abete422( ./aezt,a0d 1
,althfifr
abete422( ./aezt,a0d 1
-aevn-e-iy -I (1677 -1-4-4: ra /-ez-/,
gym.. --izzet 74 ,V6ti 42,
pa 7,-* Zeal girl& d'infizaze,
4eST wz, ,a-le ,ad/vill ,7.7„c,
/
P.033,WIMMINWAriazdf;
EFTA01699268
CAom LtIvto Sac
eNvIustoti N OM O
To Arkwom TA,O1scldviq 70-.sk Fame,
Raw:kJ (3umcuk 0 t_ vLAAA; ottairotis
Eckciow 4-60\ AA, auedistivtg za,v14 33201
oc3; (W4AvIsti lvakvio_ NveLl tiu
k)oz\v‘viicov) M53?
To Likikovv, 0- ft" Cockm
rP1tcose. \vmh\-ieritt nz hiettAiolkiffAi hMAA&RA- oz18.0,m,
caLmob ickma Oasts \\A VCA5L koa-ouuktd aAkwa . Aiv):
(\5\5) u SCA:A\ 1 VIAL VIVetiViS ‘4 oh me. G2 \v, SeipirQmibvv
)c01`91 Sca' Koloaxvte vkov,cs
akuct
oti- oss lase ov) ries 50-5-1 k N4outal esteotatkme
TuAt. Doo)
1
Aamks ouAck treicvas
EFTA01699269
Bloomberg Eiosinessweek August 5. 2019
1
B
U
S
N
E
S
Edited by
James E. Elks and
Dirnitra Kessenides VICTORIA'S SECRET
A modeling agency linked to Jeffrey
Epstein is just one of the chain's worries
Time isn't being kind to Victoria's Secret. The
lingerie retailer has a problem with the past and a
problem with the future-and that leaves the pres-
ent in a muddle of controversy.
Jeffrey Epstein is supposed to be history at the
company—and at its parent, L Brands Inc., for that
matter—but he's that skeleton that keeps rattling
around the closet to remind everyone he was once
an all-too-lively part of the business. Epstein had a
two-decade-long reign as close confidant, financial the prosecution. Epstein now sits in a Manhat
manager, and right hand to the corporation's chief jail awaiting trial—and perhaps more revelation
executive officer, Leslie Wexner. He even had the salacious secrets. On July 23 he was found inju
CEO's power of attorney at one time. in his cell and put on suicide watch.
Although he wasn't an employee at Victoria's L Brands' efforts to distance itself from Epsi
Secret, Epstein also influenced the way the lin- may not have been all that clean a break. Epstei
one point had a $1 million investment in MC2 Mr
Management, according to a sworn deposition I
former company bookkeeper. MC2 is owned byk
Luc Brunel, a Frenchman who's alleged in a civil I
suit to have brought girls as young as 12 to the I
for sexual purposes and provided them to Epsi
and other friends. Brunel even visited Epstein w
he was first imprisoned in 2008. Victoria's Se(
continued to work with MO-represented mot
after Wexner severed ties with Epstein. At least tt
MO models walked in its 2015 fashion show,genie company operated, associating with the
division's chief marketing officer, Ed Razek. In
2005, for example, Razek was a guest at Epstein's
Manhattan mansion, welcomed by young women
who said they were working as models for Epstein.
Razek told fellow guest William Mook, head of Mok
Industries LLC in Columbus, Ohio, that Victoria's
Secret used Epstein models and that his girls were
in "the major league," according to Mook.
Epstein's relationship with Wexner and L Brands
officially ended in 2007, a year and a half after the financier was charged with several counts of se
misconduct in Florida. He pleaded guilty to
charge and spent just 13 months in prison v
work-release privileges. That penalty was wic
derided as exceedingly lenient and, after sex I
ficking charges against Epstein were resurrecte
July, fresh outrage over the 2007 plea deal le(
the resignation of U.S. Labor Secretary Alex Aco
who'd been the U.S. attorney in Miami in charg
EFTA01699270
■ BUSINESS Bloomberg Busies*** August 5.2019
pI 3
I
I
5 the agency's models were at auditions in 2017 and
2018. They've also posed for its catalogs and web-
site. In a 2014 letter to Brunel, his business part-
ner, MC2 President Jeff Fuller cited worries by Saks,
Nordstrom, Macy's, and other clients about Brunel's
friendship with Epstein. There was no mention of
concern on the part of Victoria's Secret.
MC2 didn't respond to a request for comment.
A representative of L Brands declined to com-
ment beyond statements already issued. L Brands
has hired an external law firm to probe any ties
between the company and Epstein.
Epstein is the ghost of Victoria's Secret's past.
But the company has more to worry about than
history. Its business model is increasingly at odds
with society's changing definition of beauty and the
#MeToo movement, both of which have encour-
aged a very different vision of how to portray
women and their bodies. This isn't just an exercise
in political correctness: Since 2015, Wexner's lin-
gerie empire has lost $20 billion in market value,
raising the question of whether a male-dominated
company that trumpets women as lingerie-clad
"angels" may be out of step with today's consumer.
The chain's founder, Roy Raymond, came up
with the idea of a women's lingerie store aimed at
men after an unfulfilling experience at a depart-
ment store buying his wife some lingerie in the
1970s. He felt there should be a place where men
would be comfortable shopping for women's
underwear. He opened the first Victoria's Secret in
1977. Wexner, already owner of retailers Limited,
Lane Bryant, and Express, bought the company for
Si million in 1982. Through savvy marketing under
Wexner, the brand sold directly to women who
wanted to look sexy in pushup bras and panties.
