Document text
0 of 3 Premium Clicks used this month SUBSCRIBE Print + Online Subscriber Activation | Register x Forgot Password | Need an Account? e-edition | subscribe | newsletter | deals Home News Latest Stories Emergency Services District board says it won't levy maximum tax rate after all Since You Asked: No traffic signal slated at Main and Highland A test of mettle: GED tests are more rigorous Ashland gets new city parks director Crime, Courts and Emergency Services Emergency Services All evacuation advisories lifted for Rogue River Drive fire Emergency Services Fire levels historic Phoenix house Medford rainfall hits record, halts fire Politics and Elections Commissioner Skundrick plans final four town hall meetings Medford eyes electronic sign visual pollution Medford council veterans plan exit Medical marijuana patients run for council seat Former colleagues laud Atiyeh's 'practical' leadership Education A test of mettle: GED tests are more rigorous Middle schoolers get a taste of college living Abraham Lincoln Elementary parents raise money for new playground State treasurer stumps for educational endowment measure Free meals program expands in Grants Pass Environment Stressed but off life support Rogue watershed councils plan to merge West Nile Virus found in mosquitoes collected near Central Point State news Nation - World Obituaries Clarence "C.A" A. Zeitler Elvia Veatrice Donald Eugene Jackson Kenneth Merrill Chambers Gloria W. Bounds Weather Photo Galleries Videos Web Cams Sports Latest Stories (No heading) For girls in baseball, Little League not the end (No heading) Manfred elected the next MLB commissioner (No heading) Varsity 541 College Sports Beavers have a heated red zone session Thompson Tradition SOU men picked first, women second in CCC Freshman Hawkins catching on at OSU Running down Heisman contenders not named Jameis Pro Sports (No heading) Manfred elected the next MLB commissioner (No heading) (No heading) Record Pace Community Sports Results / Standings Second season a success for Rogues Runners defend titles in Mt. Ashland Hill Climb Locals shine in Dwarf Car Nationals opener Mustangs rout Alaska in opener Business Latest Stories If there's a way to fund energy savings, they'll find it Oregon's unemployment rate holds steady Blog: Big boy investors chasing after Grocery Outlet Blog: Once Upon A Time... Blog: AmericanWest owners seeking ways to cash out Real Estate News Median residential housing prices rise 10.7 percent, but may begin to level out People In Business People in business Transportation Medford airport has second-best June ever Agriculture Hail has local pear growers checking for damage Del Rio plans to add 50% more plants Opinion Latest Letters to the Editor, Aug. 15 Parent-teacher conferences can wait a year Michael Gerson: The paradox of American diversity Letters to the Editor, Aug. 14 Our View: Cheers and Jeers Editorials Parent-teacher conferences can wait a year Our View: Cheers and Jeers Our View: Police body cams provide a valuable tool Other Views: Curbing campus assaults Our View: Dark money flows into Oregon Letters to the Editor Letters to the Editor, Aug. 15 Letters to the Editor, Aug. 14 Letters to the Editor, Aug. 13 Letters to the Editor Tuesday, Aug. 12 Letters to the Editor, Aug. 11 Guest Opinions Who I am and why I want to serve on the City Council City council members should be paid Lifestyle Latest stories Second annual King of the Rogue races Saturday Fishing Report: Friday, Aug. 15 Denman parking scofflaws get reprieve Get Out: Friday, Aug. 15 What's in your Camelbak? Or how not to get stranded on the trail Food Community blog: Spur quicker consumption with quick pickling Dutch ovens are a versatile way to cook outdoors Matt’s Favorite Pie Crust Peach Pie Southwestern Baked Chicken Home and Garden Lawn talk Tips for keeping backyard birds cool this summer Bath time for the birds: You can help them stay cool and clean Learn to pick produce at the peak of ripeness Support the mycorrhizae! It could help your plants Health Community blog:Can We Define Quality Health Care? Patient numbers double at local clinics Shaking that plumb-tuckered feeling Community blog:Maybe the Movies Will Lead the Way Asante plans to open big outpatient clinic in Grants Pass Faith Community Blog: Is Peace Possible in the Middle East - Part three of four Religion briefs Community Blog: Is Peace Possible in the Middle East part 2 Religion briefs Community Blog: Peace: The inward passage - by Bonnie Greenwell Milestones and Achievements Century Club New Arrivals Wedding: Schulman-Nadolny Stuss-Bones Births Tempo Latest stories 5 Things to Do This Weekend Third Fridays art walk in Medford Film festival kicks off annual 'Daedalus Project' Review: The joy of 'Godspell' is infectious Delta Halos and The Lures at Club 66 Theater Film festival kicks off annual 'Daedalus Project' Review: The joy of 'Godspell' is infectious Randall Theatre opens 'Godspell' Entertainment 'on the bricks' at OSF 'Shrek' comes to the stage as a musical Music Review: Béla Fleck pairs his banjo with Britt orchestra Ottmar Liebert & Luna Negra at Pear Blossom Park Duke Street: 'On the Fly' Fleck to perform banjo concerto Sweet Ghosts at Oberon's Community Events 5 Things to Do This Weekend Dining Basil & Berries India Palace Taco Riendo Uber Herbal Tempo Videos Classifieds Jobs Autos Real Estate FEATURED » Obituaries TV Listings Movie Listings Oregon Outdoors Oregon Healthy Living Magazines & Special Sections NEWS NOW ANOTHER VIEW Catherine Rampell: A's for everyone MailTribune.com Writer Posted Aug. 13, 2014 @ 2:00 am Posted Aug. 13, 2014 @ 2:00 am » Social News Grade deflation is dead. Long live grade inflation! Starting around the mid-20th century, a pandemic of meaninglessly high grades swept the nation. Steadily, the Gentleman's C was replaced by the