Estate of Elkins v. C.I.R., 140 T.C. No. 5 (2013)
Estate of Elkins v. C.I.R., 140 T.C. No. 5 (2013)
140 T.C. 86, Tax Ct. Rep. (CCH) 59,471, Tax Ct. Rep. Dec. (RIA) 140.5
55
56
57 Graves, Nancy
Meadmore, Clement
Noland, Kenneth Omon (Series E) 1976
(Wax crayon on paper, 35-
x 47-1/4-)
Untitled, 1992 (Bronze,
Height: 8-1/2")
Hand Painted Bookcover,
1977 (Acrylic on canvas, 3,000
3,000
2,000
11" x 12")
58 Hamilton, Juan Abstract Form # 52, 1975 1,75 0
(Height: 14-1/2")
59 Love, Jim Monday Morning: What 1,200
to do ... What to do, 1992
(Welded Steel, 8- x
60 Love, Jim Looking for Santa Claus 1,200
(welded steel, 9—3/3" x 8")
61 Stella, Frank Pastel Stack, 1970 (28" x 900
41")
62 Fuller, Sue String Composition # 213, 750
1963 (Nylon & Saran
thread with Plexiglas, 36" x
36")
63 N/A Sepik River Carved 250
Polychrome Wood Mask,
20th Century (Height: 64"; Width: 22")
64 N/A Sepik River Carved and 100
Polychrome —Painted
Wood Shield, 20th Century
(Height: 69-1/2"; Width:
14")
Total 24,580,650
*138 APPENDIX B
Nash Artist Title/year Option 1 Option 2 Concluded Fair market
category discount discount discount value of interest
I Johns, J. Figure 4, 1967 71.72% 70.31% 70.31% $1.735.188
I Pollock. J. Untitled, Number 51.69% 59.68% 51.69% 1,449.210
21. 1949
I Moore, H. Two-Piece 51.69% 66.89% 51 .69% 966.140
Reclining Figure
No. 3, 1961
WestlawNex! © 2014 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works.
EFTA01194324
Estate of Elkins v. C.I.R., 140 T.C. No. 5 (2013)
140 T.C. 86, Tax Ct. Rep. (CCH) 59,471. Tax Ct. Rep. Dec. (RIA) 140.5
Francis, S. Green Gold, 1956 65.78% 68.95% 65.78% 624.926
I Motherwell, R. Elegy to Spanish 65.78% 84.64% 65.78% 374.956
Republic # 134,
1976
II Twombly, C. Untitled. 1971 71.08% 84.64% 71.08% 316.948
II Hockney. D. Pool on Sprayed 71.08% 100.00% 71.08% 190.169
Blue Paper ...
1978
III Bravo, C. Blue and Brown 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 140.640
Package. 1971
III Bravo, C. Wrapped Canvas, 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 140.64 0
1973
II Kelly. E. Yellow Panel. 71.08% 67.43% 67.43% 190.350
1985
II Moore. H. Standing Figure 71.08% 75.70% 71.08% 126.779
(Internal Form)
II Cezanne. P. Pot de geraniums,
ca. 1885 71.08% 79.90% 71.08% 116.214
II Soulages. P. 8 June 61.1961 71.08% 80.00% 71.08% 116.214
II Magritte, R. La lecon des
tenebres. 1964 71.08% 91.19% 71.08% 95,084
II Picasso. P. Baigneuse
debout. 1925 71.08% 96.83% 71.08% 86.7 70
II Albers, J. Study for Homage
to a Square in 71.08% 98.98% 71.08% 84,519
White Light, 1968
II Johns, J. Three Flags, 1977 71.08% 98.98% 71.08% 84,519
11 Hofmann. H. Adagio. 1962 71.08% 100.00% 71.08% 79.2371
II Louis. M. Delta Epsilon, 71.08% 100.00% 71.08% 79,237
1960
II Ernst. M. The Elements .... 71.08% 100.00% 71.08% 73,954
1962
II Moore. H. Family Group, 71.08% 100.00% 71.08% 73,954
1944
II De Kooning. Woman in a 71.08% 100.00% 71.08% 63,390
W. Garden, 1968
II Louis. M. Achenar, 1962 71.08% 100.00% 71.08% 46,486
WestlawNex! © 2014 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works.
