,
E5. 92.
,V_._ _.l
. .,
;_'!'f'.'-
-,
,.__'.:,_.._V_
E ?- . l _.
<- r.~.:.-.-£1.
r
.--W ..,_ .$5, » .'. .~.-,;_-"P -....
1-'-'.Zj=.'f_-."
es -. w-T -~-_;:-.. .
3i5:~7~'¢".
_ ._y."..».; 1
g§.,+Z-.*;'
i- .".'-i:
=4 _:.=r- - 92_
§_ :_,' .
.9 '75:
""1. R2?
R- 525'. |¥;;,~/-.53- -
»¬1_?;IT
.~9292~ 3: .'
.-
:' '5'--_»: -
=_=4,§-_' '-.._""§I$'-.< '
*1? . . -; "-.. _ ., . 1
Y-A-1
_,- '-415.; .
. ';:.'-E- ._
.
3.-7;;"i'~i?. fl
.3
.,. -. 11 -7-;.- -:- .~ 1-J.»
.-1 5* .-.-~ ..'L4 --.1-__:-_x= =
~~ . _92_ 4 _
|- _
I l 1 " . !
. I 92_I I .. U
0
-- - 92
HALDORE FJWSON. Hanson was subject full field
loyalty investigation. Reports sent to CSO
6-24-48. Loyalty Review rd disposition
"retained" 9--30-48.
PHILIP JESSUP See case No. 15 in list oi 81.!
Jessup w-:2-.s subject full field loyalty investi-
gation. Reports sent to CSO 10-18-48. LoyaltyReview iioard disposition "retained" 2-4-49.
DOROMY 1'LE1¬YON. Kenyon was subject full field
loyalty investigation. Reports sent to CSO
6-20-49. No Loyalti Review Board dispositionreceived. j
. IATTIHOEE. Served from 10-15-45 to
2-12-46 on U.S. Reparations Mission to Japan at
request of Edwin W. Pawley, te1'1:1i.na.ting on 2-142-46
on completion of assignment. On 6-5-1+6 Lattimore
made speech to group of State Department employees.
10-6-49 to 1.0-8-49 served as delegate to conference
on Chinese Affairs without compensation terminati =1
mation sent to
3-17-50; to Peyton Ford of Justice
24-50; to Attorney General Department
3-34-5 0-
FREDhTRICK L
Reports
0 h.dVl.Ce
received
JOHN STEIEART SERVICE. Service was subject full
field loyalty investigation. Reports sent to CSC
I2-23-48. Review Board dispositionreceived. _ --> > £.;_1.=.>;, , '
Presently employed State
Department.
i.fl
Pres ently employed State
Departme nt .
Terminated State Department
l2"3 0
>
Hot employed State Department.
f
>
Never employed State Department.
m
5
:
Presently employed State
Department. 1
92 uI._,
- - 92 . U . ._- 92
, .r ~ ~92 ., _, . , ._;. --
-.>'-TX.1-f=_ T
"xi -_ '21-,: -H,._,.-92-,,,|.
--; ;92'.'_".
IE
=5-._ 'Q}-:
&,i;
§if;:
4
a
__ | -'
_-Js F5;
I
j?ee
f""-"=-*
1-iii.» :1 .
_ -ff-.. ;_,;
L. -:1
;_ »._-4::3,'*"~5=- :3.
.1 ,1;-as
- : rt. -"*' 3*1~
' - -=i'-
~_I.»*~ E 4.;Yate-
'-"~-'-:4-." -., _
_ .1~"' "4
92=*.1,~={
-"1!-'&,!."'
§ T§ .1 <-,-eals»-§ n F0 " £15- ,:~,'92 -"-$*?s%- .-§».'."_.--> J,*/*3."-'-"-L- :
=>.r:,~' -5
-.1 t;-";1 IL .11 _ -I - '92HAHLOI SEAPLEY. According to State Department
employment chart furnished Bureau Harsh 24, 1950,Dr. ' * " so i
ti
as
of4I' 1
I
, _
I i;3:'.:7! . 92 X | 00--92.-_._.92_
Shapley was designated by the American Aosoc_a-
on for the Advancement of Science and was appointed
a member of the Fational Commission by'the Secretary
State. According to information received through
aison fror the State Denartuent, Dr. Shapley is L1 . ,
not an employee of.the Department of State as conung '
within the purview of Executive Order 9835. Kith
further reference to Shapleys possible connection
~.-'it11 the Ccvernment, on May 24,, 1948, in answer to
an inquiry by the Bureau, Mr. T. Vincent Quinn,
then Assistant Attorney General, advised that Harlow
Shap1ey*s emp1oymont"with the National Research
D. C-!
ve Ohim wiCouncil, National Academy of Sciences, Washington,
b did not
rder. .-.~,...'...-'L¢;...,.:z -_ .- so
Presently has without
compensation appointment
as Representative to
National Gommission,
Executive Committee of /
the American Association
for the Advancement of f
Science, having entered}f92T92 .:..+.. r..-..- n "|r92.r,r': 5
~' 1 U11 L-ILI-U phi, .J.!£.f_|'§
I
b"!
