Document text
0 of 3 Premium Clicks used this month SUBSCRIBE Print + Online Subscriber Activation | Register x Forgot Password | Need an Account? e-edition | subscribe | newsletter | deals Home News Latest Stories Gold Hill wants private company to run wastewater plant Seeing is believing 10 things to know about the Ducks and Buckeyes Design and innovation program proposed at Talent Middle School Mail Tribune 100 Crime, Courts and Emergency Services Emergency Services Emergency services One killed Friday in single-vehicle crash in Rogue River Emergency services Men sentenced in heroin case Politics and Elections Councilman stirs online dust-up with anti-marijuana post State certifies recount showing failure of GMO-labeling measure Education Design and innovation program proposed at Talent Middle School College on the K-12 dime Students forge links between forest health and people Medford School Board meeting deferred because of Ducks game Medford bulks up student support for math, reading Environment OR-7 now officially the leader of his pack Ashland trails up for changes Monument expansion expected to increase tourism, protect resources Biologist resigns over LNG reporting failure Bird flu discovered in Winston backyard flock State News Oregon State University plans $60 million forestry complex Washington man arrested in Portland hotel slaying Timber group updates green label forestry standards Attorney: Use Boy Scout files in sex-abuse trial Oregon capitalizes on championship run Nation - World Obama makes Maduro’s ‘insolent Yankees’ line harder to sell Obituaries Ricardo Ruiz-Santillan Richard Thompson LuErna Mae Jacobson Robert Charles Pollock Bob Lozano Weather Photo Galleries Since You Asked Videos Web Cams Mail Tribune 100 Shareable In memoriam: 2014’s notable deaths Looking back: Do you remember 2014’s biggest stories? Sports Latest Stories Orange Alert Lillard heats up in Blazer victory Randolph, Grizz win 2OT battle No. 11 Oregon State drubs Oregon again Walker, Matsuyama tied for Kapalua lead Varsity 541 College Sports Orange Alert No. 11 Oregon State drubs Oregon again N.C. State hands No. 2 Duke first loss Will players show wear and tear? UO’s resilient receivers stay ready Pro Sports Lillard heats up in Blazer victory Randolph, Grizz win 2OT battle Walker, Matsuyama tied for Kapalua lead Luck leads Colts to upset of Manning, Broncos Packers shake Cowboys, to play for NFC title Community Sports Business Latest Stories Business briefs People in Business Blog: Former Meier & Frank stores avoid Macy's hit list Ride & Drive: 2015 Chevrolet Trax Blog: One Frenchman's perspective on Jan. 7 attack Real Estate News Jackson County real estate market headed back to normal Dear Monty: Best start for 1st-time homebuyers People In Business Transportation Medford airport traffic flies to new heights Falling gas prices help spur travel at Medford airport Agriculture Rising prices bear fruit for local pear growers Opinion Latest Jan. 12 Letters to the Editor Jan. 11 Letters to the Editor Our View: A pipeline should not run through it Another View: A few questions to make the AG nominee squirm Another view: Politicians retreat from racism Editorials Our View: A pipeline should not run through it Other Views: ACLU leader helped change Oregon Our View: It's best to prepare for the worst Our View: Falls has work to do to restore trust Our View: WISE project offers many benefits Letters to the Editor Jan. 12 Letters to the Editor Jan. 11 Letters to the Editor Letters to the Editor, Jan. 9 Letters to the Editor, Jan. 8 Letters to the Editor, Jan. 7 Guest Opinions Guest Opinion: FERC fails our planet Guest Opinion: East is east and west is west Guest Opinion: Get the best deal on pipeline Guest Opinion: Say yes to clean energy jobs, no to the LNG project Guest Opinion: Loved one chose death with dignity in Oregon Lifestyle Latest stories Home Help: Heighten your home’s style this year Chasing the mopes The King's rocky career road ... past his supposed death It's about what we give out Medics in the Woods Food Community blog: Happy New Beer Year! Community blog: Scanty spuds stretch winter greens into salad Entertaining with a gift of treasure Food for Thought: Save time on weeknight meal prep Community blog: Farm share boosts resolve to eat more veggies Home and Garden Home Help: Heighten your home’s style this year 11 reasons why we love wrought iron fencing Dear Monty: Eight great tips to ponder before investing in real estate Home Help: Timeless or trendy? Achieve both in your home decor this year Dear Monty: Best start for 1st-time homebuyers Health Dr. Murray Feingold: Separation anxiety common in adults Health Watch: Staying fit as a frequent flyer Community blog: Tale of the Tape Community blog: We Don't Have To Conspire Against Good Health HealthStyle: New year, new you Hiking Biking Faith Churches start new year with messages of hope (No heading) Churches, synagogs host seasonal events Bethel Church helps families at McLoughlin Middle School Milestones and Achievements Old stained-glass windows face threats 50 years and counting: Bulebar Wedding: Lindsey-Maria Rios New arrivals Since You Asked: Sheriff's Office sells off foreclosed homes Columnist for a Day Rogue Healthy Aging Tempo Latest stories Live Music in Local Clubs Patty Groth's Morning Glory is still a delight 100 Watt Mind unveils 'Creatures' American Guitar Masters play the Imperial Chamber Music Concerts presents Tesla Quartet Theater Tangled up in Dylan OSF's 'Great Society' up for Kennedy Prize Next Stage presents a tribute to an iconic folk artist Camelot's 'Fiddler' is a charmer ACT presents reading of 'The Quality of Life' Music Live Music in Local Clubs 100 Watt Mind unveils 'Creatures' American Guitar Masters play the Imperial Chamber Music Concerts presents Tesla Quartet Blues jam tonight at Little Brown Jug Community Events Art Presence showcases 'Naked Art' New Schneider Museum exhibits highlight First Friday Celebrate winter solstice with the Bad Film Society Tomaseen Foley's "A Celtic Christmas" returns to the Craterian Theater Stefan Baumann and Eugene Bennett highlight Third Fridays Dining Patty Groth's Morning Glory is still a delight Entertaining with a gift of treasure Jackson Creek Pizza Co. is a good downtown haunt Dobra Tea menu offers hundreds of brews Food for Thought: Wintertime wining and dining Tempo Videos Classifieds Jobs Autos Real Estate FEATURED » Obituaries Blogs TV Listings Movie Listings Oregon Outdoors Oregon Healthy Living Magazines & Special Sections NEWS NOW Seeing is believing ... 