As the brand grew, it still provided plenty of eye
candy for men—especially in its glittery annual fash-
ion show, which became a marketing coup and a
much-anticipated event for the men who flocked
to it. The first—staged at New York's Plaza Hotel in
1995, the same year real estate developer Donald
Trump was forced to sell the legendary hostelry
to avoid bankruptcy -included model Stephanie
Seymour gliding down the catwalk. Models wore
white and black bras and underwear, but not the
large white angel wings that models in subse-
quent shows would make famous. Over the years
the extravaganza grew with more lights and pop
stars. Supermodels such as Gisele Biindchen and
Tyra Banks graced the stage. As such, it cast a sex-
§ infused spotlight on a utilitarian product our grand-
mothers used to purchase from the Sears catalog.
Plenty of clothing retailers have used sex to
sell. American Apparel's ads of pouty-faced young women in suggestive poses often had the look of
soft porn. And Abercrombie & Fitch's now-defunct
"magalog," A&F Quarterly, was notorious for
including nude models and racy content such as
its 2003 discussion on the pleasures of group sex.
But few retailers have fused themselves to the
notion of sexiness more than Victoria's Secret,
which has spent countless hours making sure the
outside world gets that message. Wexner has never
shown a lot of personal interest in the models for his
brand, according to a former executive. That task
falls to Razek, who's worked for Wexner since the
198os and is part of his inner circle. The 71-year-old
marketing chief and his team decide which models
earn angel wings. GQ has called him one of the most
important people in the modeling industry.
Between tapings of the 2011 fashion show, for
instance, the Victoria's Secret angels would crowd
around Razek as if he were a coach giving a locker
room pep talk before the big game. In a speech
that year to his accPmbled models, which included
Adriana Lima and Alessandra Ambrosio, Razek said
their job is the "most impossible job in the world,
literally in the history of the world. In the history
of the world, as of this show, only 165 women have
ever been in this show," he said to the dozens of
women present. "There have only been 140 pairs of
wings in the entire history of this show. That means
each of you, every one of you, because there are
7 billion people on the planet. Each of you is one
in 45 million human beings. Let's start with that"
But like fashion, times change. Abercrombie
in late 2014 parted ways with longtime CEO Mike
Jeffries, who once famously told Salon magazine
that his chain refused to carry women's clothing
larger than a size 10 "because good-looking people
attract other good-looking people, and we want to
market to cool, good-looking people. We don't mar-
ket to anyone other than that:' The chain has also
dropped its highly sexualized marketing. American
Apparel founder Dov Charney was ousted in 2014
after allegations of sexual harassment, and the
company later filed for bankruptcy.
Likewise, fashion companies are increasingly
embracing a broader definition of beauty. Younger
designers such as Christian Siriano and Becca
McCharen-Tran have added plus-size fashions and
models to their shows. But Victoria's Secret hasn't
strayed much from its uniformly tall, thin angels.
Last November, Razek told Vogue that, after consid-
eration, he'd decided not to use transgender models
in his shows. "Well, why not? Because the show is a
fantasy," he said, sparking some outraged celebrities
and customers to call for his resignation.
Some in the industry say such tone-deafness ► • Victoria's Secret
U.S. market share in
women's urslerwear
36%
az
ze
ze
2010 2018
• Victoria's Secret total
selling square footage
72m
2018
64
2011
ao
5740 5860
Sales per s4 ft
EFTA01699271
■ BUSINESS Bloomberg BusInessweek August 5, 2019
ill may be a result of the 2016 departure of Victoria's
Secret's longtime CEO, Sharen Jester Turney, who'd
guided the brand for a decade while managing to
convince many consumers that its celebration of
the feminine body was a form of female empow-
erment. Turney left because she didn't agree with
the direction Wexner wanted to take the business,
according to a person familiar with their conver-
sations. "With her gone, the men really just took
over," says one former executive. "And these were
men who had one ideal of women, and it's not
based in reality:'
Jan Singer, who replaced Turney, left last year
soon after Razek made comments some plus-size
models and the transgender community found
demeaning. Singer was replaced by a man, leaving
L Brands with only two women among the 10 listed
executive officers and brand leaders. At the urging of
activist investor Barington Capital Group, L Brands
this spring added two more women to its board.
The failure to embrace changing norms about
women and beauty may already be having an
impact on Victoria's Secret's results. After rising
steadily since 2010, sales fell to $7.4 billion in fis-
cal 2017—the first drop in seven years—and edged
slightly lower again last year. Sales at stores open
for more than 12 months, a closely watched met-
ric in retailing, also slipped in 2018, with operating
income at the unit tumbling 45%, to $512.4 million.
Those poor results have led L Brands to tighten
its purse strings, resulting in the shuttering of
dozens of underperforming locations. L Brands
announced in February plans to dose about 53
Victoria's Secrets in North America this year, more
than three times the 15 it's historically closed in an
average year. "Given the decline in performance at
Victoria's Secret, we have substantially pulled back
on capital investment in that business," L Brands
executives said in prepared commentary in May
after reporting a further 5% drop in same-store
sales in 2019's first quarter.
Another notable change: In May, Victoria's
Secret pulled its fashion show from network tele-
vision after 23 years. Ratings bottomed out in 2018,
with only 3.3 million viewers, down from the pre-
vious all-time low of 5 million the year prior. The
annual show is expected to move to streaming.
There may be limits to just how much Victoria's
Secret can change its messaging: American Engle
Outfitters Ink's rival Aerie line has found a base of
passionate customers who are younger and more
diverse and are calling for brands to have body-
inclusive messages. That's helped Aerie log 18 con-
secutive quarters of double-digit same-store sales.
One advantage is that Aerie doesn't have 40 years of branding to overcome. "There's been very
interesting growth in consumers embracing this
more holistic body-image view, but it's probably too
far of a step away from what the DNA of Victoria's
Secret is," says Alex Arnold, a managing direc-
tor of the consumer practice at investment bank
Odeon Capital Group LLC. "It would be a whole-
sale repositioning of the company." -Kim Bhasin,
Jordyn Holman, Sophie Alexander, and Anders Melin
THE BOTTOM LINE Victoria's Secret long prospered by promoting its sexy lingerie. But changing norms about women
and beauty could put that growth at risk.