1
I
92
~. II
92
::: 92_'=. ,|._- _,._,
T1-_ 4! -¢.'f
--,;~..=.-..
Q ;<.~-¢--
:>_.~. F
-~; :2 - J:-I§$r~*- *-1: s *.'.1,,*.*.:- .-!»#.'- '.-w _ 5'.-:"_"';»-.:'."i_'
5! '4 gr:
92 - l Hi-,
,_.. _
%§%
I-_-*
.:. *--37
-rv-,
'92...I
92 " .,_¢ - >_
-er.
. 5<&
es
P
Z£l ::
1% l%:I?=Z'
-92-J_ J11.-a ~ /-"or-.=.=-W-3
..»_w5»;;-_
¬EiiJI.?!-i-111$;-*3: *-_~n .-
- '» 5.3-v?-.e*'-1*
-5,» 4»;-. !-
Q
';;_,,. = -
l""_.--".
XI--=-.
-92-51' .T-:5? -_ --
-;%;~=?j»,.*,%e
3 ..;..-_;n-~¢'.-
*?;t' £2-_'..-7 _ _92é'5_-.,.;;; ~:>. '.rq-1..- -»- --
.,¢;._ _ ,__ _ ___-» .92
92
./
~=
L;
~/. I 'OiC6_M67' '- i M2 -I UNITED
TO = Mr.
FROM = er.
SUBJECT: - Y
Ab eTolson]/I
NicholsV -T - ERNMENT
r
mvrv-= March 28, 1950 ~
'1 _. I. jg. -'1 '1|:.:on_7,_{_
on_ lVl ' 1ne|w1|____
I » Boson" 92
arris of the Department phoned with regard to In ,Director's memorand"'to the Attorney General datedeebruary 2h, regardingghblig{éisclosure_of_RBI reports and
in particular to item Number h, Page 2, wherein Harris feels
some words were lejt out of the last line. Harris feels thesentence would read better if it were corrected and the White IHlrbo
I011!
T910 - Rocl___n_
R0-A86
Om!!!
House has asked him this morning if the worcage can be clarifiedT_-
The paragraph in question reads - disclosures might be made ;
under circumstances which would deny the aggrieved to publicly:state theirfpositions. Harris feels that the words "the K '
' shoe e - th U w ' u n'n'nn'.r92-,".1:nr+'|-1' TH ha92-I VI Lr|-ill? H .I.92lI LI-ufTer "V
r~? r-r1"F-01" a nnnrri nnr-1'rI1n ar7 on . _ 9292-Iv 92-ad/lal JIU921 W I u92-U U-I
the sentence would reaa disclosures might be made under ;
circumstances which would deny the aggrieved the opportunity 1
to publicly state their positions. 1
I see no objection to the change and recommend we q. If
advise Harris that it would be satisfactory to insert the words Lg
"the opportanity" so he can advise the White House.
~IIIII d WM
Me
5 P_._ I .....a l5T|
W iii?
Ill"
. . <' _--.fȢov~92> " Q 92 ' 7. la: _/!
;> FTW Viettili wm3 A 15301950
J
n ___ 2E _ _ _h__V__mA___U _L___J_J ___K92 K_ _V_ Y _ __I___ V1/J F
_ :_~____k '_ ___ _. MZ _
¢_
J
, k fI
__
_v_r
L_____ AI A_ __L'__ __ _ P
_¢______l_n_H_
A
A IJ /h__H '_____.____
a_,__J N __ ll 92 ,' F A E_ * Jim _A In ___ __, g_____H __ __é__:1 __¢_M_ _--_ I; _"_ 2 w __ _'_____ J_
A____ 92 __ ,__L_ ____ _HW____u__h
_ ____4_ _92 P, 6' ;F _ __
T _________h___1. fr ____ I_
_;_____§_H_d_ E ___r_ _H u_____
___ ___H;_
__ __,;_____ f__u_ I 3 . _ _ _r
¥__________q _'V_
Um _H_W____M My
__h _ _ !__
_ ,n_ __ _! _
, _ _____m ___pH/"___|__|_ __Hu_%"
92 _m__ _ V Iwta
UL __ in_ ___ ____% ._ A_ _ __1 __ _ L___ _iw___w_ J __yg_w%___$_M§iwma__W_ I ___ |I "__W92____' _