10 things to know about the Ducks and Buckeyes ... Design and innovation program proposed at Talent Middle School ... Seeing is believing ... 10 things to know about the Ducks and Buckeyes ... Design and innovation program proposed at Talent Middle School ... OUR VIEW Our View: A pipeline should not run through it Comment MailTribune.com Writer Posted Jan. 11, 2015 @ 12:01 am Posted Jan. 11, 2015 @ 12:01 am » Social News A proposal to build a 232-mile-long pipeline to carry liquefied natural gas from Klamath County to an exporting facility in Coos Bay has drawn expected protests from environmentalists and property owners along the pipeline's route. We don't think their arguments are especially compelling, but we do think they are on the right side of the debate, for a different reason that can be boiled down to two words: public benefit. Aside from the jobs that will be created — the vast majority of which will be temporary — the Pacific Connector pipeline project does not provide a public benefit. Rather, it provides a benefit to a private Canadian company that wants to export an energy resource to buyers in Asia. To do that, it proposes to build a pipeline across the mountainous terrain of Southern Oregon, crossing 400 streams and rivers along the way, to connect to a massive natural gas terminal at Jordan Cove in Coos Bay, where the gas would pass through a super-cooling process before being loaded onto tankers bound for the Far East. If you are a resident of Coos Bay, you might well argue there is ample public benefit in the form of an estimated 145 permanent jobs that would inject hope into a community desperately in need of that commodity. If you live in Klamath, Jackson or Douglas counties, the public benefits are considerably less: an estimated $11 million in annual property tax revenue (of which about $3 million would go to Jackson County). The price of that payment includes allowing eminent domain seizures of rights of way through hundreds of property owners' lands, a 36-inch pipeline crossing the Rogue, Klamath, Umpqua and Coquille rivers, to name the most prominent, and the construction of a processing plant in Coos Bay that on start-up would immediately become one of the largest, if not the largest, emitter of greenhouse gas in Oregon. We take the environmental concerns with a large dose of salt, however. The impact of the pipeline construction would be temporary, save for the 50-foot-wide corridor along the pipeline route. Concerns raised that Pacific Crest Trail hikers would see that corridor for one to three minutes do not move us to wring our hands. The fact is, people have an impact on the world around them, something that seems to escape the hard-core environmentalists when they turn on the light in the morning, take a shower and then drive to a protest meeting. There are myriad federal and state environmental rules the pipeline and terminal builders will have to follow and we have confidence the project can be built with minimal — not zero, but minimal — impact. The oft-mentioned "likelihood" of some sort of explosion along the line or at the facility is a scare tactic that doesn't hold up under scrutiny. Nothing is absolutely safe, but new technology has made these pipelines remarkably resistant to outside forces, even earthquakes and tsunamis, as evidenced in Japan in 2011. We certainly sympathize with property owners along the route and think that some of the payments proposed, most in the several-thousand-dollar range, are not nearly enough from a company that stands to reap hundreds of millions — probably billions — over the years from its sales of natural gas. Were this a project with a discernible public benefit, such as a highway or a power line,  the property owners' concerns would have to be set aside for the good of the larger community. But that's not the case. In the end, once this line is built, the benefit will fall almost wholly to the private company financing it and secondarily to the area of Coos Bay. Some may argue that the jobs, including the significant number of temporary construction jobs, create the public benefit in a region that has never fully rebounded from the loss of timber and fishing jobs. But there are counter arguments (from, among others, Dow Chemical) that siphoning off a cheap and readily available energy source for export will in the end cost American manufacturers and American jobs. We have long argued that the state and federal governments need to find a way to work past the stalemate that has crippled resource-dependent rural areas and give people hope that they will again see jobs and dollars pumped into their economies. This project does not do that, however, but rather would pump profits and jobs through our region, on their way elsewhere. MailTribune.com Writer Posted Jan. 11, 2015 @ 12:01 am » Comment or view comments Reader Reaction » STAY INFORMED Email NewsLetter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. calendar Connect with MailTribune.com Facebook Twitter RSS Back to top Reader Services Reader Services Home Subscriptions Subscriber controls Contact us Submissions Photos Events Letters to the editor Corrections Announcements Obituaries Story ideas Since you asked Alerts Email Alerts RSS Feeds Text Alerts Advertise Media Kit Home Products and services Ad rates Advertising contacts Mail Tribune Daily Tidings The Nickel Shop Our Valley Blogs Stay Informed Email newsletter Sign Up Today Sign up for our newsletter and have the top headlines from your community delivered right to your inbox. Your privacy is important, read our privacy policy. © Copyright 2015 Local Media Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Local Media Group Publications Original content available for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons license, except where noted. MailTribune.com | P.O. Box 1108, Medford, OR 97501