Selling the
Door-to-Door Rainforest
• By acquiring Avon, Brazil's Natura plans to turn
its army of direct salespeople into online influencers
On a pleasant Tuesday in May, dozens of beauty
influencers gathered at the New York Botanical
Garden in the Bronx for a vegan lunch and a panel
on sustainability in cosmetics. As they sipped pas-
sion fruit caipirinhas, the young women snapped
photos of lotions and soaps featuring exotic ingre-
dients such as murumuru and priprioca.
They're the types of products that made host
Natura Cosmeticos SA a beauty giant in Brazil—
and that the so-year-old company wants to bring
to the rest of the world. With its agreement in May
to buy Avon Products Inc., Natura is accelerating its
global ambitions and betting its brand of natural,
ethically sourced cosmetics will appeal to millen-
nial and Generation 2 consumers who increasingly
want sustainable goods.
The company wants to attract social media
enthusiasts such as Ava Lee a New Yorker who was
at the Bronx event. "I love that all Natura Brasil
products are clean and sustainable," says Lee—
@glowwithava on Instagram—who often posts pho-
tos of cosmetics for her almost 24,000 followers.
"It's hard to come by products that smell this good
and at the same time are very gentle on the skin
and don't cause irritations: .
Natura's $2 billion purchase of Avon—the very
company it had long emulated with its door-to-
door direct-selling model—will make it the world's
fourth-biggest cosmetics company and among the
largest focused on natural products. About 80% "In other
markets,
you see the
movement of
beauty going
into wellness.
In Brazil it
started the
other way
around"
EFTA01699272
■ BUSINESS • Bloomberg Businessweek August s, 2019
, of its products are vegan. The challenge will be
staying loyal to its sustainable roots as it rapidly
grows. Executive Chairman Roberto de Oliveira
Marques says the "value propositions that are the
very essence of Natura" are appealing to consumers,
particularly millennials, who look for "authenticity"
in products and the companies that make them.
Purpose-driven brands resonate more with young
consumers, according to researcher Euromonitor
International. About 60% of millennials responding
to a lifestyle survey said they felt they could make
a difference in the world through their choices and
actions, compared with about 45% of baby boomers.
Founded in 1969 as a store in Sao Paulo, Natura
soon moved to direct sales, adding 2,000 consul-
tants over the next decade. Novelties, such as offer-
ing product refills in the 1980s and a line of soaps
and creams that could be used by both new moms
and babies in the 1990s, fed steady sales growth in
a country obsessed with good looks. But though
Brazilians are leaders in plastic surgery and popu-
larized the infamous Brazilian wax, the national con-
cept of beauty is more natural—think of model Gisele
Bfindchen, with her signature loose hair.
"Natura's broader portfolio, more focused
on wellness as opposed to only beauty, puts it in
a unique position to expand abroad;' says David
Marcotte, a retail analyst with Rantar Consulting.
"In other markets, you see the movement of beauty
going into wellness. In Brazil it started the other way
around. That's the grounding for their success!'
Natura gets 30% of its revenue outside Brazil.
The company began widening its scope in the past
decade, buying a controlling stake in Australian lux-
ury skin-care brand Aesop in 2013 and British soap
maker the Body Shop in 2017. It's taken steps to bring
its sustainable ethos to those brands. Natura brought
the Body Shop's marketing back to the cruelty-free
cause that jump-started the brand in the 19705. It's
also taken the fair-trade model it uses to procure its
ingredients from the Amazon and expanded it to the
African communities that provide moringa oil to the
Body Shop. At Aesop, packaging changes will reduce
plastic consumption by 124 tons per year.
It's unclear how much Natura will transform
Avon, whose sales plunged by half over the past
to years, to $5.25 billion, in fiscal 2018 amid com-
petition from trendier brands. The company had
given up on the U.S., selling the last of its stake in
the American operations earlier this year, to focus
on international markets. But it's still struggled to
adapt to changing consumer tastes.
The Avon acquisition will give the Brazilian com-
pany access to 27 new markets—including in China
and Eastern Europe—as well as greatly expand the direct-sales model, which Natura says it can
modernize and diversify. Marques plans to turn the
combined companies' army of 6 million direct sell-
ers into social media sellers and influencers —who
increasingly drive millennials' cosmetics purchases.
Natura is also giving door-to-door associates pay-
ment machines and helping them open web stores.
"This powerful sales network that gets into consum-
ers' homes already existed of line, and now it's con-
verting itself into an online network," Marques says.
That's in line with industry trends. Elton
Morimitsu, a Euromonitor analyst, says several
brands are "abandoning the use of influencers with
millions of followers;' he says. "They're betting
• Number of direct-
sales associates Nature
will have after Its
purchase of Avon instead on microinfluencers with several thousands
of followers, because the conversion rate into sales
that the brand will have will be much higher!'
Natura doesn't sell only through its consultants;
it's made several brands available in drugstores,
cut deals to sell others at big retailers, and opened
52 proprietary stores, mostly in Brazil, to showcase
its goods. It also has its own virtual store and is using
the network of Body Shop franchisees in Southeast
Asia to open Natura locations there. It has opened
two stores in the New York area, but has no plans
to expand quickly in the U.S., Marques says. Until
that changes, American consumers need to rely on
online shopping and influencers such as Ana Kcira,
whose @fashionstylefoodie on Instagram has about
45,000 followers. She posted a photo of herself
spraying Natura's pataua oil, a hair strengthener,
on a friend's braid in Central Park—which generated
almost 700 likes. —Fabiola Mourn, with riffanyKary
THE BOTTOM UNE Natures natural, ethically sourced cosmetics
have been a hit at home h Brazil. It's aiming for *Mar success
globally. as younger consuners lean toward purpose-ddven brands 6m
EFTA01699273
EFTA01699274
TRAVEL Bloomberg Pursuits August 5, 201
Felix Worn, chief of the Asmat village of Syuru; looked
intimidating in his grass skirt and fur headdress,
bird feathers protruding from the side. A necklace
of sharp animal teeth stretched across his bare,
muscular chest, and his nose held a large curled ring. This
ornament was made of seashell, but in the past it could have
been carved from human bone.