J V A ___&_Wa,_ _ ____J_WM_WWM%92A__W__$¢$w W_wm§%W_mU I_ §_¥__ wt T!_: nW?1?_§:_ :FT¢_ni_£$HLF_%$m%£®% mW Jmwww§$:m$xMu7_ H_ 92 A U __ __ _|92V_H__£H _ Q __ __u__hw_§__H___J__ 7_n_ _M_%____ ?___ _ "_____FA%Wo%____ _M_ uIWv___'_____ I: ,___92m__M.__Q_'O_5_W G4 __1_¢HU
'____,4__=
Sp:2°
:3 _5'13J £3 _ 7 __£_m__1 _ I _U __ A__ _ .92____L __* _ G ___m____92__ _____ 92__UH_dm_ __miWM___ _____£__ %__?_yJ_l__: _ ; _ f __J___'92_H_ _
_ I ___ _k M___"_h_yH_}__h__ W ____ ___ : L , __ N _ ____ __F__ :______ Wu _ _ _ ___, __ _ _____H__ _ _,__;_ hf n iM_¢¬%m?iu*WRW yMM__iw:% N %k _~92J_f2_J _
W!uH__J iH_u_ _| §__ _ __ ___H M_____T_ ____]___ _ ____ _%_Lh_rH__"r_
_ :__H_ H Z! _ __l_ |_ 1_ ____n_m "_H_P____ _hu_____mHm ___ NH _ :H___k_}_Mm__m___ _T___ H 1_MT____H7H_é______q _mm__up_m}_w__ ___; _ _____92n__ _.__°_ __92 t ___ I I ___ _$_H_ __ __ _ __ as '___'_ ___U_?__ _ V __m__" __ m _ ______ L P D ___ l_ K; __ _, _ _%_"__ _ m_______ _H_'m_T_1 __'_____£_m_~w_ ___1___h ___&_,92_"_J_w H_
_ u ___ _ __ ____ __ _ M __ __w_____ -7 *__ _ L; _ _ $_N___'___ _ ___ _ _m___;, _ThwaM_ J 92~ _ G __ ~ ___;____ _
J I3 _
92_ _ . __ 92_ bwiw Q H@uOQDSSO h L5'_ OCT Hwdi QDdmQ E910: Mm wag aDm UWMB _ 1QON%GQQ D3 H Q5_dwM3Q 63$ Hwmiq D DAWBOEHQQQHZQ
$6 H3 63% DUQQUOW O%§1- EOOCQ1 %1OS ¬QM:~:©&O3_ AH Q5 Qahom d3m OO3UHQQ QHd 0% rm UMdQOdOi_3M&D&m5m3d GQ%oW® 63% w§OOpaS&dW® OH 63% wQ:Dd@ qOSSH&&®Q _92
O3 HO1Q ©3 mQHQd D:W O: RQTOR Mqh H@mO_ H row 63% Smk
EMHH OHQW%t a mO°:ONv&Moam Ewa QOC SEQ aDCQ SN : #Q%Q1®:Gm
*0 a %H®m 0% 63$ hmH_ _S_ _m§9_W3m:_ t9:_m__ %¢" __1__ _92'@92§P92®§ h__uq__92'____9292A__ 92____n ___H K xi yEWHQ3 Qf lat_ _ 3miohomcg N _ H__¢__ Z
_ L__K Q ? t ___ __92 Rf 92_ ' _ x;
QM M mM'%___3H,_ _ 1_92___ _ ________ _92P
I __"__ __
I _ _ _¢ __ t_
__
H
!___92 __-__w_m2_m_g___c _m_______ 1% r_I___ I 92_ _ _
_ 92T%>_ J'_k_
% O ___°___z mum! P__°o<m_N _ _ 92 _U__8mn___°I _ _ I xL_I 2__?_ I __92_9___lh __ M:_w_:_m_ $56"; H; w___:__~_m_:um_:u=__92__~__ * . _ _u____ ' -
E333 m_:_§_ H__W _ga§~=* 5* _:a_g _
B W Q: ____ ' ___. |___
"n _I I HMh_ §g_:__Gg=_ H. Q.I__ ___' f v
I '___ II __ ___ W ' I 7. __h_ L:__ __ _ 92
__ '__ f ___ p
_ __ h!m_H____,
'5 I L ________ ¢ I__ _92 Q _ k__ / __ ___ ___ J_ _ __N'__ ._r|92| I L
1_ _ _W _____ ___ ,_ __ I T H ___ _ A v
_ ;_ _I U
- -- ~ r- -- 1. - Q, ; J, 1 / .92 '- - V. r-, I - H ~, - -- ._'
- - :_-;< yz; .I.. »-. _ 1 _, _',_ __'_,"'._' _92_._.._,
92_ r 92.92 - g r 92 -
- Q I
. 1 f 92'
1»
.:-F: L- _
,,{.V¢ - .. .-.>,>~. -v.92 -.1~.'-! _ _ 5-.__._ __ { -,,1.._ Q... .,- -~.'-1.*.--=.-'»~ J-' E..;; -:92"- »: ;:f.._"--
55-¥-?_;r;'=.-9292J ' $1;-,&'..=r,ll;92g'92 5w_ _ -
_.~.
"~-?*':~§-"
1 . r,-.!"::2;:';._;
.__;i__:..
r §.§i{'i3:f'"'='-3 Iii, K
:@%£%%.':3 *~,=;.?_;:<.'-5?vi;-=9292'P'~ -a-. 2' =
<; fr-I" 3.R%..., J ._
3?" 5.<'¢~' *3 . * »..""'92
J 11 -j £13 ' 92ge.a92'§M! r~ -H: A ' Y
92 received and%¢@w~fx
';'92J:" -1".- ,.- --1 92 >_ , ._..=SF .:"'_§""w.-I J-~. .H? --.:¢'='*1I_¢= '
.%:*"'.3'- _'.»,-_ _ 53 .