EFTA01194325
Estate of Elkins v. C.I.R., 140 T.C. No. 5 (2013)
140 T.C. 86, Tax Ct. Rep. (CCH) 59,471. Tax Ct. Rep. Dec. (RIA) 140.5
II Moore, H. Working Model
for Thin Reclining 71.08% 100.00% 71.08% 42,260
Figure, 1978
II Frankenthaler. Fathom. 1983 71.08% 100.00% 71.08% 38,034
H.
III Bravo, C. Silver and Gold, 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 44.41 3
1972
III Rickey. G. Untitled (Open 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 44,413
Rectangles),
ca.1985
III Botero, F. Parrot. 1981 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 29,608
III Kline. F. The Hill. 1959 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 29,608
III Hofmann. H. Untitled (M-418), 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 22,206
1964
III Olitski. J. Carnegie Hall.
ca.1962-64 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 22,206
III Hockney. D. Nichols Canyon 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 20,726
Road. Hollywood
Boulevard, 1979
III Heizer. M. Untitled. ca.1985 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 14,804
III Di Suvero. M. Untitled. ca.1968 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 13.3 24
III Bertoia, H. Sunburst, 1972 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 11,843
III Frankenthaler, Untitled. ca.1975 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 8.883
H.
III Bertoia, H. Untitled (Sounding 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 7.402
Sculpture), 1968
III Motherwell, R. In green with Two 79.74% 1 00 .00% 79.74% 7.402
Scarlet Spots.
1967
III Held. A. North by 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 6,2 18
Northwest, 1973
III Hofmann. H. Untitled. 1949 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 5.922
III Dine. J. Tie. 1961 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 5.181
III Bertoia, H. Untitled 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 4.441
III Frankenthaler, Canal Street VIII, 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 3.701
H. 1987
III Craig—Martin.
M. Safety Pin,
ca.1990 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 3.257
WestlawNex! © 2014 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works.
EFTA01194326
Estate of Elkins v. C.I.R., 140 T.C. No. 5 (2013)
140 T.C. 86, Tax Ct. Rep. (CCH) 59,471. Tax Ct. Rep. Dec. (RIA) 140.5
Ill Hofmann. H. Untitled (N-677— 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 2.961
2), 1956
III Hofmann. H. Fluse # 12 (M- 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 2.961
1351),1962
III Nagare, M. Destination, 1996 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 2.665
III Motherwell, R. Je t'aime avec
noir, 1978 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 2.221
III Graves. N. Four Times Four, 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 1,184
1977
III Hofmann. H. Untitled. 1954 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 888
II Frankenthaler, Thanksgiving Day. 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 592
H. 1980
III Frankenthaler,
H. Thanksgiving Day.
ca.1980 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 592
III N/A Japanese Painted
and Silvered 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 592
Paper Four—
Panel Screen,
3d Quarter. 19th
Century
III Frankenthaler, Hand Painted 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 518
H. Book Cover # 11.
1970
III Graves. N. Omon (Series E). 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 444
1976
III Meadmore, C. Untitled. 1992 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 444
III Noland. K. Hand Painted 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 296
Bookcover, 1977
III Hamilton, J. Abstract Form # 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 259
52. 1975
III Love, J. Monday Morning: 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 178
What to do ...
What to do, 1992
III Love, J. Looking for Santa 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 178
Claus
III Stella, F. Pastel Stack, 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 133
1970
Ill Fuller, S. String 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 111
Composition #
213, 1963
WestlawNext © 2014 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works.