Gentleman's B-pluses. Soon even B-pluses' grew ungentlemanly, with more and more grades compressed into the narrow band spanning from A-minus to A-plus. College administrators and educators saw this as a problem, but each school feared the blowback that would come from being the first to rein it in. Then, brave Princeton, my beloved alma mater, announced that it would lead the charge. In 2004, it imposed nonbinding targets for the percentage of A's that should be awarded in each department, because "students deserve clear signals from their teachers about the difference between their ordinarily good work and their very best work." Students, not surprisingly, were less keen on clarifying these noisy signals. They groused about the targets, saying they would foster cutthroat competitiveness, undermine student collaboration and hurt Tigers' chances on the job market because their counterparts at other elite schools would still have inflated transcripts. At Yale, for example, 62 percent of undergraduate grades are A's and A-minuses; Princeton aimed for 35 percent. Princeton's administration assured uneasy undergrads that other schools would follow. Alas, almost no others did. (Wellesley, which had among the worst grade inflation, implemented a slightly different experiment around the same time.) Now, 10 years later, Princeton appears ready to throw in the towel. In a 35-page report released last week, a committee recommended that the school abandon its efforts. The committee actually found no evidence that the grade targets were hurting students' job or grad school prospects (with one possible exception: ROTC, since grade-point averages factor into an officer's first assignment), which may mean that Princeton's grading standards are still not all that tough; in 2013, about 43 percent of grades were A's or A-minuses, well above the target. That's stingier than Yale and Harvard, but about in line with U.S. colleges overall. So for a few years Princeton students may have had the best of both worlds: a reputation for tough grading but a grade distribution that was actually relatively lenient. Instead, the main arguments Princeton's committee presented for ending "grade deflation" involved concerns about undergraduate stress and recruiting. To fully understand why Princeton caved, though, you have to appreciate why high grades have been awarded at schools across the country in the first place. Some have suggested that affirmative action and the Vietnam War were responsible; in those cases, the theory goes, professors went easy on students who either were less well-prepared for college or needed decent grades to avoid the draft. Neither explanation really lines up with the data. Students likewise have argued that they've just gotten smarter over the years. While the top-ranked schools have indeed become more selective, this theory wouldn't explain why middle-tier schools also inflated grades. (Two-year colleges and the least selective four-year publics do not seem to have inflated their grades much, if at all, which makes sense from a strategic perspective; lower-ranked schools need to clearly signal which students are true standouts to help them get jobs.) And of course even if you believe modern students are uniformly smarter than their parents were, you still might argue that today's grades are supposed to reflect the distribution of talent today, not yesterday. In my view, the most convincing theory comes from Stuart Rojstaczer, a retired Duke geophysicist who has collected oodles of grading data. He blames the "emergence of a consumer-based culture in higher education." As students are forced to pay more and more for a degree, they feel more entitled to high grades. They then pressure professors to weaken standards. Supporting this thesis is the fact that GPA's tend to be more inflated at private schools, where tuition is higher, even after controlling for selectivity. Sites such as RateMyProfessors.com may also play a role, as easier grading tends to encourage better student feedback. Adjuncts in particular need favorable student evaluations to get rehired, making them especially susceptible to inflationary pressures. Plus, academic departments have learned that lenient grading can attract more majors, and thereby earn them more faculty hiring slots. This competitive edge afforded by awarding more A's extends to entire schools, too: "The committee was surprised to learn that students at other schools (e.g., Harvard, Stanford, and Yale) use our grading policy to recruit against us," Princeton's report says. In other words, A's have become a more valuable currency in higher ed, even as, paradoxically, their value on a transcript has been inflated away.   Catherine Rampell's email address is [email protected]. Follow her on Twitter, @crampell. MailTribune.com Writer Posted Aug. 13, 2014 @ 2:00 am » Comment or view comments Reader Reaction » STAY INFORMED Email NewsLetter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. calendar Connect with MailTribune.com Facebook Twitter RSS Back to top Reader Services Reader Services Home Subscriptions Subscriber controls Contact us Submissions Photos Events Letters to the editor Corrections Announcements Obituaries Story ideas Since you asked Alerts Email Alerts RSS Feeds Text Alerts Advertise Media Kit Home Products and services Ad rates Advertising contacts Mail Tribune Daily Tidings The Nickel Shop Our Valley Blogs Stay Informed Email newsletter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. Your privacy is important, read our privacy policy. © Copyright 2014 Local Media Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Local Media Group Publications Original content available for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons license, except where noted. MailTribune.com | P.O. Box 1108, Medford, OR 97501