;. mm~_»; 'a-. . ..~»;. :':"'-""-'i.""-__.'-5~'.~::5% 1%, I If 1 I c Ia r'"'" T ; $ to the files..<-_,.,_ . .. ._._.~_.-._
;+ 5:;';+¢» ,3; s- 1' Y ;;;j-_'-2-41: .4; -- v-J "LL~|-T..-- --_,-.qr'._. J1 1- *.'..|§.§s..:.. ¢.. _- .
»~§
¥_~__r'-_. i_. '_ I .- _ _--:*f;_:;-. -* P 50- ~11-"-s~_92 .. _;-- 1__;r4- -. § -
L1,, .
e --
1 "'=:-".;$" - --41- -~,. "- 92 ' '. *1,-I 121. -0. -__¢-pf
. 1§@5&f%
r!
flu $40 _r- -I ii-.~"- -¢- -1 '
15- 2
Ygly-'5
V
. 92 ? r » ' |
_;§i.;;_l§§.'.; J., , statemenjjbefore Subcommittee on March 2?, 19.sb;"i<
:i
_»1 1 -92 ,.F ~.
92
I ~ , .__ -< ' * r" ' April 6, I950é * I . '
'12-'19 e o ~
a~¢ '
Rq 01:. letter dated Burch 2e, 19.50, has been
I am taking the lzberty of ocmnow1edging"Pe-Tw?m%@ ix _S92it £n_the absence of Hr. Hoover from Ehshingtonq.o._ _..
'" * I'am enclosing the complete tart 0F_the irector'a
atotenent before the Subcommittee
on Fbreign Relations on Burch 27,of the Senate Committee
1950*? I;hogg this aater£aQ
you r;31y ;_p.c:ue'<-Jwith reference misconceptuons uh1ch'
1 at°fh~*1.*~- o e. .
-. -_ '. "'1"! f _ 92 %S mce re_1_r_;Eé:0";Q"§~__1 L"1u.!
92j1 -5 =Ln .
E, ' - 41.. _¢ 5 .92 ~- . ." ' Helen F, Gmndgi -<3 ' - 71'-
s r t - '14-" '3_. 929¢ GI"._:_r.-: _ - 11:-. e 92-1 . I . .. 3- e . - : - . . . , _. __ _ _ _ rV. . _ V !' '_ . _. _ . .r .Jk_; Iii; _
. . - -~. 4 , -_-¢_
- mv.
¢ 92~ .. 1
I --,1I92¢--. I ._92 ' , ., _"_ -a . - -'¢ '5 -
92 -92 92- -k 'Y _ " 92 . ». - ,,..-
-5 -I
. '..+-: -= '_92.-:*.';~*' -1 . ,. 3- -" ,..'»' ..v'92,-P92'92 .- '-3.1 :-. "Y~-92 ,.'_ _ -__' .1. 92_t:" .
V
'
7. 1" 115:;-';.¢--..._ N, 92-
*+1:*"=~.7-" '-»
9 1 "."".--~;_"*_":"<1:£:+¢=*.:*'§;-e-,:'<>
F1--'==.,y;=.@¥»3;92'92'$
. r -I -- 4 ~ - 1-'31.". -_?;-=5 , _i:92'_- 14._ _, .2 4 K3,i-M4 --. -*"_""" "' M I1-
o||__i
lllntn
IlcbllAPR8 1950 '
R°II_._.... I0 - '.n . 92
BI .-oh, '-»_- _ V, J»! ".-,1-*_:. . ._; kin
"----<4 1. 1-92:':i 16195 '.~'-. 5*: 5- QTJI '-'1-=!'-->.~.'1' => LawN1. - -, .'.. .7 * j1;':~-; -_ - .-i, ,- _~- » . | -_ '» - -9292- .-
v k -i. -é Q. % '
P . 192. . . . .- '.: "Ht. . * -1.3. - I .~#!.. . -H, -' ~.T:.' - eQ ! '~ ' "{. '. =1 331 '1?-' -~@-'=.,.'-'.5;*L-'~'-*.;'.¬§'T§";' .§?- *'-.:!'"3..* gt! £7---'-'-" : '=. 1. §§ ."ij3:,:%i'3'?"~;_"?':.fJ 3.7; 25' ... . L, __ ,1 __ _ 1"..1.~; .._$.,_ ,; f_'_ ',:-,:.._, ;;4_*' . .::,'. 5 I-.1 .7;-_,_.%: I! 5 .-~ .~ =§~. V92 #5 >92
1-
.. ._-~ ... %. II
~
92
. _¢_
If a -..',"'92-. ;._
'.- .--.-J.'.. .-=/f,; .|.,_:.'.- --_--..--,-.|-»»
*
Q , M .....-,¢-_-_;;-:-.~.':--=n~V- - : .»..-».k~,..-.-1.'?!:a-.. .-, - -:g;;_,_-;;. .- q--_ _-.-,,»~,.__. ¢ §**@"@.:1-'- ...,._.,,H .