Twelve miles off the sparsely populated south coast of the
Indonesian province of West Papua, Worn sat, unsmiling, for
the fust time on the deck of a cruise ship. The 120-passenger
Coral Adventurer was on an inaugural voyage to West Papua,
which encompasses most of western New Guinea and other
nearby islands, and the ship's captain had invited Worn and a
handful of other village elders onboard to calm any fears about
intruding foreigners. He offered them a look around, hats with
baseball logos, and tins of butter cookies to take home.
"They want to have a peek at us and really want to see
the ship;' says tour lecturer Kathryn Robinson, a retired
anthropology professor at Australian National University
whose research focus includes Indonesia. "If you say no,
because that would make us feel uncomfortable, that doesn't
work.... Hospitality is a big thing in Indonesia."
The chief already understood it—the symbiotic relationship
between locals and visitors. "We can keep our culture because
people come to see it," he said through a translator, acknowl-
edging the importance of the money the cruise line brings to
his village. "We would be very
happy to have more ships coin- .
ingr As I walked away from our
chat, the chief raised his chin,
looked ahead at nothing, and
let out a long rhythmic call.
The Asmat people once
were known as great warriors
who used headhunting and
cannibalism in their warfare,
cultural rituals that ended for good about 60 year ago with
the arrival of the Indonesian government. Photographer and
art collector Michael Rockefeller, one of Nelson's five sons, may
have been a victim of cannibalism after his boat overturned
near an Asmat village in November 1964 according to the book
Savage Harvest, by Carl Hoffman. His body was never found.
The culture lives on in part through performance —which
is how the government likes it, says Stuart Kirsch, a professor
of anthropology at the University of Michigan who specializes
in the Pacific region. "When you're not there, they're wearing
Rolling Stones T-shirts from the global used-clothing market,
cutoff jeans, and worn-out flip-flops," Kirsch says. West Papua
has an independence movement, he says, but "that's typically
scripted out of the tourist narrative:'
Add the navigational difficulties of swirling winds, shallow
seas, shifting sands, and multiple reefs, and it's no wonder trav-
elers seldom stop by. That our diesel-electric vessel was here,
near the equator in the middle of hot nowhere, is a result of •
the expanding market for expedition cruises. Such small-ship Asmat men from.the
village of gyuru arrive
. in canoesio oreat —and I
Intimidate—visitors
travel has drawn particular interest among baby boomers
willing to pay fares that often top $1,000 a night for meaning-
ful soft adventure experiences in hard-to-reach destinations.
In this growing niche of the cruise market, 39 expedition
ships are set to make their debut from now to 2024, accord-
ing to Cruise Industry News. Big cruise companies are dipping
their toes into the lucrative arena. Royal Caribbean Cruises
Ltd. acquired four expedition ships (as well as five ultraluxury
ships) last year when it paid about $1 billion fora two-thirds
stake in Silversea Cruises Ltd. "It probably increased their fleet
capacity by 2% but increased their profit flow by 6%. The profit
per ship is that much higher,"
says Bloomberg Intelligence
senior analyst Brian Egger.
Most of the new boats are
polar-class vessels bound for
popular cold places such as
Antarctica, Iceland, Greenland,
and the Canadian High Arctic.
But other cruises are sticking to
the tropics. As a result, some of
the most isolated people on Earth are seeing more visitors.
Wom's village of Syuru, with its rustic houses and board-
walks crossing the swamp, will welcome four shiploads of
cruisers this year, a number agreed upon by the government
and tribal representatives. Timing is important in the expe-
dition business: The May itinerary of our round-trip cruise
from Darwin, Australia, was tweaked so we could beat a ship
owned by French line Ponant SA by a day.
We arrived early in the morning after two sea days churn-
ing north from Darwin. Passengers boarded the ship's two
hop-on, hop-off tenders and passed mangroves along a brack-
ish river on our way to the village. As we approached, dug-
out canoes from several clans emerged from shore. Athletic
men and young boys paddled from a standing position, most
in grass skirts, their faces and bodies covered with war paint,
which assures the warriors their,ancestors will protect them.
Men reached for the sides of our boats. Paddles thumped
against wood in unison with war cries. "They are perform-
ing themselves as violent people;' Robinson said. "They are i "It's like anywhere
where people are performing
their culture. It can be
uncomfortable, but it can also
promote mutual recognition"
EFTA01699275
TRAVEL Bloomberg Pursuits August 5,2019
saying, 'This is who we are!" If they were trying to look scary,
they succeeded with me, especially as the flotilla increased
to dozens of canoes.
Onshore, men performed a traditional ceremony to launch
a new canoe. It was a frenzy of hip-swinging dancing, raised
spears and shields, chanting, yelping, and drumming. Women
in grass skirts, some topless, danced in support. Passengers
stood on the edge of the ceremony, the action only some-
what diluted by some of the villagers holding cellphones.
They were taking pictures of us, as we were of them. And
what a sight we were in our "adventure" wear, sun hats, and
sunglasses, slathered in sunscreen and bug spray. I hadn't
thought of myself as a cultural attraction, but locking eyes
with a half-naked elderly woman, I realized we both were
probing another world. I felt oin of place in this one.
Cruisers pulled out rupiah to purchase Asmat art, which
is sought by museums and collectors around the world.
(Rockefeller was seeking pieces for the Metropolitan Museum
of Art's collection of primitive works when he disappeared.)
The art traditionally tells the stories of ancestors, but when I
picked up a figurine for about Us-some works went for quite
a bit more—and asked about its symbolism, the shy artist said
it was just something he imagined.