EFTA01194327
Estate of Elkins v. C.I.R., 140 T.C. No. 5 (2013)
140 T.C. 86, Tax Ct. Rep. (CCH) 59,471, Tax Ct. Rep. Dec. (RIA) 140.5
III N/A Sepik River 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 37
Carved
Polychrome
Wood Mask. 20th
Century
III N/A Sepik River 79.74% 100.00% 79.74% 15
Carved and
Polychrome —
Painted Wood
Shield. 20th
Century
*139 APPENDIX C VALUES OF DECEDENT'S INTERESTS
IN THE 64 WORKS OF ART FOR
FEDERAL ESTATE TAX PURPOSES
Item Artist Title/year Decedent's pro rata share
of stipulated fair market
value'
1 Pollock. Jackson Untitled. Number 21. 1949 $3.000.000
2 Moore, Henry Two—Piece Reclining 2.000.000
Figure No. 3, 1961
3 Picasso, Pablo Baigneuse debout, 1925 300.000
4 Johns, Jasper Figure 4, 1967 5.844.400
5 Francis. Sam Green Gold, 1956 1.826.375
6 Motherwell, Robert Elegy to Spanish Republic 1.095.825
# 134, 1976
7 Twombly, Cy Untitled, 1971 1.095.825
8 Hockney. David Pool on Sprayed Blue 657.495
Paper ... 1978
9 Kelly, Ellsworth Yellow Panel. 1985 584.440
10 Moore, Henry Standing Figure (Internal 438.330
Form)
11 Cezanne, Paul Pot de geraniums, ca. 1885 401.803
12 Soulages, Pierre 8 June 61, 1961 401.803
13 Magritte. Rene La lecon des tenebres, 328.748
1964
14 Albers, Joseph Study for Homage to a 292,220
Square in White Light, 1968 Fair market value of
decedent's interest
after application of 10%
discount
$2.700.00 0
1.800,000
270,000
5.259.960
1.643.738
986.243
986.243
591.746
525.996
394.497
361.623
361.623
295.873
262.998
WestlawNex! © 2014 Thomson Reuters. No claim to original U.S. Government Works.
EFTA01194328
📷 Images in this document (5 detected)
AI-generated factual descriptions of embedded images (llava:13b). These are searchable across the corpus.
[Image 1] The image appears to be a scanned document, specifically a financial report or statement. It lists various expenses and income items, with corresponding monetary values. The document includes columns with numbers, dates, and descriptions of the transactions. There are names of individuals or entities associated with the transactions, such as "G. Love," "Jim Loveless," "S. S. Selig," "J. H. Hamilto
[Image 2] The image displays a table with various columns and rows, each containing text. The text appears to be a list of names, possibly representing individuals or entities, along with percentages. The percentages are likely indicative of some form of performance or achievement. The table is structured with headers at the top, and each row seems to correspond to a different category or group. The text is
[Image 3] The image appears to be a scanned document, specifically a table or list with numerical data. The document is titled "THE AFTERMATH OF THE CIVIL WAR, 1865-1875," and it lists various names, dates, and monetary figures, which seem to be related to the economic and social conditions following the American Civil War. The visible names include "Patrick Jackson," "Matthew Henry," "John Smith," "Mary Jo
[Image 4] The image appears to be a screenshot of a table from a document or a spreadsheet. The table contains rows with numbers and percentages, which seem to represent some form of data or statistics. Each row has a number, a name, and a percentage value next to it. The names are likely individuals or entities, and the percentages could indicate some form of measurement or comparison. The document is titl
[Image 5] The image appears to be a screenshot of a table from a document or a spreadsheet. The table contains rows with numbers and percentages, indicating some form of data or statistics. The visible text includes column headers such as "Rank," "Name," "Age," "Date of Birth," "Date of Death," "Date of Death," "Date of Death," "Date of Death," and "Date of Death." The percentages range from 0% to 100%, sug