'1 1H»; ¢ . _ ~ . . ~~_'-:-.-1%-*;+».==-"1".=* -=; "-4-1*-" -- :*..?~=t".£"-""=-"$1?-"=-'I"- . ,, M!" A!?-;'v.92¢. ~ _
-7 v .7 n
.~-_~§¢_ .n-r" "2,92 _ 1
5 - ,_ 1, .. .- -._- . .- - .---..' . :5. --.;.?'-. V_-Z.-. _._f__' r _92 ;__;_.,.§92-.__¢__92 .__».f*:._ .92._ w _ . ,2, .__.__ ;-V..-.~;- ;-_--.;92-_-1;-.--_-:3-1. . _:*.r -~10. _ _ . Iv -J-_- --' ' ' ..._1P=" TI ' -... - =7. .-..-:__ -/.- __-_v:§~"§'-*-r}:-'":;': -_*.f",-'::§5"l..:-=g.A' '<-' ... " "',"==;'*""i' .- I _ ' ' if.-'-|'-1%¢-Q; _ -._. -.-',-!:I._-Q...-W,.__;E -.-vr -92 ~- .
. '- _- - - -I ---; ..-"1 .. -.-.-,--.---923=qar=.. "* r-3': '1- *-<.-». - I g s. ..-~,|=. - _.': ._ ..',._ d"_ .. } fl,-1 >: ., 3|---m _- -.92- '1 -_._;__Q.i-§»;=H_~_~ ,,.92 5.,-,;_:_J;¢ _L;I§: 7.14;}-vi;-: .92_-=4»!. =_ Q
l " ~wF __i .".T_'-_I':_:;f'l-.'-1_- 1""., '|.~ ',! _. -._A. -,. .. 92 :
.- , . --._~ 92 '
_' ,..92_92 , ._.;-,92
-. ._>._t ;
_ _ .-___-c 5'1
- ,"1P'i<!_!.%-Q.-1
.1. __ .. .- _,;,_ .1- .- ~1,; _ . #2.. - .. -92.-§_ .:..92...__92_-._ _ . _ .-'!.r"= -- ' .--.-..- . $5 -
¢ . . M.
. § u*-1"." 31" 92?=.s-¢ ~ 1- "
1 'r Q;-9,.
-:r~ .- " -'-> -=?'?»*-3:.-..- ~ - r---<.;-=~ - . "==-
.- - -5.-
.
- ,_.,. ,.__ i - _'_ 92_.' _ 7;.;-I; '3': :--.-132.2-:1-'.~*'..:--' .~:"+'>-:-:5-" '- .'-"-""--g~ __-_. . " ... '_ ._ ,_. V._..__,l_<..,__- . _ .
iip§a&ar' ""':}'§-'5.'=|i-==a-1-=@'-'='--??"= .-*--?-'. _
-< _-I __. ..
.15; -*'E~ é3"!.-"7
. v _;_ ~ »-4» a;--: -~.--= -*..,_;_,, .=l5»?§ _
14
4-.»= ..>"1 H 1 . .3."§1%"
3. ..j=;.._: ...
.~._3;~ =. j|:~7*-J
-;.':-'1==~.-':~.- 3"_-5?";»'¢: -BT75 '31"-"5-~L
-' "f "3 1"-F"' -1, --n-'.'--Jr. "1; '~r-s<1:.Kb? i*"3-§='=.*; -. -"'1' ;-:~. -~'...<*"- ."-- '
. ~
- gs" .-I!
ha ' ,-_-..-_, .--._'1a'. '--..,j..,.. . 1; T..-
~ *:x~+-J,;-92 ~ ..,._..-92 I l
x
. /__ PT... . ..._.-U1. v J _ , _ I-
1
92
5,4 <1/5.. ,%.:..,r". '1
921
.' ':'1, , .- =- ..__. ,92'_._ ._.,_., .1. _. -. , ;_
' e-- c <-.!~-'7; 6 0
I
'
0
/174.!WW2 ¢¢#_@ ..'-I. ',3."-"P?-é-', '-,1.
.--A
92=_-'.
_.'920. I ¢ -92. . *192. - _-1 _. ,..* . -' '.='* __.._-___4". .._._. /1 ¢_, J A; .| .- .- .-- r '_.':'-' 'L .-...-.;.-F2-. :.3-;'-'6.-3.-'i"I.7l:;" °1"I" "'* "-»'----7/ l :'- 1 92 Q ¢ Q! if; ~.="§O 0 0 13 =l'~ .- _.-, :1»
:1. IL »' l _-D.
~ -J
%,4/.44 .2; /£4? .
