31 May 2015 Integrated Oil US Integrated Oils Figure SI: Though the recent recovery and narrowing of WTI-WCS has increased rail netbacks for Canadian heavies to the Gulf Coast, rail economics remain 'heavily challenged 1 70.0 80.0 50.0 40.0 30.0 20.0 10.0 „ "'' -ftnirAnn "23 ...ingArI:3 m'ArAnirra 0.0 ,,,, !u, ... lilt?, . wiz "I"• ...... 'II" .... !. ... "1 •..", • ..... -10.0 -20.0 -30.0 -40.0 awe Price Ciff to Implied Stumen Price (SOK) g21.1rva4nr .r.2 IaraQn11,- - !i2.1 .... ....... 'II " • ", /std. aka. Opex Sustaining Capex —Net Back to GC No 6 (3% Sulfur) Fuel Oil SOL/C4 DolaitSChe Sint lituf rAidleedv db0rnbevra entre 1O% (Aben's .re 4W SCONCIOKIIIATOUS IFigure 82: Key Growth Projects, 2014-2020 J Prof Start Peak Prod 201.2017 2014,2011 'flint ILA Ilrgi on Country totter °panic? Pnrjrd Two ore Stara MI 140W Vr Prot. Prod Irearl North &Tears (Anwar Alnabroca IsPerlalOd &shone Onilrearn 8 MD 1010 III 143 SA-dam vrojed NonnAmenta Canwar Atralrnua canegoVhdlips Onshorn Onstrtam MIA X07 20/11 9S 109 Canadian Natural PlOrl/OndrOgal North Adana Canada Adnabarda --In Onshore Ondrearn II X08 1469 RI 165 lot., Croti north AnanA• C..441. AthitAncr C•11.111 foot Cvdrror. Ondrorm al 21)111 2(69 MI 121 AOSP MAO Amenc• Canirdo Athabasca Snell Onsnore Ons16Arrn II X03 2021 Id SS Sande north Amery Canada Adsbava Hasid Caren OnrrAre On IVI,IfIl 8 XI5 2025 60 (0 Chislina Ude Protect North Andes,. Canada •ihabassa CorrI4oPhIllIps Onshore °natters 9 x02 3)25 SI IDS 1hberns S subsea 411691 IlAW Ordbed LA* North Amer. North Amery.. Canal, Canada krtratoundirrd AtIatraIda r•MCC DAG (nein Sh.rlarr Onshore Onstroam Onitream 36 9 XII ZOOS 2017 MS SI 47 ZA (0 Marsh North Anvers. CJI.4•1 Addbuvra Devon Inera Onarerre Onthearn $ al:07 :on 41 41 Sane' AUTO* Ant Iltoctiaateris Page 46 Deutsche Bank Securities Inc. CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0058897 CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00205081 EFTA01367364