Oswald Huma, a tour agent from the island of Savu, west
of Timor, was hired by Coral Expeditions, based in Cairns,
Australia, to help map out our "Warriors and Wildlife" itin-
erary. He said the most common question the villagers ask
is, "Why do these people come to see us?" He struggles with
the answer, usually replying that travelers want to buy the
wood carvings. He doesn't want to mention the attraction of
a history of headhunting.
Robinson says the interactions bring much-needed income.
y.
DONES1/9.-Mpik
Sangliat Dol
Iria;saps *sae' She's noticed that, since she first visited the Asmat a few years
ago, conditions seem to have improved. "The way I see it, for
these people who are miles away from any of the circuits of
capital, tourism is helping them to realize that they do have
something the world will buy, which is their culture," she says.
"We might have anxieties about it. But all through Indonesia,
people hope that tourism is going to bring income into these
remote areas. These people are separate from the exigencies
of the world. Pristine and untouched has also got its negatives!"
The visits also provide the Asmat an opportunity to prac-
tice their culture, Huma says. Elders traditionally teach youth
the group's customs by performing ceremonies; paying cus-
tomers are an excuse to do so. Kids also see the outside world
and have an opportunity to practice English, "so they can go
out and seek employment and send money home;' he says.
"It's like anywhere where people are performing their cul-
ture," says Kirsch, the Michigan professor. "It can be uncom-
fortable, but it can also promote mutual recognition. The
Asmat are well known for their art, and these encounters can
stimulate appreciation for the artistic style!'
Agats, a larger town we visited nearby, has imported goods
for sale to locals. Among them are rice, which isn't a staple
of the Asmat diet but has become popular, as well as electric
motorbikes, tea, sugar, and cellphones. Given the spotty signal,
the phones are mostly used as cameras and for playing music.
Huma had spent months in his boat on the Arafura Sea
south of West Papua, sometimes in rough seas, convincing
leaders in remote villages to welcome the Coral Adventurer.
He also arranged for English speakers to meet us at each of
four stops. Many are teachers, and some traveled far for the
jobs as guides.
In the village of Sangliat Dcl, on Yamdena Island in the ►
WEST PAPUA
rT:\
Argun' & Ando metal,*
akor ay
V
4Triton Bay
iii
EFTA01699276
$
Bloomberg Pursuits August 5,2019
1 ,..."4231113027.a:&34 -
Check out these other adventure cruises,
priced per person, double occupancy.
Antarctica on
Quark Expeditions'
Ultramarine
Debuting in late 2020,
Ouark's.Polar ship—
complete with two • twth-engine choppers
todrop you off for
heal-skiing—will explore
Antarctica Prices
hot yet evell0510:
quarkexpeditlehscom Arctic Spring on the
National Geographic
Endurance
Sailings in April tv Don
Undblad Expeditions
126-guest ship bring you
to Nonvays Svalbard
arthipaiago Just at the
ight is starting to return
and the polar bears
are waking up. ti-day
sailing (rein '$t1600.
sveditionstom Galapagos on the
Sliver Origin
Purpose-built by
%Iversea Cruises for
tripi to the Gahipagos
starting in July 2020.
SiWer Origin will pro-
vide a posh floating
base camp for visiting
Da reeffs finchesaexl
blue-footed boobies.,
Seven-daysailings from
$9459 avirseacon1Greenland and
Iceland on the
Scenic Eclipse
This 'Discovery Yachtr
debuting this summer
for Australian-owned
Scenic, has a sub-
marine and two heli-
copters for exploring
glaciers and fiords,
plus other toys.11-dey
cruises Item $12,295;
scenicusecom The Kimberley on
the Coral Adventurer
Red cliffs, ancient
rock art, towering
waterfalls, and salt-
water crocodiles all
turn up on April-
through-September
sails around Western
Australia remote
northern coast. l0-day
onuses from $7.024
corelexpeditions.com
41 province °Maluku, the push.and pull of multiculture life
was magnified. During a one-hour bus ride beforehand, our
guide said, "Visitors are rare, ask destroys the daily life."
We were met by an enthusiastic crowd of costumed women
in embroidered white peasant blouses and sarongs. Some had
arrived hours-earlier from nearby villages to greet us with a
dance in which they waved scarves and small towels. They wel-
comed us as "sons and daughters of the village."
A smiling older woman grabbed my arm, and to the accom-
paniment of druths and singing, the crowd danced past tin-
roofed homes to a megalithic ceremonial stone boat in the
village center. Shouting, shoving, even screaming ensued, and
cruise passengers were hustled off to the side.
Seating in the boat is based on status, but it can be con-
tested. A man had taken a position someone else felt was his.
Government officials moved the arguing men out of view so
a smaller group could perform a planned ceremony honor-
ing our ship "elders."
The fight—with yelling and shoving—was the rawest experi-
ence of our cruise. But for the locals, there was a price to be
paid. A government official threatened to file a report, say-
ing there would be consequences. Our ship withheld bags of
school supplies, soccer balls, and clean sheets and towels for
the health clinic, similar to gifts we'd delivered to other villages.
The donations to'Sangliat Dol returned with us. "We don't
know when we left the village if they would fight over a soc-
cer ball," Huma said. "We don't want a bad thing to happen."
No one on the Coral Adventurer, not even the cap-
tain, had sailed the West Papua itinerary before, a route
designed to mimic a portion. of Dutch explorer Abel Tasman's
lenders ferry
pastengers to
isolated beaches
along the coast voyage roughly 375 years ago. Coral Expeditions, a 35-year-
old company owned since 2O14 by Kallang Capital Holdings
Pte. of Singapore, is known more for its cruises of Australia
ICirnberley region and the Great Barrier Reef.
When you commit to an expedition cruise to a remote
locale, you can expect long days at sea getting there. Wi-Fi
connections are sporadic, and there's no satellite TV. Lectures
are the main shipboard activity. A marine biologist prepared
us for the world's largest fish, whale sharks—who apparently
didn't get the memo about our arrival. We looked for them
without success in Triton Bay in the southwest corner of West
Papua. The passengers, mostly Australians over-6o, relaxed
onboard in modern cabins and lounge areas accented with
African wood and Italian marble. Hot water flowed from
showers, cappuccinos from coffee machines. Dinner was a
three-course affair, with Australian wines.