_.. 4/L-4_J
7 - - f . ' _4/-<.l-1.-_»._,; . .~.:_; . _.-_ ';. -" -' ' _ -2- - -
§ :'**.= i== a,';-<-$7". ?§."i-*. i'-.35:3;- -. Y- '"%'§.¢.--¢i '*' '.'-*1?-".-. 4- /7, /'X A ?.' ~=1"."fl92.92_1,+_-»~'..-.'*""ii-_..-.'L.j1~T* 'i-"-~»4<_' .-- xix 1 __._ -.. _ . _;r:,_{ H; _:.J__.I§_L,q . .5. :. _ 1.4; A-4-_...? _ _,__ . ,1. I. I _ .I//1:-: ',y rz 4- - ", y .a - - i ' - .. ' I-"PF lg. - -.. _ - - S 'H 3 1, .. ____ '-, .3; - J ~42. ". .'.' E 3 sx <._; =-. 1. »,92?."J_,,t1 ": §"_ 7 92 n 92 I-" - -;~ I . . ~. . ~+mgr . , - . _~¢ _ 92
-5,.;-;,.1,~..q:.;;-=_.¢;* _-,_;_-j.-.; .- > __ . 3, . ._- - ._ _ --" j.= __-. _ _ ,1 "_. .< 92 ' '.-;f-;~§-";,_-.-=. _-' " =.r ' '. " _r-.-.---~.:~_ ':! ..» Y: _' -'. -' it _,,-,;>~.~, _-. 9. , _ -_ _=J92§____ ... _-1 '*. ,-fk-. . ;.-_Z _~ ~.:,. *- , ,{.;.':92. .' - ;.-.-q' .- '~- K ":.-;;£"1 ~ .-I!-' ~.. H-.92" -- ..- ~ -.= - > " - 1-r~' '.-=e- vi-".'. ",2-K, ' 92'.1r=":;-'_ 1 : - xi-;'.,"?.-.'-';' '-;-_-<~;'E'. .&J7* /I-4o6~l//' ¢//:1!
" ' *= .-.; -- -r -:;-.=.1g.;.-
KY .- ., '4".-,: 3"" ., V "1 :1 "_='§; 1 :- _;~
4 __ 4 . .» _- -5: . *' -A*-*7".|l_:._': - , 'wi:--av .- 1-: é ,-5.4. ,;;'......,~.-,».»zé.?4~¢ ;//-¢_, M? /~41/:14
,2/I
. 92 _ .
-7- . " 41.-mar» --. ~"1-mr92 4 -*P .-.- #1
_;~~
. '._--'£-':- . .-
3-. "
'. ' w " -1~'_>'='<?-"._.-we -.-.1.-"? -§92*"' "3$ "=- . M52 - '-:'* -~-xi .-.~:-~%_ ,... __ .._.. .__. W 1 ~29. . _1_..._i__
. .,__ _ _ .,.A, _¢,. .... ., . . ._
. if I - I _ '.-:-*~ *-*.._ .3 q _ Ii¢r' » . ': ;. '1 ' "" ''¬"'._4:'}i-- -""?.~. ' /..= ',- _P-*_' -'-"V T '15 '1
_;-. .- - .-»_ A - I .- J..-;.,_._- -,- .=::= - +r _- :-
. A J1 I . I I - - . /#02:
I macqgs 15] I __ J» .. .W /'£V"s /#7 ? ~=. :1--.12-=':'. %§ vszng. .52... - ; 6%!-i _.._i_:.-_,.. 31-. . . ___ ,-3- _"_9:_._
"*".;-._' . ."-'92'!". *é."¢-j;=<':-31¢"-_5f ii,-:r&4r"¬"'.§*; '-.. '- V * ,4/' , ,_1.;'. ._,- =1 _ ,.. - -- - .1. V'1 . - __=:._ U. ;-":i ":' . _ _ ' - -' L 6 -" '-'@=Y=.?.-;»Z@;=..f;" ."-:r.*'~>=.~.e¢é1**-; ~ * _ - ...5.-};.;_I#.-;v ' . mi. " ' fa - ~ - . 1 - -_»...4,?4,.7.~.,¬% ¢P~~4/J" W *#4WwM ' /4""£¢'4~/
% d'71- ./ .- _..
r
.
92 .92 ~._. -. J -."-" - .. .", '-.~-" -',; 'j,_-_.'j;- . .,-. .<. ,. Ci;
G 0 -'-.-r 92 _ I _.:_ Q I.
' _~92 r ' ' '.- ;
" . ' . 7'
_V 1 - -.. .. .. .._.,. . .
.?-._92..:;-J- .~::_!_A_,___. .1 __.92_ .__< ._,_:92_-.-_ I/,_ ,. '.._: . ;-=_ . ¢¢._ -,.-s--__ . 5»-92-_--., ._ - -- 1. . r-_ 92 »._~- p, _-._|' ~-..~.-.- I . '_--92 K-_., 2-',~ _-1. -_- - -.~ __ .:- A =3-.~l 1-'.,_...92.;_f_-5-._-".'.>. -=__f'--1,-..-;,-=3; { 92 x 92 -_ ~, _,;__-._-..'.. =_;._ '-1,; *4T _ ; I 92.-"w-A-1, "'41,-._-Lj:? _ _j -J" I-aw-' --".-. .. .-4 - 1 , .l I:.-.- _ *;..._,<:§_ _- =.._,_ M _ I _92'§-y:¬'_;: _ .
