SegynOeg luee eipSinea 'Figure 20: Commodity Sionsiovity Anblysis - VD'S&IS00 Oil - S millions alga 'Amin IIIIIIII Meng FY IS FY16 Levrage FY IS FY 16 rn .44 FY 15 FY16 653075 SOY) 75 370(3 75 $500 75 5600.75 5700.75 5570 .75 1609.75 6709 76 1500 75 1643 375 1704.75 5500.75 3600.75 6700 .75 $50I3 75 WOO 75 670415 1154R4•4 CNA °vest-este &Avg, Se 1 IBS. 3474 4 370 4.663 3.440 4060 4.6711 14 2.9( 224 la 324 2a 214 11.602) 11.2191 16.17) 11.972) 113431 1714) xEC CIIII•ltl Energy Walt 939 1.143 1.347 1.006 1261 1.66 Oat 181 1 44 1 04 16 134 16 1526) (3771 inn (531) 1312) 193) CXO Ceecha Resources 16344). 1.723 1.636 1.016 161 1.646 2480 174 2.44 22 214 3.14 26. 2.34 14471 (3761 OM 166) 1607) 1667) eiii.CRP eicop Emig, Ba3/126 1.023 1.115 1,246 948 1.118 1.66 0.94 2.14 1St It 264 2.3 1.7s 19741 (0721 (711) 163) 044) VW NF X Na(Atie Exoccelen 134101111- 1.107 1204 1464 1803 1.210 1,517 21). 2.3x I* It 294 21* 1.54 122 00 447 1527) 1303) 00 CEP OEF Retourtes Be 1830. 1.110 1246 1.351 105 1.112 1320 0.94 Lb 164 02( 2.1.4 It I* OM (2331 (147) 15211 (346) 1166) RRC Range Revue), NIBS* 1.097 1.16$ 1241 1675 1.266 1.336 2h 3.11 2* 244 3.44 2* 2.6 13161 (2371 OM 1211) 1101 (47) SSA E 801 514 Etta* 5 INF/ WC% Enogy BOAS 041/40. 1.1 73 MI 1110 486 (.463 1.016 556 1 06 714 1274 673 1 Zs to 2* 1.74 2.1x IS: I Es 144 4 34 4 ft3.04 3.14 2 b 2.34 645 I(615)) (563)S631(441) 092) 1601) III) 080 1766) 063) On) 66C.C44,111 Rich AQUER Annacen Ferman Cm 'FCC* 26 346 402 193 263 333 NA 0.14 764 6.34 17.8r 12.34 9.34 1474) (4191 (364) 1674) 1606) (534) AR Amoco Reverts* BIBB 1446 1578 1.711 2021 2.216 2.412 31, 2.14 I* 17, 24.ftb 1 74 110161 (9251 OW) 1246 11661 17 6G1 0/46 Ilerent•0444 Energy Otneurylltscurces 113.13. BIBB 319 656 377 997 631 1050 251 4)5 323 661 364 672 1.0% 274 3.6 4.0t 2*.c 344 2h 304 4 b 21.: 5 Oz 2.14 3 64 (122311:il (2°61;62411 010) 374(54) OW II 10 4 196 PANG. thefleck Energy 643 266 362 417 269 334 a 1.41 2.14 114 121 1.04 1.b 0.7z 03) 1101 50 120 EFE EP Emegy ICA 1400 1.611 1 626 13611 1.426 1.64 104 3* 2* 2* 334 31x 3m 11631 (3451 (320) 195 244 293 XCO P670 EACO Retcvrch rant W Ca KVCCC• itCCC 49 2 27/ 34a 313 361 327 374 215 303 257 334 266 324 4114 5* 7.34 53), 7.0( 50c 6.74 70z 14.0z 7.14 11.2t 644 10.6 (11174641 40 69 I Rap 064) 131r) ( 127)110 127916 1247) 1410)3 Natal Rescreen 0440/COC• 641 665 669 576 630 la 40( lb 5* 534 674 4.04 55* 20 35 50 050/ (1031 156) 47601 1.8. utrearearn Resat/6 lAzgoan Hume. 064743. CCC 263 103 309 125 3S1 116 167 106 256 IX326 234 6114 S* 14.14 4* 1156 414 9* 8.34 It* 5.86 136s 4.44 11 It (7) adz3S(141 24 512 1211) WO lAthirez Petrclasn CatS 259 334 376 241 297 354 3.64 7.04 52/ 5.14 916 7.0, 5.74 13021 (NO (220) OM 075) 170 04$ Ottsis Pettoeurn MB* 766 544 653 429 5511 607 274 3* 346 324 611 4a 3.2) 11051 (761 (51) 14) PARSLY Peary Ca41(CCC• 216 261 291 222 20 307 2 Ix 3* 2* 234 3.9c 213r 2.14 11521 0201 ((03) iiii PM 6 PVA Pat wont( Rosen Chief. 62 697 712 344 MO 466 2414 2.14 204 I* 411 36 321 12011 0091 ((76) (1131) (117) (74) ROSE BIB& 451 560 66 422 514 406 2h 4.44 364 32x 5.3( 4.04 314 (341) MN 0116) hp es *mut Inyettreute Sneer Sma5404 Eibmg, Seven Gererean Tom* Pettoieten SANST 6$ $0 Vil Ch vCCC cos-82B IISCCC• 445 367 646 463 495 447 729 504 544 507 611 54$ 196 272 367 506 462 347 533 617 526 422 660 724 604 I* 154 NIA 49.: 564 3.6 Ittc" 484 214 7 EN 3.34 4 7A 16 12.0t 6.94 104.14 10 .Ix 5.04 732: 0.68 3* 5 64 2.34 163/ (3631 13761 (3191 (6401 (5741 run) u.crui (3223 OM (936) (1.OM (j4434: 1926 (4S279) 7 0601 141:16) 014) 146) TPLM Ca vCCC• 214 225 237 200 217 226 254 4m 34:4 3014 4.6 4.2c 3a 17021 (1021 0823 170) (57) 145) TAIGA GI " 11W 82i8 1.193 120 1.154 677 1.014 1.151 164 3.74 3.44 324 5.04 4.2s 364 18021 (146) (694) 06) 13) 99 Sam Orate Sot cceepsev letcmcwg Isnancx. (P Fa rye IbIoseng ccereres nY ea...wryCB Mr Noe rte foreman loins teeter cant/ neeseass mattes 0* AMPER.A/(6C41.440,4ANG,EPt( mom 'mit wox.A.F. PCPVA(4054.5N.MWEItS4t(PL44 77 Ws'4 VIPX CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00190752 DB-SDNY-0044568 EFTA01357790