It was sticky and hot when we explored the tidy dirt streets
of the Muslim village of Arguni (population 227), in the Fakfak
regional district. Women, their heads covered, and their
grandchildren offered warm but cautious smiles. Most of the
village's adults were as far away as Bali and Jakarta for work
or study. Although it was Ramadan, women had risen early
to prepare fish dishes and cakes made of tapioca.
"You are not tourists anymore, but part of our family;'
King Hanafi Paus Paus told the crowd. Later, in his small
house, where the front room is furnished with plastic patio
chairs and the walls are decorated with photographs of his
forbears, the king said tourism is improving. Another ship
had arrived five months ago. Ships have a "good effect," he
said through a translator. "It protects the history, plus we get
money. People leave for work, and now work comes to us."
The king's two sons are in high school in the town of Fakfak
about 3O miles away. He goes there in his boat, then uses a
car he keeps in town to get around.
In all the villages, locals attempted a few words of English,
and there was a warmth and sincerity to our encounters —even
if most amounted to us staring at them and them staring at us.
Ngilngof village, on Kai Kecil Island, provided the welcome
that felt most linked with the outside world: Women in bright
purplejackets and long gold skirts danced with delicate hand
movements as a ritual leader in black raised a coconut, invok-
ing ancestral protection for the island's natural resources.
Meanwhile, on a 3-mile-long beach with soft, white sand, plas-
tic chairs were s'et up under a tent you could rent for the after-
noon. Snack bars sold cold beers and Diet Cokes. 0
EFTA01699277
EFTA01699278
BIKES Bloomberg Pursuits July 29, 2019
0 n Valentine's Day, Sharry Billings posted a
photograph on Instagram. Below the image of
herself, her hair a red-caramel and her smile
open, she wrote: "I love you so much I wanna
squeeze you!"
The object of her affection? "All the motorcycles I have
owned and will own in the future," she explained. Alongside
the photo of her astride a Harley-Davidson, she wrote that
bikes "have changed my life, healed my soul, and brought me
more love and friendships than I could have ever imagined r
Billings goes.by @sistermotherl3 on Instagram, but the
main account she oversees is @thelitaslosangeles. The Litas
is a group she joined three years ago as a way to connect with
other women riders in her city. She's co-led the L.A. branch
for two years. When she joined, it provided her with much-
needed healing and Camaraderie after her kids grew up and
she got divorced. Billings had ridden as a teenager and into
her 20s but took a hiatus later. "It was always in my heart,"
she says. But when she was married with young children, "I
thought it was a little too dangerous?'
' After the breakup in 2015, she found herself longing for
escape. And adventure. "My prayer at the time was, 'God, I
don't want to date: These men are not happening," Billings
says, laughing. "The first thing that came to 'my heart was the
motorcycle I wanted. It was a Harley." night pizza runs, say, or weekend coffee meetups—and they
take periodic excursions to women-only destination events
such as the Wild Gypsy Tour, which is organizing a festival in
Sturgis, S.D., in August, and the Dream Roll in Ashland, Ore.
The biggest crowd follows Babes Ride Out, a series of
events founded by Anya Violet and Ashmore Ellis in 2013. It
started with so women riders who gathered to camp out in
Borrego Springs, Calif. They built fires, pitched tents, drank
beer, and played games on Harleys, Husqvamas, and Hondas
while soaking in nature and one another's company.
These groups are tapping into an undercurrent of the
motorcycle industry. As sales have faltered, dropping more
than 4o% from 2008 to 2010, then recovering somewhat by
2014 but never to previous levels, manufacturers including
Harley-Davidson Inc. and BMW Motorrad have struggled to
create appeal beyond their core demographic of older white
men. Their efforts include offering electric and less-expensive
motorbikes and introducing exciting conceptual prototypes.
Female riders offer enthusiasm and youth, and, yes, they're
spending money that brands crave.
The number of women who own motorcycles has almost
doubled since 2010, according to a 2018 study by the Motorcycle
Industry Council. Today, 19% of owners are women, up from
10% in 2009 and 8% in the late 19905. And the number of female
riders gets higher as you go younger: 22% of Generation X
While the industry on the whole dropped
40% from 2008 to 2010, the amount of women who
own motorcycles has almost doubled
She bought the bike, took the ride. Then she joined the
Litas. "I'm very grateful to have found my heart again,"
Billings says.
Founded in Utah byJessica Haggett half a decade ago, the
Litas have expanded to include hundreds of branches around
the world (Litas Denver, Litas Lisbon, Litas Rome?, with
members ranging from twentysomething singles to 6o-and
70-year-old retirees with EA-maids. They take regular rides,
often along wild back roads, including the Pine Mountain
Ridge route near Ojai, Calif., that Billings took with 32 other
riders one Saturday in July. It's about riding with your own
style and pace but surrounded by like-minded friends.
"If you're learning to ride, you're going to kill yourself rid-
ing with men—they ride like bats out of hell!" Billings says.
"And women—I'm generalizing here—tend to be more careful.
We are mothers, we are sisters, we feel obligated to stay alive."
The Litas are singular but not uncommon. All across
California, Oregon, and Utah, from Texas to New York, women-
only motorcycle groups and riding events are springing up
like wildflowers. They go by names such as the Miss-Fires
(Brooldyn, N.Y.), the Chrome Divas (Austin), and Leather and
Lace (Daytona Beach, Fla.). They do regular rides: Tuesday riders are women, and 26% of millennial riders are women.
What's more, the average woman who owns a motorcycle
spends $574 annually on maintenance, parts, service, and
accessories, while the average man who rides spends $497.