.. -w ' ";*-$7-"'-"3-=.-> v. 5"3:¢~$:*¥, ' Q .,k_..92-,~.-.~,,_._L . .$G_£.h;__v?¥.i . ' _-.-._.,.-xi . 4. _.=
;>.i__"92_,_-_.. - .
"46 ' ' $5,? ''¥- Q .-_w _, I -_:..;;"" - '>. .ff:$:}_Y'
--- _- 1... _ -%- -..'~. . »>.>$§vIi%.§¢;;-:~*.-- 1-.= -1'; . ;;_ ;,~".92 --'
-.-»..;;_;;; ,5»... . __ H _;_ .- . _ -.:,.:92*;_ H- - /J-.- -u. - ~ I-'.'.- - '3; 92:|_ .4.,- _ 7-.-. Ha, Ff-.14 __ *- '.:.5,g1, _;-,,- J, §_-
a-1".-.~-J-*'<~,-~.<*--"~--"-=: ...'*'-1 --;--. '-'-.-R1.-i. . . ~.__.- '....-~:- ~- .-;...92.-~--v...-.--~:>:-~.2.-_= ,-. ....- 1= -' Q ~.1:>§":-'-f"- P. '. '14""?',.¥;' 2-, ':"'.'.'- -- _r"§ ='_§""'"- -..-_<-._.v=:._.,..-- /
~ . "-- ". ¢~.<
L I '--e:'Ž,h,_,g: ii .__* ,-
' - - "i --- -4:»:
, '{;.1..!'=.,92.§';___ __ _ _ __-.;. -~* at ' -= ,-=- 1",-.-~ 01¢ . 11". 92*.;g- '92 ~ .;__~;: . ~ ~ ~. 1.,-... _,, . ._.. W ,92__LJ_ _av '-
"'. V ' * ¥=-rt, ."f'"~ .. H?-===*,_-..~ 3-.~--.-E.--. - '1' -., - --." - "1 - _. ,.1--. _ _u U $___ r__"~' ._ -.| :¢-;- B _ h I ' 3 5. - P VJ-5; ._.,| 1.5; ff.-=.f-,.1_ Mi 3 _g_ ax. J
J7-_ g. L, ".' Kg. . _'-'1 5;; . -- 73.. .,,_-.,$- .. M.-, _=¢_ -.4 1 ~<;i@=_;- -- ire: pl;a?;§'*z._¬.r;u.., ! we" ' :4; ' '7_, - 1~_;,;..~ . -'= .=~. .»-..-_!. ..
.. <.---;».=.r- Y -~~ ~ . -..=-»:-;~<;.~=.--w "~ . -+ ." . VIE . . ._ ¢{_-£,-.--;.- - 2'-I =-¢!_-_A.- - _ _ I .___ _ _ __.; -.'--/-.-'¢j-:-;.;_;;-3;-.§=_1;5E . .-3;.» 92""Z»:,'*:_:" 4-1;" .-7., 92 l. '.92._- _ 1 . t --. .. . ".:v!~* ="" --::="- .. : :.-'. -.*"=--:-$9. 0.1-s.---1~» "?*' " ' .=- .. ._---. F. . ..+. i . .--r.. . _ r._~ -~ -Jp,;,,__;w-;v_; 1. - -> 0 _¢_~l;;=-,1 -5:-92¢5'<= .1 . .. ..=--L. _~,, _. 4" .-.-.-_ '. . ' "3'? _
--*1 - »-w-- 1* A -.-~+»-_. ' ,,-. ..' -. 3-f-L-- IF' " - -. ---.' ' .. 392 - .- ..-- .n» 1,; . . .. - .».=-3;-,;,-.>-_ .1_-.,>-__» -s ---L5? -. ..l
I i ,._. . '_,_ . '..;.;;__';E;V~.__.- .~-- .- -.1. .'".-.-1*-W. 2 *-4.:-.- -- -- __- ".j'-'.;'{.'l.,' .1"--'j_"§r_; '___.'_-"Q."-§1§..'.1.1."'_-'_-E.-'2,-_| 1?; -_,,,,,_ - . . . ..__ _¢';;_.,=';.2.?::,_, ... . -' - -1.-.;.j _--. _..;. .. o~
l - _zg_,H4,¢,7444z_:.!' _
6 - _ .,- 1/ ,1¢__.n.¢,g-,6 57¢/J,¢//% N
4/L-
4,, ~~ ,1; _ 4: a
_
1. --. we l.':- . -..-":4 "' .1? '5?" ' - 14"
m'"=<=- -. .=;=.'.?..**'>.r;".-1%-¥<:="*.'~".
