INVESTIGATIVE

CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIVE DIVISION NY AD. GERMINAL BRIEFING ADIC JAMES SMITH EFTA00160670 •CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIVE DIVISION FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION UNCLASSIFIEDMES Criminal Threat Bandings Threats FO Band HQ Band (FY23) Corruption of Domestic Public Officials II I Civil Rights II I Crimes Against Children II II Financial Crimes and Intellectual Property Rights II II II II II Health Care Fraud III Money Laundering Facilitators II TOC — Eastern Hemisphere II TOC — Western Hemisphere II II Violent Gangs II II Violent Incident Crimes - Domestic III Human Trafficking III III Indian Country Crimes Unbanded III International Human Rights Unbanded III Corruption of Foreign Officials and Antitrust III IV Environmental Crimes Unbanded IV Fraud Against the Government III IV Violent Incident Crimes — International IV IV EFTA00160671 0 CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIVE DIVISION FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION Agent FSL Statistics FY23 NY Criminal Special Agent FSL PC 13% TOC-West 5% UNCLASSIFIEDMES 2C3CCIP 9 HCF %CR 3% C N M VA: 4ilb VCG 22% Threat FSL AOB Civil Rights 10 9.46 Complex Financial Crimes 84 90.23 Health Care Fraud 32 26.61 Public Corruption 48 37.44 TOC-East 77 76.23 TOC-West 18 18.61 Violent Crime and Gangs 78 88.43 VCAC 15 20.48 Total Criminal 362 367.49 Page 2 of 34 EFTA00160672 •CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIVE DIVISION FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION UNCLASSIF IE DMES Crimes Against Children PCOR Name: SSA Seamus Clarke Most Recent FOSP Rating: Mid-Year Year-End 2022 On Track High Performing 2023 On Track N/A Threat Banding • FBI New York (NY) Crimes Against Children (CAC) is a Band II threat, which is consistent with field offices in the region, FBI Newark (NK) and FBI Philadelphia (PH). Both comparative offices are a Band II under the CAC threat. Threat Profile vs National Threat Picture • The CAC threat for NY is similar to the national threat picture., NY focused on the production of CSAM, sextortion, online enticement, and travelers. Intel Production for Banded Threats • FBI NY CAC intelligence production is commensurate with a Band II threat when compared to NK and PH. Half of NY's FY23 CAC strategic production focused on online groups extorting minors to harm themselves or others, a cross-programmatic threat that is being led by a NY DT squad. Level of Engagement with HQ • NY maintains consistent communication with CACHTU, and routinely provides thorough and timely updates regarding significant events within its AOR. • In FY23, NY co-authored a PSA and EIR with CACHTIU. CACHTIU facilitated a briefing by NY at a virtual sub-IPC on Child Sexual Exploitation and Abuse. Initiatives • NY maintains an effective and productive Group I UCO. Areas of Opportunity/Program Strengths • In FY23, NY opened 88 new investigations, approximately 70% of which address Tier I/Tier II threats. Program Weaknesses & Recommendations: • CACHTU recommends NY continue to target Tier I and Tier II offenders and increase its target for activities to interrupt the threat significantly. Additional Important Information: • NY effectively utilizes two CEHTTFs, which have 15 funded TFOs, to build relationships with its state/local partners. EFTA00160673 •CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIVE DIVISION FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION UNCLASSIF IE DHLES Human Trafficking — C20 PCOR Name: SSA Seamus Clarke Most Recent FOSP Rating: Mid-Year Year-End 2022 On Track High Performing 2023 On Track N/A Threat Banding • FBI New York (NY) Human Trafficking (HT) is a Band III threat, which is consistent with field offices in the region, Newark (NK) and FBI Philadelphia (PH). Both comparative offices are a Band III under the HT threat. Threat Profile vs National Threat Picture • The HT threat for NY is similar to the national threat picture. The majority of HT efforts and intelligence production for NY are focused on the sex trafficking sub-threat. Intel Production for Banded Threats • FBI NY HT intelligence production is commensurate with a Band Ill threat when compared to NK and PH. NY focused on diversifying their production and enhancing their intelligence collection capabilities. Level of Engagement with HQ • NY maintains consistent communication with CACHTU, and routinely provides thorough and timely updates regarding significant events within its AOR. Initiatives • NY's Penn Track initiative addresses high levels of sex trafficking and violent crime in a targeted geographical area in Brooklyn. Working closely with NYPD, NY has generated 12 CEHTTF investigations in pursuit of more than one 120 traffickers of minors and adults. Areas of Opportunity/Program Strengths • NY continues to work the highest profile HT cases in the FBI: i.e. Epstein, NXIVM, OneTaste. Program Weaknesses & Recommendations: • CACHTU recommends NY continue to target Tier I and Tier II offenders and increase liaison/tripwire activities significantly. Additional Important Information: • NY's HT program is a model for other field offices and is the only HT program rated "High Performing" in each of the last 6 years. EFTA00160674 EFTA00160675 EFTA00160676 EFTA00160677 EFTA00160678 EFTA00160679 EFTA00160680 EFTA00160681 EFTA00160682 EFTA00160683 EFTA00160684 EFTA00160685 EFTA00160686 EFTA00160687 EFTA00160688 EFTA00160689 EFTA00160690 EFTA00160691 EFTA00160692 EFTA00160693 EFTA00160694 EFTA00160695 EFTA00160696 EFTA00160697 EFTA00160698 EFTA00160699 EFTA00160700 EFTA00160701 EFTA00160702 EFTA00160703 EFTA00160704