"We are riding a ton," says Joy Lewis, who started when
she was 12. "I have a friend who put 20,000 miles on her bike
in one year." Lewis's father, an Alaskan crab fisherman who
owned a Harley, got her hooked. 'e spend a lot of money
on our gear and our bikes, and a lot of things to go with them.
I think that's starting to be appreciated?'
Andy Jefferson, a spokesman for Husqvarna, says one of
the brand's priorities must be to provide support for wom-
en's motorcycling. "We were like everyone else—going after a
piece of the pie;' he says. "But everyone was looking at men,
and there are all these other people-women-that nobody
even really talks about in conversations about how to sell
more bikes" The brand lacks figures for how many of its own-
ers are women but is "working to change thatflefferson says.
"That's part of the problem:' • .
Husqvarna honed in on women riders five years ago when
it started sponsoring Babes in the Dirt, an offshoot of Babes
Ride Out that's more focused on off-road and dirt-bike riding.
EFTA01699279
COLOR ADO MO NTAIN HAT COMPANY -
Last year the company spent $50,000 to $60,000 in support of the three-day rally, lending 27 motorcycles and nine staff- ers to service the bikes and teach. "We counted between So and too girls out there (trying out] Husqvarnas; he says. "The number is nor huge by any means, but those are too people we didn't have before. It alio jumps down to their brothers and sisters and kids. We never would lave got these people without doing this!' But more important, "we want to get you to ride a motor- cycle," Jefferson adds. "If you ride with Babes and have fun • and go buy another brand, great. We just want people riding' At BMW Motoriad, which on July I named Trudy Hardy vice president for the Americas, the company is sponsor- ing women-only events including the Sisters' Centennial Motorcycle Ride. It's also covering travel expenses and appearance fees for brand reps such as Elspeth Beard, an architect who was the first British woman to ride her motorcycle around the *odd. The brand also sends pro racer Jocelia Snow and Erin Sills, who holds a 242 mph land speed record, to-attend events at local dealerships. Harley-Davidson has expanded its retail line in recent years to include a host of riding jackets; helmets, boots, and gloves size.d ancl styled for women. It's perhaps the most critical field of growth for the n6-year-old Wisconsin brand, which has seen sales steadily decline since 2014. The average age of a Harley owner is so. The average price of one is $15,800—more than tunny mifiennials will spend on a car, let alone a motorcycle. "Even just in the last five years the conversation has shifted," says motorcycle aficionado Lewis. "I'm sitting here in leather Kevlar paths as we speak, about to go into a Rkiterilsuilor
winftudYrire9)ri
1,101401n .Soeica4 kneWiti Oyissi Tour
meeting. Not only are companies making cute technical stuff thatyou could wear to work—rather than some weird leather pants with pink embroidery all over the butt that you'd never wear—they're making things we can actually. user Attendees at events for Babes Ride Out (or BRO, the ironic abbreviation they've adopted) come to America from as far away as Sweden and South America.-Some have rid- den since they could walk; some can't operate a bike at all, preferring always to be a passenger and imbibe the inspi- rational atpxosphere. There's always plenty of denim and leather on-site—but the hipster kind, not the leather-daddy look. Local shops give clastes on basic bike maintenance. Some women get tattoos to commemorate the experience. "People camp, and there are trailers, toO," Lewis says. "The idea is that you grab coffee and breakfast, and then during the day everyone is out tiding. And then all the stuff happens in the evenings with bands.or karaoke and show rated"—feats of throttle control. • Earlier this year, a g6-year-old woman joined them at camp; she'd first ridden cross-county on her motorcy- cle TS years ago: Last summer the annual California desert meetup SAW 1,700 women ride in Yucca Valley; 500 attended an East Coast campout in- the Catslail Mountains in New York; 700 attended the most recent Babes in the Dirt in Lebec, Calif. "Maybe people think that women who ride are pretty tough and badass, which it probably true, but all in all, women riders come in all shapes, sizes, colors, and lifestyles, so any label that you wantto.give them does not really work," co-founder Violet says, tan honestly say that there is no 'type' ...andwe like it that way!" 0 Ti
EFTA01699280
Bloomberg Bustnessweek -Puy 15.2019
4
E
C
0
N
M
C
S
Edited by
Style 101Ingsworth When
Mother
Earth
Gives You
A Building
Permit • AMLO's passion project is a
900-mile train to connect bead
resorts and colonial-era towns
One day last December, Mexican President Andrt
Manuel Lopez Obrador donned a beaded necklac
and bowed his head reverently before a fire pit, t
ask Mother Earth for permission to build a railroa
through the heart of Mayan territory.
The line, which will stretch 1,460 kilometer
(goo miles) across five Mexican states, may cart
more than 8,000 passengers a day. It will serve som
of the country's most popular tourist destination:
including seaside resorts Cancfm and Tulum, Mend
and other colonial-era towns, and archaeologic
sites like Chichen Itza. For AMLO, as Mexico's lead(
is widely known, the Mayan Train is something c
a passion project. Critics call it an expensive folly.
Rusty railways dating to the iggos cover les
than half of the proposed route, but they'll have t
be completely overhauled to handle modern rol
ing stock. That's the easy part. To lay track alon
the rest of the route, construction crews will hay
to cut through miles of rainforest, home to jaguar:
which are endangered in Mexico, and pumas.
The most difficult part of the undertaking ma
be finding investors to finance the project's cost
as much as 160 billion pesos (about $7.9 billion
AMLO's government hasn't specified how it cam
up with that number, nor has it commissioned
study to prove there will be sufficient passenger an
cargo volume to make the line commercially viabli
The agency in charge of the endeavor, Fonatur, ha
described the Mayan Train as a "social" projec
whose main goal is boosting the economy of th
Yucatan Peninsula by way of hotel construction an
tourism. "What we're looking for is for the town
along the train's routes to be profitable, and tha
goes beyond how many tourists use the train;' say
Aaron Rosado, the Yucatan liaison at Fonatur, th
national fund for tourism promotion. The mediai
household income across the five states is half tha
of the capital, Mexico City. Chiapas, one of the state
on the route, is the country's poorest, according t.
statistics agency Inegi.