/ .:- " =---=-» A-1 -ti-,.-= j,, ./ ~e~ ' ' "'Yr_ £7 /A
:,z .-E. --..'.~ - .- - -7-:1 .. . .._ . ~-~-__' _. . ;.-'».._ _7-,; J4.'- _ .9 _ ~_, - 1 .'__ . .F1... ~,Pc_; ,__§;, .u ___3_ __, _: :;..;.A¢;,_92; '.=_ ' q- .. -... __ .»-- --- <'_' .-_. __
_ :7: _92_ .,.-,. 1.. ; -L.- I -- _ -..-'__~ _I '- -'
.' '_-1
=-.-.-2 ' - . .' ,._,_.,_ -. -1;. '-.u.- ..,=*' _ F
. ,| . . , <92 r
-* . r . J-4' » Q ,.
.'r_!_. Vi :, ,- w,J ' - 1 1._- ~. 92¢._-. _ -..-1. .-a,--|= --.1-»~|.._ . .,- - . .. -'. M.-. ~,'._ __.._-_---92._ _';r |_ .;.'f __ _. L
~ e u 0 c.» c|a'"'"*4"' c c 0 oi
1 T Z
4.!-/1., ~'_:_ ,6./1].; ¢'?"1_,-If-1,4 >____ ;, 7:1'1L;-.
.1 L.1.--- .- :4 v_I~.T ~___ ._ 777.777-> 4
. E km;92 . ' , i I | » - .l I . .»-92,
1-r -1'-w '.-:;-. _. .- -5
1.
.4 'Z<.£»;-
en»-4¥<:1<*+..<:-4=-<---.. - /¢¢vvwZ".-. /<'
»<¢/'~<~{//*'<- .-.
, ' ..,.¢-A.-- 4./Z¢~../~.,. //' /Ldfé,-fa f/ff. j.<,¢Z Q,/A"¢4-.1'..4? |*L:4 4/ :1,/'
~§/92-.,<,/ fxi, /»-=...L.-~74./>-;.c»¬. A ..' ..-»¢..¢._,_%
.4-1/1-/£1--, - ,- ,_Z.=~>,§L,q.: _-J .;z.. ,,....,.,.2.// "' /1 _ / ~ ~ / /71.. »..-,.=.,/ 73:..- -.=.¢'.~..,.7-.44.... .-___. J4/.'J?7.¢_ -"l"...~*.?*t¢- .' H '-;.-N 11+ '5 I K - . .
' +.§' '.~.*.-;' " J 1» ="~' ..- 5 *=% "- " '~ 1. -'._'_5.;'-§_e:;_ .»'. 2 . ~;| _-:,:' W-.___ I" w J ....-*=I-.=*=-":.:.=. . . ._ =-:¢'.»>*..-..~;5§-1.=~.=*a2:s»§-"»..~.:'¢..**~.-".~=r. .. 1./'1 -- s ~ "1/T, .,./ ."rI~"- =92 -- 1-. ' ;'~ -='-5 F,--.;-.-,.-..¢.e1u~.-' _ -¢<.;'~'¬:;Y*"F1"~':- - 1 FA» .. _¢_, . .- --, I» ~//" .14-- . =1 __-_ " -s4 --. ' --I» =. - ' ;r~~.'1
1'L=:l=>4r- * - -»... . #1.. 92:;1:- . // /1 .' ~'>~..».=.-'"'-.~?*.-"=""*.-.--. /"F-. -4 1-1; " *./M1 /-<.-2.. .1-7.4----./ /. , ,.,_- , _,§__;. J6 A. / %//L.-{_"'._
_ _ . !£-hm/¢__ .-¢_,J,.¢ 1..., Li/»..¢.,
* .Y-*1 - /4 ,4.»/4 ..........<z:<4 %....,¢
__ _'l _.. _ . _ __. . __ ___ __i_.___.____ __ ,;-E r'l1.;.; __ ___ __ ________L i i 7 f
n ..92 _i I -5 .4.
i... .- ...| ~
. . 4 . . . . 1.-.--. .-.-. . -rwr . ..- . --.._ >_-=1 .' .#'IIt¢<!_92-l'r- 1-----: ~==._ 1 __ _ '1--'.. - _._-.. ' .. i __ '
.-';-1 -" ' {{{{ " Ls " { Q192.
.-g__ *5?/P '
_I7GJ ___L__' V
____|__ _ _ _ J t_%I:1_f_92___ RH _____"3 M lr_V__V_!___4____ :__
:0
P-F.-_
by _____
L __b_____m_______1 _u£__
_ ____*__ ____ __'__!J_ ,5 _ __ ____ __~ _"l _ 1__'___;
__
3
_' __
k
P _
PH _:
_ f _
92J
__- P V$__ _ _ p_ __ if 1 ,
__ _ ___ A_ _
__ ,_ I F"
_________
'-IP _ II |__ _|7 I _r ____ __d__w*r ____ _______
_
: L IE! PIE
'_ _*_ __B1_ _1
____v_______h_
_.__,_v_ __"_ _,F Iy _ __ uWW u
_J
_
_
____l|_A_____ I_ __92 _
Ha:__V_w____ U ~_ __V_ MW___ __ _
J _r__________r_
A___
___ ___"_ __
__ _ _" _
'H_fr__'__:_____W
,_ __ _
H _1_ _
_"b__
_H_ _:_1
_WF ___H___f_1_P
_%H_ F in92F FA
_ AU