"It would be a huge mistake to plan this poorly,
says Alexandra Zapata, adjunct director at Mexico'
Competitiveness Institute, IMCO, a think tank tha
studies the impact of policy on the Mexican econ
omy. "There's a profound difference between bei
Ling on regional development and ending up witl
an abandoned ghost project because it cost 10 time
more than what was originally thought:'
EFTA01699281
■ ECONOMICS Bloomberg Bus,nessweek Juty 15.2019
Fonatur opened bidding for engineering work
on the Mayan Train in May. The tender elicited
enough questions from interested yet confused par-
ties to fill a 253-page document. The session sched-
uled to respond to those queries had to be delayed
a month to allow Fonatur enough time to come up
with answers. "Look, I'm not against the train,"
says Eduardo Ramirez, president of the Mexican
Chamber of the Construction Industry. "But they
need to prove this is economically feasible and that
it won't be a burden for future administrations. We
can't keep absorbing governments' mistakes—it's
always the Mexican people who end up paying."
Fonatur chief Rogelio Jimenez Pons told
Bloomberg in February that "a group of too of
Lopez Obrador's closest friends" has funded stud-
ies that contain traffic projections, but his agency
"can't share them just yet."
The Mayan Train's current estimates put its
per-kilometer cost at $5.2 million, on par with
France's Valence-Marseille route, the sixth-lowest
among 22 lines worldwide that IMCO studied. "It's
not clear how they got to that number," Zapata
says. "But what is clear is that international expe-
rience shows these projects—even when they're
perfectly planned—tend to end up costing as much
as 130% more."
The only other passenger train that's being built
in Mexico will connect the capital to the nearby
industrial town of Toluca. Started under former
President Enrique Pefia Nieto, it's been beset by
problems, including lacking the right of way in
some parts. The line was supposed to be up and AMLO's Mayan Train Project
o Station
• Cabkraut Biosphere Rosen.
/ Existing rainy
&Alfa
Maim
ns.ircArcega
Palenpue
Tenosatstecl .Cancun
Maus Izemel
Vagadolid Puerto Morelos
Chkhon0O-CL Playa del Carmen
Itza cowl
Tulum (./
Guatemala Ci Rape Carnikt Puerto
.........
') I Caribbean
sea
t00
running in early 2018, but today there's still no start
date in sight and costs are running 92% over budget.
Its price tag has grown to $66 million per kilometer,
IMCO says, making it the third-most-expensive line
in its study. "You'd think the Mexican government
would learn from this, but apparently they're head-
ing in the same direction;' Zapata says.
Pefia Nieto's administration also studied the idea
of building a train in the southeast. It would have
been about five times smaller, but ultimately the
administration shelved the project when oil prices
fell and the federal budget took a hit.
AMLO's government is looking to fund 90% of
the Mayan Train through a so-called Fibra-a hybrid
of a master limited partnership and a real estate
investment trust. This is the same vehicle that was
I used to fund part of the $13 billion cost of building
a new airport for Mexico City, a project the presi-
dent canceled late last year, triggering a sell-off in
Mexican bonds, stocks, and the peso.
Environmentalists have voiced concerns about
the impact a project this size will have on the
region's fragile ecosystem. The proposed route
is home to an estimated 800 to 1,200 jaguars, an
already endangered species, according to Panthera,
a New York-based nonprofit focused on the conser-
vation of wildcats.
To allow the animals to roam freely, the govern-
ment is considering building large overpasses along
sections of the track, likely modeled on those built
in Canada's Banff National Park for grizzly bears,
beavers, and other big mammals. It's unclear if the
current budget for the Mayan Train includes money
for any overpasses; the Canadian structures cost
as much as $2 million each, according to Mircea
Hidalgo, a member of Panthera Mexico's scientific 10-AMLO (standing
center) a
📷 Images in this document (25 detected; 6 largest described)
AI-generated factual descriptions of embedded images (llava:13b). These are searchable across the corpus.
[Image 1] The image appears to be a scanned document, possibly a newspaper or magazine article. The text at the top reads "What to catch, help you find them." Below this headline is a photograph of a person holding a fishing rod, with a boat and water in the background. The text at the bottom of the image includes the names "The Eryndor" and "Nathan Vance." The document is dated "1998" and mentions "The Ery
[Image 2] The image shows a newspaper page with an article titled "Meanwhile, Back at the Ranch." The article appears to be about a fishing trip or vacation at a ranch. There are several photographs accompanying the article, depicting different scenes:
1. A cozy interior room with a fireplace and a dining table.
2. A scenic outdoor view with a river and mountains in the background.
3. A rustic wooden cabin
[Image 3] The image is a photograph of a printed newspaper page. The visible text includes headlines, articles, and various sections with different fonts and sizes. There are no visible names, dates, places, or logos that can be described confidently. The content of the articles is not clear due to the resolution and angle of the photograph. The newspaper appears to be a standard format with columns of text
[Image 4] The image shows a printed newspaper article. The article is titled "New Jersey's High-Tech Project" and is authored by "The Star-Ledger." The text discusses a project related to New Jersey's technology industry. There is a map included in the article, which appears to be a map of New Jersey, highlighting a specific area related to the project. The map is partially visible, showing a section of the
[Image 5] The image appears to be a photograph from a newspaper, showing a group of people on a street. There are individuals standing and sitting, some of whom are wearing motorcycle gear, suggesting they may be part of a motorcycle club or group. The setting looks like a small town or rural area, with a building in the background that has a sign that reads "Golden Eagle." The photograph is accompanied by
[Image 6] The image is a photograph of a newspaper page. On the page, there is a headshot of a woman with a smiling expression. She has long hair and is wearing a dark top. The newspaper contains text, which includes headlines, articles, and possibly advertisements. The visible text includes the name "Charles" and the word "Amazon." The style of the image is a straightforward photograph of a printed page, c